WP5_ National case study Poland (Polish version)
Transkrypt
WP5_ National case study Poland (Polish version)
With the support of the Lifelong Learning Programme of the European Union „Identifying Barriers in Promoting the European Standards and Guidelines for Quality Assurance at Institutional Level“ IBAR Agreement number – 2010 – 4663/001 - 001 WP5 Internal Quality Assurance Systems National study –Polish version 2011 This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This publication reflects the views only of the author, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein. ! !"#$%&'!"#!'! ( ! !")'!"#'! ("(# %*+'(! !" # $%&'( ! )* +, -.! *! /0 ) • $ ( 12 0 3 $4 2* 6 + 0*+ 7 60( 8 9 • : ; ! 0 3 3 < 0 1 $6<01(! = 1 0 3 ! ! 1 *+ >>? > >?> > > >* A> 6+ < 6*+ $C / D * C/D( 7 > >+ >* EA> >F !C>+>G> + >> >>?+H>I> J>+*H! +* *+>? !! +*J +*'K4&*+!C*+*L II?) • *+I> >+*H+ • H**+ J>> J6<6 • + M 7 *> H > A >GA M ?*>? • > >I $ (> E>*> +?>+&1N! , '$ # -"#. -!/! 1*"2+$ 4!.5( .1!6( ! 1.6!( #71#( > ** J G *J G + $O 1E > P , ! ++ * *>(>?) • * • >>?> =C1>E >! H*>G •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• 1>*GNGJ%E>$E1& (V1N%2E1&W • • • O 0 =*> > $0 =*> O( VO0=20=OW *XJ>*$OM>(VX2OMW K*EA>1>*G !8!>*>K* KG+$!!(VKE12YYW ' +*J>? I > A> ! 1?> A J > > ? +?+ > >?*+*H *>>>*+*>+>&1N! : ;+(- ' !"-"< ("'+ *=!("( !(> !1!'(1" 1 1>*GNGJ% E>2E1 & O ! 0 =*> 2 0 =*>O * XJ>* 2 OM> K*EA>1>*G !8! >*> H .!"1!( 4! 1 *+ " #- 1 > A 1 > A 1 M* 7 > G : 1.6!?6@ !%! +"!!1!A!!("( $( 1N%>) • H)!*!2>GPFF>*>GGPJ> #-*J • >*>E>$*+( *!R ! >*4JI?+ >?A+** *!-%&'! • +>7>GJ* > $>>?>( • >G+?*GI>> Z; >G > * • >+ )*++,! • >GA+ *> >++) + >? >>G? *J+ >GHL* >+>>>,*J • >? ' ** '' ** ** $>IHL J +I>* (! • *** >** *>>?> • + + > U? >? J + $-PJ?>IP( • +?*I>?GJ>!> $PPR> PFF>( • * * ) > * > **J >> ! :, #$+!$!B(.(1!A+!$B(.(1 #B O0=>) • A)!*!2>G#->*>GGRFFPJ • >*> +H >4 $ E**( ,,P#, >*4J $, + ( + + > +I*> H*J > • +> > , **J +>+ > *** • > 7 >G > P , ! 7 >*A> • >+ )>GA* • >+*>>++)R>GJ+ +?I+? >>*) >G>HG>>>?>>>*?! • >?>*> J)'''''' *>G MMM • >? + + $# F J + F,P#+ J ( • J>> • +?*I*J+>+I*>HO0=+ + • >G*&O0&O3&C! • > :9 "( .!C@+1.!A( (!" #+1 X>) • A)!*!2>GRR>*>GGFPJ> ,*J • >*> X> $ ( *! ! >*4J *> G • +>7>GJ> • >G+?* ?>P,* GI>> Z*; • >H A )*++R,! • >GA+*>>++)>GJ! • >' #,***>?' +I>** P**> +I>** + **9'' #,***>?'' +I>* * , ** > ** ! • + + > U? >? J + $RF,J?>IFP( • 4**R4 * • *I > GJ >! > $R-F > RR >( • * * ) > * + + JGI > > G > ! :: ;".!#71!1.6!$D#1.(1!<;> KE1>) • G)!*!2>GR->*>GGF-J • >*> +HK* KG$*>& K*( *! P ! >*4J * > G+ >+ >> • +> >,>JA **J$>>?> * * *+> * I> * ( F +>+*J> G >**+ • 7>GA>>D+I!>>D+IK*3N* <*+!6I>*>7I>> • G) >G >> > >> = &*+ C+C"C1 # R,2R,2->- • +*>>++)>G • >?G?>' > *>G MMM • >? + + > U? >? J +$-#J?>IF-( • +?*I>?GJ>! $#R>R- >( • > ) > 4 * > **J >> ! , E E ED DA F G , 1.6!?6@ !%! +"!!1!A!!("( $( 1>*G NGJ % *I +*H! T GJ ++ >GH *++>+) ( ? +* +A>+ +*H *>G + 4 > > > >* J + J ( ? *+ > > > *J *>G >>* >JJ #( ? +* +A>+ >+ **++ > > >I +*HL *>G* +* **+ R( ?G*+*H*>G! 1+GJ>*+*H*>G1>*GNGJ%?> >* >I*) • * > > * * + *> *>* * • • • • • * * *>G *+? > HG ?>4 >>>>>* *>>H? >GH*++ >A+A>*>>>?>> +*H? *>G > > * I> >>?>+*H?*>G +>+*>****>G > >* 4 J + J >AJ>>?>+*H?*>G>>JH >>?>+*H? J>+IL*> >A * J >I> > +*H) + + >? H*+ * + *++ >*JG * >$D06&(*JG! 1+ GJ +*H *>G 1>*G ? JA > A > ? * I> > +*H *>G** ) • +*H J*> *>G • +*H J • * +>* * • *+J>*+J! I> > +*H 1N% >>I G [[ *! Q > J >+? +*HL *>G*+*) • >> >*>? J*>G • J • >+*H**>+ • >>J*>H*JJ • +! C >+*H*>G*G+?II+?) • * *>G • >+*H*>+ • ** *>+ • *>+IL*> • > >GH *>+ * >+ >++ *J •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• **>GXJ>*+ • +*A >I>>GA • >* +A HA**>G • >+ * >* ** > > J >* *JA+?I>*** • *>G +*HH*> > *+*H*>G • JGI > >I > + *>G>>G>* • >>>GH*>+*XJ>*+ ?**>G • > >?>4 >+? >JA? > ? ? HLJ • > *+H **+H *>+ * XJ>*+**++ I>+! >> >+*+*H+I> >+*H*>G!E >?I+? >) • A*?G*+*H*>GX> *>>+>>?I) J J J > > J**>G6+< 6*+ >** >> >* * J *>G *J *>G ? >> J > *>+?>*++X ?G >***>+ > > >? >GH *>+ ++ *J >>H* +*>A+* >GH*>+> >GH*>+ +>G4> >+?*+*H*>G A > J >>?> > *EI>1 T8*H6>G! EI> >+*H*>GXJ>*++ +) • >>I>?>GH*>+ ) >*4*>J *++ > J >* * *+ > +* >>>*A> + > > *J > + J ?I*J*>GJ>J*>+?> *++X >J>J>*++X*J >*J>*> > * * *J + ** >HJ>*> >J >J >J**>*H*> • >?> > J >> > + *H H +*H *U*J +>?>GH*>+++*J • > +* >+ > +* I>>G >>G *+ G+ >>J > >GH *>+ > >?> +? J >+? *> + >>J >>GH *>+ >*>G *A+>** • >+I>G4*+?>>* +*H*>G! • • •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• ZT *? > ; > H*J O& * R >*JG H • *G > >J >*JG H > *J > JG+>>+*H*>G • >> Z > >>; + J >*JGH9 7> > *>* • HA* *+ J >*JG H *J >G J *+O& • *>*>* >*JGH J*JHA* *+J>*JG>>GJ O& • > J*>G?! 1>*G > JGI > >+?? > >?>*J > +*H *+>*GH!T? JG>>!Z *G; > ! F F ? L ;GB F? ;BBDBMNDE O<?> P?%Q • 6++) *> >! K* >> + >>?> +*H? *>G HJ>* *! OA >>?> +*H? *>G > + > ? >+?! Q> >GH>* *! K**>+A>G>1N%>* + >+*H • M+ 7 * > +*H I> + > PBQ • 6++) 6> >?*> J>* +*H O>/0>*?*+I • C* $*J*>(7**>J >?/0 • 1>+/0 • K**GJ2* ++>G*J>G * +!+*H*>GV06W • 3>I> <T8*H>>I*+HL*+! PQ • 6++) > IL> *> >+*H • C+H>* *A>I>+*H • QJ > > * * + * >>*J > P;Q • 6++) *> > * *+ >IH * > >? $HL( * >>+ > • =HLJ)>>*>+? +?>+*H! • * + > G >+? > > >> *+ >?+*H NE NDDR BBD BM N DE O<?> P?%Q • > > +H >>?>+*H?>+! • "*K4*7+I>GL+? >+*H! • 0*+>*> *>>+ • TA1 >?1J>G>?>>>>?> +*H? *>G! PBQ • 0*+ 60 +* >* >*J >>J >GJG>G* +!+*H*>G • &1N7+I>GL+? >+*H • 0*+>*> *>>+ PCQ • ^ HL>A*> • 0*+>*> ?Z**?; • 1*>+ >+*H • 6+HIK4* >X P;Q • D>+7>GI>L*+*H+ • "*K4*7+I>GL+? >+*H • 0*+>*> *>>+ • B BBD QM'\6' ' 1\1&=O T0&EC'0C'0806Q^3'7KO"QE\6OMO<\806Q^3') P?%Q • EA>+Z ;! D*++? *>G J J +*H >+IL*>*J*>G! • 6*>>I> >+*HA+I J**>?>4 > +*H! • = *> * G 7 > *> ! • > ? *> J > +*H *>G1N%! • 8*HL*>G+>> H ! PBQ) • EAZ ; • 1>* *J O0= >* > +*H >? >+I +Z ; • >?* J * I+ 7 * I > *+ >*J *+I>K<86 • E> >A J > * G >> J >?+*HO0=>I*>GI*! • E * +*H+ ? > >G +? >*H*J+> O1T86! PCQ • EAZ ; • >?*J*I+ • 1 >+*H>?*+>A • = *G! P;Q • EAZ ; • >?*J*I+>A!I J >>>6<6! • >H*KE1>H>KE1 >> • = *G! • NEC ;%EE P?%Q • > *+? >+IL>AH+*H! • *> +*H>+IL*> • J > > A +*H *>G PBQ • 1>* + O1T86 ?I >I* >>?> > > > > G * <*!8*H6>G PCQ • **>*4*J>O1T86 P;Q • * *> I J > * > + >> >I> ! • *HL>**>H*J++*H