act of beasts - Uniwersytet Przyrodniczo

Zeszyty Naukowe UNIWERSYTETU PRZYRODNICZO-HUMANISTYCZNEGO w SIEDLCACH
Nr 100
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!
2014
dr !"#$%&'!"()*+
Uniwersytet Przyrodniczo-Humanistyczny w Siedlcach
Wydzi !"# $%"&%'(')*+,(-+h i Prawnych
Problem kons,*,-(*./01(2%,)"3%ustawy o bestiach
The constitutionality problem of the „act of beasts”
Streszczenie: !"#$%&'($%) *+,-./!(.) *&0.-.) ') 1($.) 22) /$&0!#.1.) 2345) 67) !) #!&08#!waniu wobec osób z zaburzeniami psychicznymi, &0-.6'.9:+;+,) '.<6!=%($%) =;+$.>)
zdrowia /*?)-!/(!"+$)&%@&*./(%9)$((;+,)!&A?)?*1'$)-$%/%)-:0#/$-!"+$ prawnych. Wska'.B)(./%=;)#6'%1%)-&';&0@$C)(.)C!=/$-!"B)(.6*&'%($.)#6'%')*&0.-8)@!(&0;0*+;9(%9)'a&.1;)1%[email protected];+'(%<!)#.D&0-.)#6.-(%<!7
4$0"!%+5-()0"#6%nadzór prewencyjny, , . / "01'0'1+2 3('4+*5
Abstract: The act voted in day 22 November 2013, about procedure concerning persons with mental disturbances who could threaten life, health or sexual freedom of other
persons, many legal doubts wakes up. First of all, it is supposed that the act breaks constitutional principle of the legal state.
Keywords: preventive supervision, the principle of proportionality.
6"/(*$"77".8-+,(* "79:;"15"<=.,! "<">-+*="$.8 < ","77"3*.8'0 / "79:?"15"
'"0'.8@0'< (*$"<'A=+"'.BA",", A$1,=(* )*"0.-+C*+,(-)*, .8< 1, 2D+-+C",a1
E1'>=(*=">-+* F",/1'<* "3$A"<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2"*((-+C"'.BA – bardzo szybko
'%1,-%(*@8 " 01,=," )=/* " 8,<5" G$.8 <D '" A=.8* +CH5" I1 +=" ( /" 01,=/)*'8'<D"
$.8 <D", *(*+2'< (=" ,'.8 !-" <"/$>=2")*=1,="0=1.0=%8-<D"<-24+* "( "<'3('4J"
'.BAF"%8B1="01,=/":KLK"15",'.8 !-".% , (="( "% 1@"4)*=1+*F" "%8B1-)"( ")'+-"
)(=.8**",":KLK"15"% 1 "8 ",'.8 ! ", )*=(*'( "( "% 1@"7M"3 8"0',A <*=nia wol2
('4+* 5"N0!-<"'1,=+,'(=2"% 1-F" "+'", "8-)"*/,*="%'(*=+"*,'3 +2*"8-+C"'.BA",a+,@8'"0'.81,=E J"2 %'"1= 3(=", E1'>=(*="/3 ".0'!=+,=O.8< 5"P/ ('".'A*="2=d('+,=4(*=" .01 <@F" *>" *.8(*=2D+=" 1=E$3 +2=" (*=" .D" <-.8 1+, 2D+=" /3 " '+C1'(-"
.0'!=+,=O.8< " *" %'(*=+,(=" 2=.8" 0'/2@+*=" ('<-+CF" ( /,<-+, 2(-+C" 41'/%B<"
01 <(-+C5"&Q=%8=)"0'/2@8-+C"01 +"2=.8"01,=/)*'8'< "$.8 < 5
6-+C'/,D+" ( 01,=+*<" .-E( 3*,'< (-)" , E1'>=(*')" $.8 < " 'A2@! "
.<'*)", %1=.=)"'.'A-".0=!(* 2D+="!D+,(*="( .8@0$2D+="01,=.! (%*R
:S"'/A-< 2D"01 <')'+(*="'1,=+,'(D"% 1@"0',A <*=(* "<'3('4+*"3$A"% 1@"7M"
lat 0',A <*=(* "<'3('4+*F"<-%'(-< (D"<".-.8=)*="8=1 0=$8-+,(-)F
7S" <" 81 %+*=" 0'.8@0'< (* " <-%'( <+,=E'" <-.8@0'< !-" $" (*+C" , A$1,=(* "
psychiczne <" 0'.8 +*" $0'43=/,=(* " $)-.!'<=E'F" , A$1,=(* " '.'A'<'4+*"
lub zaburzenia preferencji seksualnych,
?S" .8<*=1/,'(=" $" (*+C" , A$1,=(* " 0.-+C*+,(=" ) 2D" 8 %*" +C 1 %8=1" 3$A" 8 %*="
nasilenie, >=", +C'/,*"+'"( 2)(*=2"<-.'%*="01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'"0'0=!(*e1
Dz.U. z 2014 r. poz. 24.
T<+,=.(-" %'/=%." % 1(-" (*=" 01,=<*/-< !" % 1-" /'>-<'8(*=E'" 0',A <*=(* " <'3('4+*U"
zob. ustawa Kodeks karny z dnia 19 kwietnia 1969 r. (Dz.U. z 1969 r. Nr 13, poz. 94).
2
2$3!4&5"$3-067
110
nia czynu , A1'(*'(=E'","$>-+*=)"01,=)'+-"3$A"E1'VAD"2=2"$>-+* "01,=+*w%'" >-+*$F,/1'<*$" 3$A" <'3('4+*" .=%.$ 3(=2F" , E1'>'(=E'" % 1D" 0',A <*=(* "
3
<'3('4+*F której górna granica wynosi co najmniej 10 lat (art. 1 ustawy) .
PE'/(*=","$.8 <D, 2=43*"<"81 %+*="0'.8@0'< (* "<-%'( <+,=E'"( "0'dstawie opinii psychiatrycznej i psychologicznej ustalone zostanie zaistnienie
0'<->.,-+C"01,=.! (=%"<".8'.$(%$"/'"%'(%1=8(=E'"'. /,'(=E'F"/-1=%8'1",a%! /$" % 1(=E'" A@/,*=" )$.* !" <-.8D0*J d'" <! 4+*<=E'" .D/$" ," <(*'.%*=)"
o $,( (*="8 %*=2"'.'A-F", "'.'A@".8< 1, 2D+D", E1'>=(*="W 185"K"$.8 <-S5 6!a4+*<-"/3 "01'< /,=(* "0'.8@0'< (* "A@/,*="'%1@E'<-".D/"+-<*3(-"'1,=% 2D+-"
w .%! /,*=" 81,=+C" .@/,*B<" , <'/'<-+C5" I'.8@0'< (*=" A@/,*=" .*@" 8'+,-J"
zgodnie z zasadami procedury cywilnejw trybie nieprocesowym (art. 2 ustawy).
W celu ustalenia, czy osoba, której dotyczy wniosek, wykazuje zaburzenia, .D/"<"8=1)*(*="X"/(*"'/"/(* "'81,-) (* "<(*'.%$F"0'<'! "/<B+C"A*=E!-+C"
3=% 1,-" 0.-+C* 81B<F" <" .01 < +C" '.BA" ," , A$1,=(* )*" '.'A'<'4+*" 0'( /8'"
A*=E!=E'"0.-+C'3'E F" "<".01 < +C"'.BA"," , A$1,=(* )*"01=Q=1=(+2*".=%.$ lnych – ponadto A*=E!=E'" 3=% 1, " .=%.$'3'E " 3$A" +=18-Q*%'< (=E'" 0.-+C'3'E "
seksuologa (art. 11 ustawy).
PE'/(*="," 185":7"$.8 <-".D/ ,"$1,@/$ $.8 ('<*"1B<(*=>"0=!(')'+(*% "
'.'A-F"%8B1=2"/'8-+,-" <(*'.=%F"2=>=3*"(*=") "'( "0=!(')'+(*% "A@/D+=E'" d<'% 8=)"3$A"1 /+D"01 <(-m, ustanowionego z wyboru.
6" 81 %+*=" 01'< /,'(=E'" 0'.8@0'< (* " .D/" /'%'( " '+=(-F" +,-" / ( "
'.'A "<"/ 3.,-)"+*DE$".8< 1, ", E1'>=(*="/3 ".0'!=+,=O.8< "*"+,- konieczne
2=.8", .8'.'< (*="<'A=+"(*=2"2=/(=E'","/<$"01,=<*/,* (-+C"$.8 <D"41'/%B<F"
tj. nadzoru prew=(+-2(=E'" 3A'"$)*=.,+,=(*="2=2"<"Y1 2'<-)"Z41'/%$"P 0'4
biegania Zachowaniom Dyssocjalnym 5"[*=1,="01,-"8-)"0'/"$< E@"+ !'%.,8 !8"
'%'3*+,('4+*" $.8 3'(-+C" <" .01 <*=F" " <" .,+,=EB3('4+*" $,-.% (=" '0*(*=" A*eE!-+CF" "8 %>="<-(*%*"01'< /,'(=E'"/'8-+C+, ."0'.8@0'<ania terapeutyczneE'"'1 ,")'>3*<'4J"=Q=%8-<(=E'"0'// (* ".*@"01,=,"8@"'.'A@"0'.8@0'< (*$"8e1 0=$8-+,(=)$"( "<'3('4+*5
I'"01,=01'< /,=(*$"1',01 <-".D/"<-/ "0'.8 ('<*=(*="'"$,( (*$"'.oA-" , " .8< 1, 2D+D" , E1'>=(*=" *" , .8'.'< (*$" <'A=+" (*=2" ( /,'1$" 01=<=(+-j-
3
N.8 < "/'8-+,-", 8=)", A$1,'(-+C"0.-+C*+,(*=".01 <+B<"( 2E1'V(*=2.,-+C"01,[email protected]<F"< .8'.$(%$"/'"%8B1-+C"A1 %"A-!'"0'/.8 <"'1,=+,=(* "41'/% ", A=,0*=+, 2D+eE'"<"0'.8 +*"$)*=.,+,=(* "<".,0*8 3$"0.-+C* 81-+,(-)F"E/->"<"+, .*="0'0=!(*enia [email protected]< " A-3*" + !%'<*+*=" 3$A" +,@4+*'<'" 0'+,-8 3(*5" \,@4J" 8-+C" .01 <+B<" <" / 3.,-)"
+*DE$" .8 ('<*" , E1'>=(*=" /3 " .0'!=+,=O.8< F" 0'(*=< >" <-.8@0$2D" $" (*+C" .0=+-Q*+,(="
, A$1,=(* "'.'A'<'4+*"3$A", A$1,=(* "01=Q=1=(+2*".=%.$ 3(-+C5"]=E'"1'/, 2$", A$1,enia, zgodnie z )*@/,-( 1'/'<D" %3 .-Q*% +2D" +C'1BA" *" 01'A3=)B<" ,/1'<'8(-+C" ^\_-10,
(*=".8 ('<*D"+C'1'A-"0.-+C*+,(=2F" 3=".D".%3 .-Q*%'< (="<"0'/E1$0 +C"`a9-F62 (zabu1,=(* " '.'A'<'4+*S" * w 0'/E1$0*=" `aM" W, A$1,=(* " 01=Q=1=(+2*" .=%.$ 3(-+CS" 0'<'! (=2"
klasyfikacji; zob. uzasadnienie do projektu ustawy, s. 1, druk sejmowy nr 1577.
4
b=.8"8'"'41'/=%"$8<'1,'(-"01,=0*. )*"01,=/)*'8'<=2"$.8 <-F"%8B1=E'", / (*=)"2=.8"
01'< /,=(*="0'.8@0'< (* "8=1 0=$8-+,(=E'"<'A=+"'.BA".8< 1, 2D+-+C", E1'>=(*=5"Z41o/=%"2=.8"2=/('.8%D"A$/>=8'<D"0'/3=E!D")*(*.81'<*"/.5",/1'<* "W 185";"*"M"$.8 <-S5
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
ZN nr 100
Problem konstytuc6.*?@-#&,03A&B+,$36&?&C!+,#$-D
111
n=E'" 3A'" '" $)*=.,+,=(*$" 2=2" <" Z41'/%$, 3A'" 0'.8 ('<*=(*=" '" $,( (*$F" >="
5
'.'A F"%8B1=2"/'8-+,-"<(*'.=%F"(*="2=.8"'.'AD".8< 1, 2D+D", E1'>=(*= .
cD/" '1,=%(*=" '" , .8'.'< (*$" <'A=+" '.'A-" .8< 1, 2D+=2" , E1'>=(*="
( /,'1$"01=<=(+-2(=E'F"2=>=3*"+C 1 %8=1".8<*=1/,'(-+C", A$1,=O"0.-+C*+,(-+C"
3$A" *+C" ( .*3=(*=" <.% ,$2DF" >=" , +C'/,*" <-.'%*=" 01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'" 0'0=!d
(*=(* "01,=,"8@"'.'A@"+,-($", A1'(*'(=E'","$>-+*=)"01,=)'+-"3$A"E1'VAD"2=2"
$>-+* " 01,=+*<%'" >-+*$F" ,/1'<*$" 3$A" <'3('4+*" .=%.$ 3(=2F" , E1'>'(=E'" % 1D"
pozbaw*=(* "<'3('4+*F"%8B1=2"EB1( "E1 (*+ "<-('.*"+'"( 2)(*=2":9"3 85
# 8')* .8"<"01,-0 /%$"'.'A-".8< 1, 2D+=2", E1'>=(*=F"2=>=3*"+C 1 %8=1"
.8<*=1/,'(-+C" , A$1,=O" 0.-+C*+,(-+C" 3$A" *+C" ( .*3=(*=" <.% ,$2DF" >=" 2=.8" 8'"
(*=,A@/(=" ,=" <,E3@/$" ( " A 1/,'" <-.'%*=" 01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'" 0'0=!(*=(* "
+,-($" , A1'(*'(=E'" ," $>-+*=)" 01,=)'+-" 3$A" E1'VAD" 2=2" $>-+* " 01,=+*<%'" >y+*$F",/1'<*$"3$A"<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2F", E1'>'(=E'"% 1D"0',A <*=(* "<'3('4+*F"
%8B1=2"EB1( "E1 (*+ "<-('.*"+'"( 2)(*=2":9"3 8F".D/"'1,=%(*="'"$)*=.,+,=(*$"2=2"
w O41'/%$5
Zarówno nadzór prewencyjny, 2 %"*"$)*=.,+,=(*="<"Z41'/%$"'1,=% ".*@"
A=,"'%1=43=(* "8=1)*($"W 185":;"$.8 <-S5
Z1,=% 2D+"'", .8'.'< (*$"( /,'1$"01=<=(+-2(=E'F".D/")'>="/'/ 8%o<'" ( !'>-J" ( " '.'A@" .8< 1, 2D+D" , E1'>=(*=" 'A'<*D,=%" 0'// (* " .*@" '/0owie/(*=)$"0'.8@0'< (*$"8=1 0=$8-+,(=)$"W 185":aS5"
N.8 < "<" 185"77".8 ('<*F"*>"+=3=)"( /,'1$"01=<=(+-2(=E'"2=.8"'E1 (i+,=(*=", E1'>=(* ">-+* F",/1'<* "3$A"<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2"*((-+C"'.BA",=".81o(-"'.'A-".8< 1, 2D+=2", E1'>=(*=F"%8B1 "(*=",'.8 ! "$)*=.,+,'( <"Z41'/%$5"
Nadzór prewencyjny jest sprawowany przez komendanta powiatowego (miej.%*=E'F"1=2'('<=E'S"I'3*+2*F"( "'A., 1,="<! 4+*<'4+*"%8B1=E'"'.'A ".8< 1, 2Dd
+ ", E1'>=(*=") ")*=2.+=".8 !=E'"0'A-8$5"Z.'A ".8< 1, 2D+ ", E1'>=(*=F"<obec której zastosowano nad,B1" 01=<=(+-2(-F" ) " 'A'<*D,=%" % >/'1 ,'<=E'"
*(Q'1)'< (* "%')=(/ (8 "I'3*+2*".01 <$2D+=E'"( /,B1"01=<=(+-2(-"'",)* (*="
)*=2.+ " .8 !=E'" 0'A-8$F" )*=2.+ " , 81$/(*=(* F" *)*=(* " 3$A" ( ,<*.% F" " 2=>=3*"
%')=(/ (8"I'3*+2*"8=E'", >D/ F"1B<(*=> udzielania informacji o miejscu aktualnego i zamierzonego pobytu oraz o terminach i miejscach wyjazdów.
I'3*+2 F" /3 " ,1= 3*,'< (* " +=3B<" ( /,'1$" 01=<=(+-2(=E'F" )'>=" 01'<a/,*J" +,-(('4+*" '0=1 +-2('-1',0',( <+,=" /'8-+,D+=" '.'A-" .8< 1, 2D+=2" ,aE1'>=(*=F"<'A=+"%8B1=2", .8'.'< ('"( /,B1"01=<=(+-2(-F" "8 %>="<=1-Q*%'< JF"
E1') /,*J" *" 01,=8< 1, J" *(Q'1) +2=" $/,*=3 (= 01,=," 8@" '.'A@" '1 ," $,-.% (="
w <-(*%$" +,-(('4+*" '0=1 +-2('-rozpoznawczych. b=>=3*" <=1-Q*%'< (*=" *(Q'r5
I1'2=%8'/ <+ "/'"0=<(=E'".8'0(* "'/.,=/!"8$"'/"1=E$!-F">="$+,=.8(*+8<'"<"1'z01 <*="+-<*3(=2"2=.8"01 <=)F" "(*="'A'<*D,%*=)F"$,( 2D+F">=","$< E*"( "+C 1 %8=1"1'z.81,-E(*@+* F" /3 " <-/ (* " 01 <*/!owego orzeczenia, 1=E$!D" 0'<*(('" A-JF" >=" .D/" ) "
'.'A*.8-"%'(8 %8","'.'ADF"%8B1=2"<'3('4+*"* 01 < "A@/D")'E!-",'.8 J"*.8'8(*="'E1 (*+,o(="<.%$8=%"<-/ (* "'1,=+,=(* 5"P 8=)".D/"0'3=+ "/'01'< /,=(*=",", %! /$"% 1(=E'"
'.'A-F"%8B1=2"/'8-+,-"<(*'.=%F" "2=>=3*"0' skierowaniu wniosku, o którym mowa w art. 9,
'.'A "8 "'0$4+*! ", %! /"% 1(-F"<,-< "2D"/'".8 <*=((*+8< "( "1',01 <*=5"b=>=3*"2=/( %"
'.'A "8 "'/)B<*"$/,* !$"<"1',01 <*=" 3A'"(*=".8 <*".*@F"0'<* /')*'( "'"8=1)*(*=F" .D/"
uzna jej stawiennictwo za konieczne, )'>( " , 1,D/,*J" 2=2" 0'.,$%*< (*=F" , 81,-) (*="
i /'01'< /,=(*="01,=,"I'3*+2@U",'A5"uzasadnienie do projektu ustawy…, s. 5.
ZN nr 100
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
2$3!4&5"$3-067
112
) +2*F" '" %8B1-+C" )'< " 0'<->=2F" ( 0'8-% " 81$/('4+*" 3$A" 2=>=3*" , +C'/,*" $za. /(*'( " 'A < F" >=" '.'A F" <'A=+" %8B1=2" , .8'.'< ('" ( /,B1" 01=<=(+-2(-F"
+,-(*" 01,-E'8'< (* " /'" 0'0=!(*=(* " 01,[email protected]< " 01,=+*<%'" >-+*$" *" ,/1'<*$F"
, E1'>'(=E'" % 1D" 0',A <*=(* " <'3('4+*F" %8B1=2" EB1( " E1 (*+ " <-('.*" +'" ( j)(*=2"M"3 8F"3$A"01,[email protected]< "01,=+*<%'"<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2"*"'A-+, 2('4+*F".D/"
)'>=F" <" /1'/,=" 0'.8 ('<*=(* F" ( " 0*.=)(-" <(*'.=%"%')=(/ (8 " <'2=<B/z%*=E'"I'3*+2*F"0'"$,-.% (*$"0*.=)(=2",E'/-"01'%$1 8'1 "'%1@E'<=E'"<! 4+*<eE'" ,=" <,E3@/$" ( " .*=/,*A@" %')=(/-" <'2=<B/,%*=2" I'3*+2*F" , 1,D/,*J" %'(81'3@"
6
'0=1 +-2(D (art. 23 ustawy) .
Art. 21 jest przepisem o charakterze prewencyjnym. Ma on na celu
'E1 (*+,=(*="(*=A=,0*=+,=O.8< "/3 "*((-+C"'.BA",=".81'(-"'.'A-".8< 1, 2D+=2"
<-.'%*=", E1'>=(*=F"%8B1 "01,=A-< "( "<'3('4+*F"3=+,"$+C-3 ".*@"'/"'1,=+,'(=2"
<'A=+" (*=2" 8=1 0**" 3$A" 'A'<*D,%B<" <-(*% 2D+-+C" ," ( /,'1$" 01=wencyjnego.
W .8'.$(%$" /'" 8 %*=2" '.'A-" )'>( " A'<*=)" $,( JF" >=" <.%$8=%" 3=%+=< >=(* "
8-+C" 'A'<*D,%B<" .8< 1, " '( " , E1'>=(*=" 2$>" <*@%.,=" (*>" <-.'%*=F" " 8-)".a)-)"/ 2="0'/.8 <-"/'"$)*=.,+,=(* "E'"<"'4rodku.
cD/" $+C-3 " ( /,B1" 01=<=(+-2(-F" 2=>=3*" (*=" , +C'/,D" 2$>" '%'3*+,('4+*F"
z 0'<'/$"%8B1-+C"'1,=+,'('"( /,B1"01=<=(+-2(-F" 3A'"2=>=3*"'.'A ".8< 1, 2Dd
+ ", E1'>=(*=",'.8 ! "$)*=.,+,'( "<"Z41'/%$5"6(*'.=%"<"8-)", %1=.*=".%!a/ " Y')=(/ (8" I'3*+2*" .01 <$2D+-" (adzór prewencyjny (*=,<!'+,(*=" 0'" $,y.% (*$" *(Q'1) +2*" <.% ,$2D+-+CF" >=" (*=" , +C'/,D" 2$>" '%'3*+,('4+*" /3 " %8B1-+C"
,'.8 !"$.8 ('<*'(-U"'.'A "<'A=+"%8B1=2", .8'.'< ('"( /,B1"01=<=(+-2(-"3$A"
2=2"0=!(')'+(*%"(*="<+,=4(*=2"(*>"0'"$0!-<*="a")*=.*@+-"'/"/(* ", .8osowania
nadzoru (art. 24).
^.8'8D"$)*=.,+,=(* "'.'A-" .8< 1, 2D+=2", E1'>=(*=" <" Z41'/%$"2=.8"'b2@+*="2=2"'/0'<*=/(*)"0'.8@0'< (*=)"8=1 0=$8-+,(-)F"%8B1=E'"+=3=)"2=.8"0o01 < ".8 ($"2=2",/1'<* "*", +C'< (* "<".8'0(*$"$)'>3*<* 2D+-)"Q$(%+2'('<a(*=" <" .0'!=+,=O.8<*=" <" .0'.BA" (*=.8< 1, 2D+-" , E1'>=(* " >-+* F" ,/1'<* " 3$A"
<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2"*((-+C"'.BA5"P 1B<('"/3 ".01 <+-F"2 %"/3 ".0'!=+,=O.8< "
jest to zasadniczy cel pobytu sprawcy w , %! /,*=", )%(*@8-)"W 185"7MS5
6
Y'(81'3@ '0=1 +-2(D" 01'2=%8'/ <+ "$.8 <-" $, . /(* ".0=+-Q*%D"+,-(B<"*" , A$1,=OF"
których dotyczy ustawa. Mianowicie wykrycie stanu zw*@%., 2D+=E'".*@"(*=A=,0*=+,=O.8< "
, "0')'+D" ,<-%!-+C")=8'/"+,-(('4+*"'0=1 +-2('-1',0',( <+,-+C" , ,<-+, 2"(*="A@/,*="
)'>3*<=F","1=E$!-"8=>"(*="A@/,*=")* !'")*=2.+ "<-.8D0*=(*="'EB3(-+C"01,=.! (=%", .8'.owania kontroli operacyjnej przewidzianych w ustawie o Policji. W uzasadnieniu projektu
0'/('.*".*@F"*>".01 <+B<"E1'V(-+C"01,[email protected]<".=%.$ 3(-+C"+=+C$2="/'%'(-< (*="( E!-+C"
*)0$3.-<(-+C" 8 %B<"0'01,=/,'(-+C"+,@.8'"+,-(('4+* )*F"%8B1=" 3A'".D"81$/('"/'.81,eE 3(="<"1 ) +C",<-%!=2"01 +-"'0=1 +-2('-rozpoznawczejF" 3A'"(*=") 2D"/3 "'.BA"0'.81'n(-+C"%'('8 +2*"01,=.8@0+,-+CF"+,=E'"01,-%! /=)")'>="A-J"1',0'+,@+*="01,=E3D/ (* ".81'("
*(8=1(=8'<-+C" ," +'1 ," A1$8 3(*=2.,-)*" 81=4+* )*F" 0'E!@A* 2D+ " .*@" 3*=( +2 F" 1',0'+,@+*="
0=<(-+C"+,-(('4+*"G1-8$ 3(-+CHF"(05", %$0"$A1 O"/,*=+*@+-+C5"6.,-.8%*="8="'A2 <-"4<* d+,D+="'"1'.(D+-)"1-,-%$" 8 %$".D"(*=/'.81,=E 3(="<"1 ) +C",<-%!=2"01 +-"<-<* /'<+,=2"
/,*=3(*+'<=E'F" " 2=/('+,=4(*=" (*=" .8 ('<*D" 2=.,+,=" 01,-E'8'< (* " /'" 0'0=!(*=(* " 01,[email protected]< " <" 1',$)*=(*$" Y'/=%.$" % 1(=E'5" P +C'< (*= 8 %*=2" '.'A-" 0'<*(('" A-J" , 8=)"
analizowane przez wyspecjalizowanego funkcjonariusza policji w porozumieniu z psycholoE*=)"/-.0'($2D+-)"01'Q*3=)"8 %*=2"'.'A-F"<'A=+"%8B1=2"'1,=+,'('"( /,B1U zob. uzasadnienie do projektu ustawy…, s. 7,8.
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
ZN nr 100
Problem konstytuc6.*?@-#&,03A&B+,$36&?&C!+,#$-D
113
Przepisem o charakterze gwarancyjnym jest art5";aF"( %! / 2D+-"( ".D/"
'A'<*D,=%"A / (* "(*="1, /,*=2"(*>"1 ,"( "a")*=.*@+-F"+,-"(*="$.8 ! "0'81,=A "
$)*=.,+,=(* " '.'A-" <" Z41'/%$5"Z+=( " 8 " A@/,*=" /'%'(-< ( " ( " 0'/.8 <*="
'0*(**" 3=% 1, " 0.-+C* 81-" '1 ," <-(*%B<" 8=1 0**5" _'" 'A'<*D,%B<" %*=1'<(*% "
Z41'/% "A@/,*="( 3=> !'".0'1,D/, (*="+'"a")*=.*@+-"'0*(**"( "0'81,=A-".D/$U"
'0*(*@" 8 %D" 'A'<*D, (-" A@/,*=" 01,=.! J" A=,,<!'+,(*=F" 2=>=3*" <" ,<*D,%$" ,="
,)* (D" .8 ($" ,/1'<* " 8=2" '.'A-" $,( F" >=" / 3.,=" 2=2" 0','.8 < (*=" <" '41'/%$"
nie jest konieczne.
b=>=3*"$.8 (D"01,=.! (%*"$, . /(* 2D+="$)*=.,+,=(*="'.'A-"<"Z41'/%$F"
.D/" A@/,*=" )* !" 'A'<*D,=%" (*=,<!'+,(*=" '1,=+" '" 2=2" <-0*. (*$5" Z1,=% 2D+"
o <-0*. (*$"'.'A-","Z41'/% F".D/"A@/,*=")BE!", .8'.'< J"<'A=+"(*=2"( /,B1"
prewencyjny (art. 47).
b %" 0'/('.*" .*@" <" $, . /(*=(*$" /'" 01'jektu ustawy, < 3'1-" 01,-2@8=E'"
1',<*D, (* " 'A=2)$2D" , 1B<('" + !=" .0'!=+,=O.8<'F" 2 %" *" . )-+C" .01 <+B<5"
c0'!=+,=O.8<'" A@/,*="A'<*=)".%$8=+,(*="+C1'(*'(="01,=/"( 2A 1/,*=2"A1$8 l(-)*"01,[email protected]< )*"0'0=!(* (-)*"01,=,"'.'A-F"%8B1="<"01,=.,!'4+*"2$>".*@"8akicC" +,-(B<" /'0$4+*!-F" " , +C'/,*" A 1/,'" <-.'%*=" 01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'F" >="
w ,<*D,%$"," , A$1,'(D"0.-+C*%D"/'0$.,+,D".*@"*+C"0'('<(*=5"c01 <+-"( 8o)* .8" $,-.% 2D" ., (.=F" A-" 0'// J" .*@" 8=1 0**" *" 0'<1B+*J" /'" >-+* " <" .0'!e+,=O.8<*="<".0'.BAF"%8B1-"(*="A@/,*=".8< 1, !", E1'>=(* "/3 "*((-+C"'.BA5"#a3=>-" 0'( /8'" , $< >-JF" >=" *.8'8(-)" .%$8%*=)" 01'2=%8'< (-+C" 1=E$3 +2*" )'>="
A-J",)* ( ".8'.$(%$".0'!=+,=O.8< "/'"8 %*+C".01 <+B<5"6"+C<*3*"'A=+(=2".D"
'(*F"0'"'0$.,+,=(*$", %! /$"% 1(=E'F"( 1 >=(*"( ".*3(*="(=E 8-<(=F"(*=%'(81o3'< (="1= %+2="*((-+C"'.BA5"I'(*=< >".0'!=+,=O.8<'") ")'+(="0'+,$+*=",aE1'>=(* " ," *+C" .81'(-F" <-<'!$2=" 8'" '/0'<*=/V" <" 0'.8 +*" E1=.2*" <'A=+" (*+CF"
)'ED+=2"01'< /,*J"(*="8-3%'"/'" , E1'>=(* "*+C"0'+,$+* "A=,0*=+,=O.8< F" 3="
( <=8"/'", E1'>=(* "*+C"<! .(=E'">-+* "*",/1'<* 5"I'"<=24+*$"<">-+*="01'2=k8'< (-+C" 1',<*D, O" .8'.$(=%" /'" 8-+C" .01 <+B<" 0'<*(*=(" $3=E J" .8'0(*'<=2"
,)* (*=F" " *+C" .8-E) 8-, +2 " .0'!=+,( " 0'<*(( " ) 3=JF" E/->" <-%.,8 !+*" .*@"
.0'!=+,( " 4<* /')'4JF" >=" 0'<1 + 2D+" /'" .0'!=+,=O.8< " 0'" '/A-+*$" 8=1 0ii,
7
.01 <+-"8 +-"(*="A@/D"2$>".8 ('<*J", E1'>=(* .
I')*)'" 8 %" '08-)*.8-+,(=E'" $, . /(*=(*=" 01'2=%8$" 01,-2@8=" 1',<*D,a(* "( 3=>-"$,( J", "<D803*<="<"4<*=83="*+C",E'/('4+*","Y'(.8-8$+2D5"6.% , J"
8$8 2" ( 3=>-" ( " )'>3*<=" ( 1$.,=(*=" %'(.8-8$+-2(=2" , . /-" /=)okratycznego
8
0 O.8< " 01 <(=E'" W 185" 7" Y'(.8-8$+2* ) w aspekcie tzw. przyzwoitej legislacji,
a 4+*43=2"G(*=/,* ! (* "01 < "<.8=+,H"'1 ," , . /-"01'0'1+2'( 3('4+*F" "<"%'n.=%<=(+2*" %'(.8-8$+-2(=2" , . /-" 0'., ('< (* " <'3('4+*" '.'A*.8=2" 2=/('.8%*"
9
(art. 31 ust. 1) .
7
Zob. uzasadnienie do projektu ustawy…,s. 1, 2.
Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej z dnia 2 kwietnia 1997 r., Dz.U. 1997 nr 78
poz. 483.
9
I'/'A(="<D803*<'4+*"<"8-)", %1=.*=",E! ., ! "1B<(*=>"e=3.*O.% "`$(/ +2 "I1 <"
\,!'<*=% U" ,'A5 $&C!) 6%'%&.) E.6':1*) F%/&$D&@$%9) G*(1.+9$) 6.-) H'I!-$%@.) J.(*0;)
Przywary do Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich prof. Ireny Lipowicz, z dnia 24 stycznia
2014 r.,http: // programy. hfhr. pl/ monitoringprocesulegislacyjnego / files/2014/01/RPO_
ustawaz22list2013_pismo_TK.pdf; Naczelna Rada Adwokacka; zob. Pismo Przewodni8
ZN nr 100
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
114
2$3!4&5"$3-067
PE'/(*=",", . /D"(*=/,* ! (* "01 < "<.8=+,"(lex retro non agit) ustawodawca (*=")'>="$.8 ( <* J"przepisów prawaF"%8B1="<*D, !-A-"skutki prawne
ze zdarzeniami prawnymi ) 2D+-)*" )*=2.+=" <" 01,=.,!'4+*5" I1 <'" )$.*" A-J"
01,=<*/-< 3(=" *" A$/,*J" , $Q (*=F" " podmiot prawa )$.*" )*=J" 0=<('4JF" >="
10
w / (=2".-8$ +2*"0'.8@0$2=",E'/(*="3$A"(*=,E'/(*=","'A'<*D,$2D+-m prawem .
c!$.,(*=" 0'/('.*" e=3.*O.% " `$(/ +2 " I1 <" \,!'<*=% F" *>" <" 01,-0 /%$"
(*(*=2.,=2" 1=E$3 +2*" 81$/('" <.% , JF" A-" '.'A-" 'A2@8=" ('< " 1=E$3 +2D" )'E!-"
01,=<*/,*=J"<"81 %+*="'/A-< (* "% 1-"7M"3 8"0',A <*=(* "<'3('4+*F">="<"'.8 t(*+C"3 8 +C"W3$A")*=.*D+ +CS"2=2"'/A-< (* "<01'< /,'(=",'.8 (*="1',<*D, (*=F"
%8B1="A@/,*="$)'>3*<* !'"*+C"/ 3.,D"*,'3 +2@"0'/"01=8=%.8=)"8=1 0**"'"<D803*<=2"
.%$8=+,('4+*5"Z.'A-"8="(*="8-3%'"(*=")'E!-"01,=<*/,*=JF">="8 % "1=E$3 +2 ",o.8 (*="<01'< /,'( F" 3="+'"<*@+=2"(*=")* !-"'(=")'>3*<'4+*"/'.8'.'< (* ".*@"
11
/'"('<-+C"1=E$3 +2*"<"8 %*".0'.BAF" A-"$(*%(DJ"2=2".%$8%B< .
601 </,*=","'1,=+,(*+8< "]1-A$( !$"Y'(.8-8$+-2(=E'"<-(*% F"*>"01,=0i.-" /,* ! 2D+=" <.8=+," )'>( " <-2D8%'<'" $,( J" , " ,E'/(=" ," , . /D" /=)'%1a8-+,(=E'"0 O.8< "01 <(=E'F" 3="0'/"4+*43= '%1=43'(-)*"< 1$(% )*F")5*(5"%*e/-" (*=" .D" 8'" 01,=0*.-" 01 < " % 1(=E'" (*" 1=E$3 +2=" , %! / 2D+=" 0'/0'1,D/%'< (*="2=/('.8%*"0 O.8<$U"*+C"<01'< /,=(*="2=.8"%'(*=+,(="W(*=,A@/(=S"/3 "
1= 3*, +2*" 3$A" '+C1'(-" *((-+CF" < >(*=2.,-+C" *" %'(%1=8(*=" <.% , (-+C" < 18'4+*"
%'(.8-8$+-2(-+CU.0=!(*'( " 2=.8" , . / " 01'0'1+2'( 3('4+*F" 8,(5" 1 +2=" %'(.8-8u+-2(="01,=) <* 2D+=", "1=81' %8-<('4+*D"1B<('< >D"2=2"(=E 8-<(=".%$8%*U"(*="
0'<'/$2D" '(=" 'E1 (*+,=(* " 3$A" ,<*@%.,=(* " ,'A'<*D, O" /1=. 8B<" ('1)"
prawnych, a przeciwnie – 0'01 <* 2D" .-8$ +2@ 01 <(D" (*=%8B1-+C" /1=. 8B<"
/ (=2"('1)-"01 <(=2"W 3="(*="%'.,8=)"0','.8 !-+C adresatów tej normy); proA3=)"1',<*D, (-"01,=,"8="1=E$3 +2="(*="A-!",( (-"$.8 <'/ <+-"<+,=4(*=2"*"(*="
)BE!" A-J" 1',<*D, (-" ," <-01,=/,=(*=)" A=," $>-+* " 01,=0*.B<" /,* ! 2D+-+C"
12
wstecz .
Z) <* (="1=E$3 +2="<.% , (-+C"< 1$(%B<",/ 2D".*@"(*=".0=!(* J5
+':+%<!) K!C$&9$) 6.-) H'I!-$%@.) #6';) L.+'%/(%9) M.1'$%) N1-!@.+@$%9) .1-7) O$@!I.9.) $e06'.@.)1!)O$($&06.)P#6.-$%1/$-!"+$)O.6@.)Q$%6(.+@$%<!)')1($.)4R)C.9.)2345)6.,http: // adwokatura. pl/ wp-content/ uploads /2013 / 05/ 2013 - 05-16 - pismo - do – MS -w-sprawie - projektu – ustawy – o - post%C4% 99powaniu - wobec-os% C3% B3b - zaburzonych psychicznie - 75"0/QU"Y1 2'< "f / "cD/'<(*+8< U",'A5"S#$($.)K6.9!-%9)M.1.)P:1!-($+0-.)
z dnia 17 maja 2013 r., http: // krs. pl/ pl/ dzialalnosc/ posiedzenia-rady/ f,99,posiedzenia-w2013-r/73,14-17 – maja - 2013/881, opinia - krajowej - rady - sadownictwa - z - dnia - 17 –
maja – 2013 – r - nr - wok-020-5413
10
]1=4+*D" , . /-" lex retro non agit 2=.8" , % ," /,* ! (* " <.8=+," 01,=0*.')" 01 <(-)"
%.,8 !8$2D+-)"01 < "*"'A'<*D,%*"'A-< 8=3*F"2=>=3*"8'"01'< /,*F"3$A")'>="01'< /,*JF"/'"0oE'1.,=(* " *+C" .-8$ +2*" 01 <(=2" <" .8'.$(%$" /'" .8 ($" 0'01,=/(*=E'5" P . / " (*=/,* ! (* "
01 < "<.8=+,".8 ('<*"0'/.8 <@"0'1,D/%$"01 <(=E'5"Y.,8 !8$2=", . /@", $Q (* "'A-< 8=3*"
/'"0 O.8< "'1 ,".8 ('<*'(=E'"01,=,"(*=E'"01 < 5"N"0'/.8 <"8=2>=", . /-"3=>-"<-1 >'( "
<" 185"7"Y'(.8-8$+2*", . / "/=)'%1 8-+,(=E'"0 O.8< "01 <(=E'U",'A5 wyrok TK z 17 grudnia 1997 r5F"Y5"77gKa5"P . / ", $Q (* "/'"0 O.8< "<-) E F"A-")'+-"<.8=+,(=2"(*="( /a< J"01,=0*.')F"%8B1="1=E$3$2D"01 < "*"'A'<*D,%*"'A-< 8=3*"* 0'E 1., 2D"*+C".-8$ +2@"01 w(DU",'A5"wyroki TK z 8 marca 2005 r., K27/03 oraz 19 marca 2007 r., K47/05).
11
Zob. $&C!) 6%'%&.)E.6':1*)F%/&$D&@$%9)G*(1.+9$) 6.-)H'I!-$%@.TU
12
Wyrok TK z 17 grudnia 1997 r., K. 22/96); Wyrok TK z 19 listopada 2008 r.,. Kp 2/08
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
ZN nr 100
Problem konstytuc6.*?@-#&,03A&B+,$36&?&C!+,#$-D
115
h'>3*<'4J"$)*=.,+,=(* "<"Y1 2'<-)"Z41'/%$"P 0'A*=E (* "P +C'<aniom _-..'+2 3(-)" <-/ 2=" .*@" ( 1$., J" , . /@" 01'0'1+2'( 3('4+*5 Z zasady
8=2"0!-(*=", !'>=(*=F"*>"( 3=>-"<-A*=1 J"41'/%*".%$8=+,(="/3 "'.*DE(*@+* "+=3B<"
,!'>'(-+CF" " , 1 ,=)")'>3*<*="( 2)(*=2"$+*D>3*<="/3 " 0'/)*'8B<F" <'A=+"%8ó1-+C") 2D"A-J" , .8'.'< (=F"3$A"/'3=E3*<=" <".8'0(*$"(*="<*@%.,-)"(*>"2=.8"8'"
13
(*=,A@/(="/3 "'.*DE(*@+* ", !'>'(=E'"+=3$ . b %".!$.,(*=", $< >-! "# +,=lna Rada Adwokacka, analiza przepisów ustawy, 2 %" 1B<(*=>" '0*(**" =%.0=18B<"
z , %1=.$"0.-+C'3'E**"*"0.-+C* 81**"(*="0','.8 <* "<D803*<'4+*F"*>"0')*)'"'/<o!-< (* " .*@" /'" <,E3@/B<" 3=+,(*+,-+C" '1 ," $.8 <-" '" '+C1'(*=" ,/1'<* " 0.ychicznego, rzeczyw*.8-)" +=3=)" 1=E$3 +2*" 2=.8" 81< ! " *,'3 +2 " '.BA" .8< 1, 2Dd
14
+-+C" , E1'>=(*=F" %8B1=" '/A-!-" 2$>" % 1@" 0',A <*=(* " <'3('4+* . Wielokrotnie
0'/%1=43 ('F" *>" $.8 < " ,'.8 ! " $+C< 3'( " 01,-" A 1/,'" <-1 V(-)" .01,=+*<*="
3=% 1,-" 0.-+C* 81B<5"6.% ,$2D" '(*" 01,=/=" <.,-.8%*)F >=" 01,-)$.'< " 8=1 0* "
, A$1,=O"'.'A'<'4+*"2=.8"(*=.%$8=+,( F" "+'", "8-)"*/,*="8=1 0* "<"Y1 2'<-)"
Z41'/%$" P 0'A*=E (* Zachowaniom Dyssocjalnym, )*)'" >=" ) " A-J" ( %*e1'< ( "( ",(*<=3'< (*="8-+C", A$1,=OF"8 %"( 01 </@"A@/,*=".8 ('<*J"G01,y15
%1-<%@H"/3 "*,'3 +ji tych osób .
i( 3*, " 01,=.! (=%" , .8'.'< (* " ( /,'1u prewencyjnego (art. 14 ust.
2 $.8 <-S" '1 ," 01,=.! (=%" $)*=.,+,=(* " <" Z41'/%$" W 185" :; ust. 3) prowadzi
/'" <(*'.%$F" >=" 2=/-(D" 1B>(*+D" 2=.8" 0',*')" 01 </'0'/'A*=O.8< " 0'0=!(*=(* "
+,-($" , A1'(*'(=E'" ," $>-+*=)" 01,=)'+-" 3$A" E1'VAD" 2=2" $>-+* " 01,=+*<%'" >y+*$F",/1'<*$"3$A"<'3('4+*".=%.$ 3(=2F", E1'>'(=E'"% 1D"0',A <*=(* "<'3('4+*F"
%8B1=2"EB1( "E1 (*+ "<'3('4+*"<-('.*F"+'"( 2)(*=2":9"3 85"6"01,-0 /%$")'>3i<'4+*", .8'.'< (* "( /,'1$"01=<=(+-2(=E'"<-) E (="2=.8"„wysokie prawdo0'/'A*=O.8<'HF" ( 8')* .8" <" 01,-0 /%$" $)*=.,+,=(* " <" Z41'/%$" – „bardzo
<-.'%*="01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'H5"Y 8=E'1* "<-.'%*=E'"01 </'0'/'A*=O.8< "A@d
/D+ " 01,=.! (%D" $)*=.,+,=(* " <" '41'/%$" 2=.8" 2=/( %" 0'2@+*=)" (*=)'>3*<-)"
do zdefiniowania, co rodzi du>=" 0'3=" /'" /'<'3(=2" *(8=101=8 +2*F" %8B1 " )'>="
.%$8%'< J"1-,-%*=)"0'/=2)'< (* "/=+-,2*"'"$)*=.,+,=(*$"<"Z41'/%$"<".0o16
sób arbitralny 5" _'2/,*=" , 8=)" /'" .-8$ +2*F" <" %8B1=2" .D/F" <" '0 1+*$" '" '0*(*@
13
S. Wronkowska, !/&@$%)1;&@*&9%)!)#.D&0-$%)#6.-., Warszawa 1995, s. 74; Zasada
01'0'1+2'( 3('4+*"2=.8"=3=)=(8=)".%! /'<-)", . /-"0 O.8< "01 <(=E'5"P . / "01'0'r+2'( 3('4+*"< $2@+*$".,=1'%*)".,+,=EB3(-"( +*.% %! /,*="( " /=%< 8('4J"+=3$"*"41'/% "$>y8=E'"/'"2=E'"'.*DE(*@+* 5"P"0'<->.,=E'"<-(*% F"*>"2=>=3*"+=3"1=E$3 +2*"01 <(=2")'>( "'.*Dd
E(DJ"01,-"0')'+-"/<B+C"41'/%B<F"01,-"+,-)"2=/=(","(*+C"<"<*@%.,-)".8'0(*$"0'E 1., "
.-8$ +2=" 01 <(D" 0'/)*'8$F" 8'" ( 3=>-" <-A1 J" ten drugi; zob. orzeczenie TK 31 stycznia
1996 r., Y"KgKM5"P", . /-"01'0'1+2'( 3('4+*"<-0!-< "0'"0*=1<.,=F"01,-2)'< (*="/ (=2"1eE$3 +2*"8-3%'"<B<+, .F"E/-"2=.8"(*=,A@/( "/3 "'+C1'(-"*(8=1=.$"0$A3*+,(=E'F","%8B1-)"2=.8"
0'<*D, ( F" 0'" /1$E*=F" ( % ," %.,8 !8'< (* " / (=2" 1=E$3 +2*" <" .0'.BA" , 0=<(* 2D+-" '.*Dd
E(*@+*=", )*=1,'(-+C".%$8%B<"*"0'"81,=+*=F"<-)BE", +C'< (* "01'0'1+2*")*@/,-"=Q=%8 )*"
<01'< /,'(=2" 1=E$3 +2*" " +*@> 1 )*" <,E3@/(*=" (*=/'E'/('4+* )*" <-(*% 2D+-)*" ," (*=2" /3 "
obywateli; zob. orzeczenie TK z 26 kwietnia 1995 r., K 11/94.
14
Zob. $&C!) 6'%-!1($+':+%<!) K!C$&9$) 6.-) H'I!-$%@.) #6';) L.+'%/(%9) M.1'$%)
Adwokackiej…;
15
Zob. $&C!) 6%'%&.)E.6':1*)F%/&$D&@$%9)G*(1.+9$) 6.-)H'I!-$%@.TU)#6';#$&)V)$)W7
16
Zob. $&C!) 6'%-!1($+':+%<!) K!C$&9$) 6.-) H'I!-$%@.) #6';) L.czelnej Radzie
Adwokackiej…
ZN nr 100
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
2$3!4&5"$3-067
116
A*=E!=E', A@/,*=")$.* !"'+=(*J"01 </'0'/'A*=O.8<'"01,-.,!-+C", +C'< O"W( "
17
<'3('4+*S"'.'A-"0',A <*'(=2"<'3('4+*"01,=,"'.8 8(*="%*3% ( 4+*="3 8 .
]1$/('"1B<(*=>"$,( JF"*>".0=!(*'(=",'.8 !-"0','.8 !="01,=.! (%*"0',<a3 2D+=" ( " /,* ! (*=" 01 < " <.8=+,F" " .-E( 3*,'< (=" 01,-<'! (-)" '1,=+,(*c8<=)"]1-A$( !$"Y'(.8-8$+-2(=E'"– )* ('<*+*=F">="<01'< /, (="01,=0*.-"(*="
)'ED")*=J"+C 1 %8=1$"01 < "% 1(=E'"'1 ,"01'A3=)"1',<*D, (-"01,=,"8="1=Eu3 +2=" (*=" A-!" ,( (-" $.8 <'/ <+-" <+,=4(*=2" *" (*=" )BE!" A-J" 1',<*D, (-" ," <y01,=/,=(*=)"A=,"$>-+* "01,=0*.B<"/,* ! 2D+-+C"<.8=+,5"
Podsumowanie
Pr,-8'+,'(=" 0'<->=2" 1',< > (* " /'<'/,DF" *>" ) 8=1* " 1=E$3'< ( "
01,=/)*'8'<D" $.8 <D" ," + !D" 0=<('4+*D" 2=.8 A3*>., " 01 <('% 1(-)"1',<*D,a(*')"(*>"+-<*3*.8-+,(-)5"68!'+,=(*="') <* (-+C"1=E$3 +2*"<"01'+=/$1@"+-<*l(D"1 ,*".,8$+,('4+*D"*"(*= /=%< 8('4+*D"W'"+,-)"4<* /+,-"+C'+* >A-"(*=$/'lna próba zastosowania cywilistycznej instytucji zabezpieczenia w przypadku
G( 2.!-((*=2.,=E'H" ," '. /,'(-+CS5" #*=.8=8-" $,( J" ( 3=>-F" *>" $.8 <'/ <+ " 8a%*)", A*=E*=)"2=/-(*="0','1'< !"G(*="% 1(-H"+C 1 %8=1"<01'< /, (-+C"01,=0isów, tj. s0=!(*=(*=" 01,=.! (%*"%'(.8-8$+-2('4+*" 01,=0*.B<" /,* ! 2D+-+C" ," )'+D"
<.8=+,(D5"
#*=")'>( " 1B<(*=>" $,( JF" *>" 01'A3=)" 'A2@8-" 01,=/)*'8'< " $.8 <D" (*="
A-!",( (-"$.8 <'/ <+-"<+,=4(*=2"*"(*=")BE!"A-J"1',<*D, (-","<-01,=/,=(*=)5"
c8'.'<(="/,* ! (* "W+C'+* >A-"<", %1=.*="') <* (=2"1=E$3 +2*S"( 3=> !'"0'd2DJ" <" :KLK" 15F" 01,=/" $+C< 3=(*=)" )(=.8**" <" .8'.$(%$" /'" '.BA" ," '1,=+,'(D"
% 1D"4)*=1+*5
P"'0*. (-+C"0'<->.,=2"0'<'/B<"<01'< /,'(="1=E$3 +2="( 3=>-"$,( J"
, "<D803*<="<", %1=.*="*+C",E'/('4+*","%'(.8-8$+-2(D", . /D"/=)okratyczneE'"0 O.8< "01 <(=E'5"]-)". )-)"$)*=.,+, (*="'.BA"<"Z41'/%$")'>="A-J"
0'.81,=E (="<"% 8=E'1* +C", ) +C$"( "<'3('4J"'.'A*.8D"2=/('.8%*5 6"4<*=83="
0'<->.,=E'" <-/ 2=" .*@" %'(*=+,( " ,)* ( " ') <* (=2" 1=E$3 +2*" 0'01,=," 3*%<i/ +2@" *,'3 +-2(=E'" 41'/% " , A=,0*=+, 2D+=E'F" " 1',.,=1,=(*=" % 8 3'E$" 41'd%B<")(*=2"*(< ,-2(-+C"'"+C 1 %8=1,="<'3('4+*'<-)5"
Bibliografia
Akty prawne
Konstytucja Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej z dnia 2 kwietnia 1997 r., Dz. U. 1997 Nr 78, poz. 483.
X&0.-.) ') 1($.) 22) /$&0!#.1.) 2345) 67!) #!&08#!-aniu wobec osób z zaburzeniami psy+,$+'(;C$) &0-.6'.9:+;+,) '.<6!=%($%) =;+$.>) '16!-$.) /*?) -!/(!"+$) &%@&*./(%9) $nnych osób., Dz.U. 2014 r. poz. 24.
Ustawa z dnia 19 kwietnia 1969 r. Kodeks karny, Dz.U. z 1969 r. Nr 13, poz. 94.
Ustawa z 6 czerwca 1997 r.Kodeks karny, Dz.U.1997., Nr 88, poz. 553.
Orzecznictwo
S6'%+'%($%)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<!)')1($.)2R)@-$%0($.)4ZZ[)6., K 11/94
S6'%+'%($%)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<!)')1($.)54)&0;+'($.)4ZZR)67, K 9/95.
17
Zob. $&C!) 6%'%&.)E.6':1*)F%/&$D&@$%9)G*(1.+9$) 6.-)H'I!-$%@.T
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>
ZN nr 100
Problem konstytuc6.*?@-#&,03A&B+,$36&?&C!+,#$-D
117
W;6!@)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<!)' dnia 17 grudnia 1997 r., K 22/96
\;6!@)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<! z dnia 8 marca 2005 r., K27/03
\;6!@)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<!)')1($.)4Z)C.6+.)233V)6.,K47/05
\;6!@)Y6;?*(.I*)K!(&0;0*+;9(%<!)')1($.)4Z)/$&0!#.1.)233W)6., Kp 2/08
Literatura
Wronkowska S., !/&@$%)1;&@*&9%)!)#.D&0-$e prawa, Warszawa 1995.
Inne
Uzasadnienie do projektu ustawy !) #!&08#!-.($*) -!?%+) !&A?) ') '.?*6'%($.C$) #&y+,$+'(;C$) &0-.6'.9:+;+,) '.<6!=%($%) =;+$.>) '16!-$.) /*?) -!/(!"+$) &%@&*./(%9) $nnych osób; druk sejmowy nr 1577.
$&C!) 6%'%&.)E.6':1*)F%/&$D&@$%9)G*(1.+9$) 6.-)H'I!-$%@.)J.(*0;) 6';-.6;)1!)
Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich prof. Ireny Lipowicz, z dnia 24 stycznia 2014 r.
http://programy.hfhr.pl/monitoringprocesulegislacyjnego/files/2014/01/RPO_ustawaz22lis
t2013_pismo_TK.pdf;
$&C!) 6'%-!1($+':+%<!)K!C$&9$) 6.-)H'I!-$%@.)#6';)L.+'%/(%9)M.1'$%)N1-o@.+@$%9).1-7)O$@!I.9.) $%06'.@.)1!)O$($&06.)P#6.-$%1/$-!"+$)O.6@.)Q$%6(.+@$%<!)
z dnia 16 maja 2013 r.
http://adwokatura.pl/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/2013-05-16-pismo-do-MS-w-sprawieprojektu-ustawy-o-post%C4%99powaniu-wobec-os%C3%B3b-zaburzonychpsychicznie-2.pdf
Opinia Krajowej M.1.)P:1!-($+0-.)')1(.)4V)C.9.)2345)67
http://krs.pl/pl/dzialalnosc/posiedzenia-rady/f,99,posiedzenia-w-2013-r/73,14-17-maja2013/881,opinia-krajowej-rady-sadownictwa-z-dnia-17-maja-2013-r-nr-wok-0205413
ZN nr 100
!"#$%&'()#*#+,"$-.$&#&/$"01(0$*#!&89:;9<=>