metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i

metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i

Stosunki Międzynarodowe – International Relations
r
nr 1–2 (t.43) 2011
X''&"!#*3(0,
$12345!26789:1;!<8=95!>8?<361; 6!=@=AB:B1!<3AB25CB!:=>8=@B9:@1; B!454=C2591 D23D?@C76!$BE4:5@=8343659F
!" #$%&%'()*" +),&+-()" ./01#2)" %)34'(,(" &'&5(-#2&'(&" 1#5(%6,(" -&./&'(3-')*" -/#7(86"
-&2/#%'9",&/()/:"2"('$%6%03*&34"&,&+);(3,(34<"7&+&23-634<"262(&+#23-634<"&"%&,=)<"
*&,"1#,&-0*9"#;>2(#')"2"%6;"%),?3()"+#?2(&+3-)'(&<"#,&-0*9"$(:"1/-6+&%')"2"+6+&,­
%63)"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634@"A)5);"*)$%"#;>2()'()"-&$&+"$%#$#2&'(&"0$%/0,­
%0/6-#2&'634" %)34'(," 1/&36" ./01#2)*" 2" &'&5(-()" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634<"
1#,&-&'()";#=5(2#?3(<"*&,()"+&*9"%)";)%#+6"#/&-"(34"#./&'(3-)B@"A#"$-3-).>5'()"('%)­
/)$0*93)"-"&,&+);(3,().#"10',%0"2(+-)'(&<"'&/-:+-(&"%)";&*9"-&/>2'#"-&$%#$#2&'()"
7&+&23-)<"*&,"("+6+&,%63-')@"C+1#2(&+&"%#"-&1#%/-)7#2&'(0"1#5(%#5#.>2"1/&30*93634"
'&"26=$-634"03-)5'(&34<",%>/-6"-"*)+')*"$%/#'6"1#$-0,0*9"'#2#3-)$'634";)%#+"&'&­
5(%63-'634" +#" 1/#2&+-)'(&" 28&$'634" 7&+&B<" &" -" +/0.()*" D" 1#-#$%&*9" '&03-63()5&;("
("2"%)*"/#5("-&('%)/)$#2&'("$9"/#-2(*&'();"('$%/0;)'%&/(0;"+6+&,%63-').#@"
! "#!$%&'()!*%+,)-&)./0%
E)%#+#5#.(&"1/&36"./01#2)*"2"&'&5(-()"1#5(%6,("-&./&'(3-')*"'()"*)$%"'(3-6;"'#26;<"
34#F"+#1()/#"2"1()/2$-)*"+),&+-()"GGH"2@"-6$,&8&"$-3-).>5'9"1#105&/'#?F@"I07+6­
$3615('&" 1/#.'#-#2&'()" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2)" #+'#$-93" $(:" +#" #;&2(&'634" %0" %)34'(,"
1#$80.0*)"$(:"#+"+&2'&"%)/;(');"J;)%#+6"4)0/6$%63-')KL@"M&,"1($-)"E(/#$8&2"I08),<"
J;)%#+6"4)0/6$%63-')"$80=9"+#"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);>2"1/-)-"-#/.&'(-#2&'6"26$(­
8),"./016"#$>7KN@"H$%#%9"%)*";)%#+6"'()"*)$%"*)+'&,"$&;#"-&&'.&=#2&'()"2()50"#$>7<"
&"%2>/3-6"34&/&,%)/"1/&36<"(''#2&36*'#?F"*)*")O),%>2@"M&,#"1#+)*?3()"'&0,#2)"4)0­
/6$%6,&"0,$-%&8%#2&8&"$(:"2"5&%&34"PQ"GG"2@3<"&"1/-)8#;#26;"26+&/-)'();"#,&-&8#"
R&"%);&%".)')-6"$8#2&"!"#$%&'%()*+,-.)+"/0%(1-2"34)+2-.&5"0!/)+67,<"!&/$-&2&"LSST<"$@"UVU@
E@"I08),<"6$-8/-5-.)/4"+4+&%9#1)0:"+94;35%/)$-3-."<"!&/$-&2&"NQLQ<"$@"WQ@
3 M@"X'%#$-,()2(3-<"<"'-3%+!"#$%&'%05/"=+>.?$05"+$-5.45%.)/4"+2$-@1"9?.<"!&/$-&2&"LSSQ<"$@"UY@
L"
N"
218
Anna Wojciuk
$(:"+5&"'()*"26'&5)-()'()"1/-)-"X5)Z&"C$7#/'&"%)34'(,("@#$5%+9?58?.V@"E)%#+6"4)0­
/6$%63-')"'&,()/#2&')"$9"'&"/#-2(9-62&'()"1/#75);>2"(",/)&%62')<"?;(&8)"$%&2(&'()"
4(1#%)-<"%)"+/#.("7#2();"1/#2&+-9"+#"#+,/62&'(&"'#2634"1/&2+@"I9"%#";)%#+6"$,8&­
'(&*93)"+#"26*?3(&"1#-&"'&26,#2#"$%#$#2&')"&5.#/6%;6";6?5)'(&"("#%2&/3(&"'&"'()­
$-&75#'#2)"/#-2(9-&'(&@
E)%#+6"4)0/6$%63-')"/#-2(*&*9"$(:"+6'&;(3-'()"-&/>2'#"2"1#+)*?3(&34"(5#?3(#­
2634<"*&,"("2"&'&5(-&34"'&,()/#2&'634"40;&'($%63-'()@"!";&%);&%63)"#/&-"('O#/;&­
%63)" '&5)=9" +#" '&*2&='()*$-634" '&/-:+-(" 2" 7&+&'(&34" '&+" $-%03-'9" ('%)5(.)'3*95@"
[#105&/')"$9"2"7(-')$()"("-&/-9+-&'(0<"$%&'#2(9"'()#+893-'6")5);)'%",05%0/6"#/.&'(­
-&36*')*"'&*7&/+-()*",/)&%62'634"\/;"?2(&%&<"%&,(34"*&,"]##.5)P"3-6"X115)@"R(3"+-(2­
').#<" #+1#2()+'(#" 0$%/0,%0/6-#2&')" ;)%#+6" 1/&36" ./01#2)*" /#-2(*&*9" 1#%)'3*&8"
50+-,(<"3#"1$634#5#.#2()"'&-62&*9"'$"/4/84"9+'.?$05-A04U."C+"1$634#5#.(("1#-'&2­
3-)*"75($,#"*0="+#"+6+&,%6,("D",/)&%62'#?F<",/6%63-')";6?5)'()<"0,()/0',#2&'()"'&"
/#-2(9-62&'()"1/#75);>2<"&"%&,=)"$&;9"-+#5'#?F"+#"1/&36"2"./01()"#/&-",#;0'(,&­
3*:" 02&=&" $(:" -&" '&*3)''()*$-)" 0;()*:%'#?3(" 2" GGH" 2@W" ^$%/0,%0/6-#2&')" ;)%#+6"
1/&36"./01#2)*"03-9"%634"2$-6$%,(34"0;()*:%'#?3(<"1#+#7'()"*&,"26%2&/-&*9"1#3-03()"
2$1>8#+1#2()+-(&5'#?3(" (" 1#-6%62'()" 21862&*9" '&" -+#5'#?3(" #/.&'(-&36*')" (" 1/-6­
2>+3-)@"_&%);"$1)8'(&*9"2()5)",/6%)/(>2"1/-6$-8#?3(#2#"0,()/0',#2&')*"+6+&,%6,(<"
'&,()/#2&')*"'()"%65,#"'&"/#-2>*"2()+-6<"&5)"%&,=)",503-#2634",#;1)%)'3*(@
!"%/&+636*'()"/#-0;(&'634"1/-)+$(:2-(:3(&34"./01#2634",503-#26;"+5&"2$1>8­
1/&36")%&1);"*)$%"O&-&"2$%:1'&@"!"%&,(;";#+)50"#$#76"#+1#2()+-(&5')"-&"26,#'&'()"
-&+&'(&"$1#%6,&*9"$(:".8>2'()"'&"1#3-9%,0"1/&3<"2$1>5'()"#;&2(&*9"1/#75);<"+)\'(0*9"
-&.&+'()'(&"("70+0*9"1/#75);#29";&1:"+&').#"%);&%0@"R&$%:1'()"/#-+-()5&*9";(:+-6"
$()7()"1#$-3-).>5')")5);)'%6"$,8&+#2)<",%>/)"2"-&$&+'(3-)*"3-:?3("/)&5(-0*9"*0="('+6­
2(+0&5'()@"R&",#B3#26;")%&1()"03-)$%'(36"-'>2"1/&30*9"/&-);"'&+"-8#=)'();")5)­
;)'%>2"2"3&8#?F"("0-.#+'()'();"261/&3#2&'634"1/-)-"$()7()"26'(,>2@"^;()*:%'#?F"
$1/&2').#" -&/-9+-&'(&" %&,(;" 1/-)+$(:2-(:3();<" $-3-).>5'()" 2" -'&3-')*" $,&5(<" *)$%"
+0=6;"#$(9.'(:3();<"1#+#7'()"-/)$-%9"*&,"-+#5'#?F"+#1&$#2&'(&"$(:"+#"1#%/-)7"("$%&'­
+&/+>2" 1/&36" ./016" 2" 1/-61&+,0" *)*" $-)/).#2634" 3-8#',>2@" E&',&;)'%);" %/&+6­
36*')*";)%#+6"1/&36"2"./01()"*)$%"*)+'&,"%#<"=)"2",503-#2)*"O&-()"%2>/3-)*"&'&5(-6"
(" /#-2(9-62&'(&" 1/#75);>2" 03-)$%'(36" 1/&30*9" ('+62(+0&5'()@" !" )O),3()" 1/#+0,%"
%&,().#"-7(#/#2).#"26$(8,0"1/-61#;('&"7&/+-()*",#'3)/%"-"0+-(&8);"2()50"$#5($%>2"
'(=",#'3)/%"34>/0@"R()"768#76"%#"1/#75););<".+676"'()"O&,%<"=)"3#/&-"2(:,$-&"5(3-7&"
V"
X@`@" C$7#/'<" B2214"3+ C9)84/)'4-/*+ 6$4/0421"&+ )/3+ 6$-0"3#$"&+ -D+ E$")'4F"+ 6$-@1"9+ G-1F4/8H" R)2"
a#/,"LSTY@
5 E@"I08),<"#1@"3(%@"<"$@"WL@
P"
4%%1bcc222@.##.5)@3#;c3#/1#/&%)c305%0/)@4%;5
U"
d@"R:3,&b">$"/4/8+'.?$05-A04<"C5$-%6'<"LSSN<"$@"LV@
W"
[#/@b"!@"e0(%%<"Success 4/+'!"+E-/0"2'#)1+B8"*+B/-'!"$+2)$)3489+&!4D'@"f)O)/&%"26.8#$-#'6"'&"YN"X'­
'0&5"E))%('."#O"%4)"])#/.(&"d+03&%(#'&5"f)$)&/34"X$$#3(&%(#'<"I&g&''&4<"]X<"C3%#7)/"NP<"NQQU<
4%%1bcc222@)+1$63('%)/&3%(g)@#/.c1&1)/$c3#'3)1%0&5h&.)@1+O@
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
219
-&.&+'()B<" ,%>/6;(" -&*;0*9" $(:" 7&+&3-)" (" 1/&,%636" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634"
-&5(3-&"$(:"+#"-7(#/0"1/#75);>2",#;15),$#2634"("34&/&,%)/6-0*)"$(:"26$#,(;"1#-(#­
;);"'()1)2'#?3(@"
! G#!<,H.H!I!J,+KL%!H!H0HML/H!(H0).*!I)ILH('I./).*
M&,"1#,&-0*9"7&+&'(&"1/#2&+-#')"2"/&;&34"/>='634"+-()+-('"'&0,(<"%2>/3-&"1/&3&"
2"./01()"*)$%"'&*$,0%)3-'()*$-6;"'&/-:+-();"/&+-)'(&"$#7()"-",#;15),$#26;("-&.&+­
'()'(&;("#"'()*&$'634"/#-2(9-&'(&34@"f&1#/%"-"NQQW"/@"'&"%);&%"1/-6$-8#?3("262(&+0"
I4&4-/+JKLM*+B+N1-@)11%+,"'.-$("3+)/3+C/'"8$)'"3+C/'"1148"/0"+O/'"$2$4&""1/-)2(+0*)<"
=)"2"'&*75(=$-634"5&%&34"'&$%91("+&5$-)<"-&$&+'(3-)"1/-)2&/%#?3(#2&'()";)%#+#5#.(("
&'&5(-#2&'(&"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634"'&"1#%/-)76"262(&+#23-)@"C/.&'(-&3*)"
7&/+-#"#./&'(3-9"(5#?F"-&+&B"1#2()/-&'634"1#*)+6'3-6;"),$1)/%#;"'&"/-)3-"1/-)+­
$(:2-(:F"26;&.&*93634"2$1>81/&36"'&"2$-6$%,(34")%&1&34"1/&36"&'&5(%63-')*"("/#-­
2(9-62&'(&" 1/#75);>2@" !$1>81/&3&" #1()/&F" $(:" 7:+-()" *0=" '()" '&" ,##/+6'#2&'(0"
-7(#/#2).#" 26$(8,0<" &5)" '&" /).05&/')*" +6$,0$*(" +#%63-93)*" +&'634<" 2$,&i'(,>2"
("4(1#%)-"2)"2$-6$%,(34"O&-&34"1/&3"&'&5(%63-'634S@"
`(5#-#\(" %)*" #+1#2(&+&" *)+)'" -" 7&/+-()*" -'&'634<" &" -&/&-);" '&*'#2$-634" 1#+­
/:3-'(,>2" +#" &'&5(-6" +&'634" 262(&+#23-634" G'$#0'#$"3+ B/)1%'40+ >"0!/4P#"&+ D-$+
Intelligence AnalysisLQ@ [/&3&" %&" -#$%&8&" #1075(,#2&'&" 1/-)-" 7&+&3-6<" ,%>/-6" ;&*9"
#./#;')"+#?2(&+3-)'()"1/&,%63-')"2"#;&2(&')*"%0"+-()+-('()@"f(34&/+$"e)0)/"*)$%"
2)%)/&');" &;)/6,&B$,().#" 262(&+0" -" 1#'&+" 3-%)/+-()$%#5)%'(;" $%&=);" (" -&/&-);"
&0%#/);"($%#%')*"1075(,&3*("'&0,#2)*"Psychology of Intelligence Analysis, .+-()"2"7&/­
+-()*" %)#/)%63-'6" (" 0$6$%);&%6-#2&'6" $1#$>7" 1/-)+$%&2(&" %61#2)" 108&1,(<" 2" ,%>/)"
21&+&" 50+-(" 0;6$8" 2>23-&$<" .+6" 1/>70*)" &'&5(-#2&F" %&," -8#=#')" 1/#75);6<" *&," %)<"
-",%>/6;(";&;6"+#"3-6'()'(&"2"$%#$0',&34";(:+-6'&/#+#2634LL@"f&'+#514"[4)/$#'<"
+/0.(" -" &0%#/>2<" ;#=)" 1#342&5(F" $(:" '();&5" %/-6+-()$%#5)%'(9" 1/&,%6,9" &'&5(%6,&"
262(&+0<"&"-&/&-);"-'&3-936;"+#/#7,();"2"#7$-&/-)"$-,#5)'(&"-"%)34'(,"&'&5(%63-­
'634<"-&/>2'#"'&"1#%/-)76"&.)'3*("262(&+#23-634<"*&,"("\/;"1/62&%'634<"2"$-3-)­
.>5'#?3(" -&?" 7(-')$0LN@" [4)/$#'" 1#?2(:3(8" +-()$(:F" 5&%" $2#*)*" ,&/()/6" -&2#+#2)*"
261/&3#262&'(0" %&,(34" '&/-:+-(" &'&5(%63-'634<" ,%>/)" 1#-2#59" -;('(;&5(-#2&F"
/6-6,#" %61#2634" 78:+>2" #1($&'634" 1/-)-" e)0)/&<" /#-70+-9" 26#7/&i'(:" (" ,/)&%62­
S"
I4&4-/+JKLM*+B+N1-@)11%+,"'.-$("3+)/3+C/'"8$)'"3+C/'"1148"/0"+O/'"$2$4&"<"!&$4('.%#'"j@A@"NQQW<"
$@"LY@
LQ"
f@M@"e)0)/"M/@<"f@e@"[4)/$#'<"G'$#0'#$"3+B/)1%'40+>"0!/4P#"&+D-$+C/'"1148"/0"+B/)1%&4&<"!&$4('.%#'"
j@A@"NQLQ@
LL"
f@M@" e)0)/" M/<" Psychology of Intelligence Analysis," A)'%)/" O#/" %4)" I%0+6" #O" H'%)55(.)'3)<" A)'%/&5"
H'%)55(.)'3)"X.)'36<"LSSS<",$(9=,&"+#$%:1'&"'&"$%/#'()"4%%1$bcc222@3(&@.#gc5(7/&/6c3)'%)/kO#/k%4)k$%0+6k#O­
k('%)55(.)'3)c3$(k1075(3&%(#'$c7##,$k&'+k;#'#./&14$c1$634#5#.6k#Ok('%)55(.)'3)k&'&56$($c('+)Z@4%;5
LN"
[#/@b"4%%1bcc222@14)/$#'@#/.c@
220
Anna Wojciuk
'#?F"50+-(<"&"-&/&-);"0$%0/0,%0/6-0*9"1/#3)$"&'&5(%63-'6"%&,<"76"0'(,'9F"34&#$0"("/#-­
1/:=)'(&@"j034&"%)*";)%#+#5#.(("+#7/-)"#++&*)"4&$8#"\/;6",#'$05%('.#2)*"'&5)=93)*"
+#"[4)/$#'&b"Q$")(+94/3&"'&=+C/&'411+$48-$=+R"F"$)8"+49)84/)'4-/+l3#";#='&"1/-)8#=6F"
'&"1#5$,(b"6$5"S)9+&0!"9)'=+T)2$-.)3U+S)3=+VU.48/4:+.%-@$)U/4;mLY@"
M0=" 2" 1()/2$-6;" -+&'(0" #;&2(&').#" 1#+/:3-'(,&" &0%#/-6" -2/&3&*9" 02&.:<" '&"
O0'+&;)'%&5'9"%/&'$O#/;&3*:";6?5)'(&"#"$%#$0',&34";(:+-6'&/#+#2634<",%>/)"1/-)­
$%&*)" 76F" 2$1>83-)?'()" +-()8);" -'&,#;(%634" 34#F76" $#5($%>2<" &" $%&*)" $(:" +#;)'9"
2$1>81/&36"2"./01()"),$1)/%>2LV@"!6;()'(&*9"3-%)/6"1#2#+6"%)*"-;(&'6@"
[#"1()/2$-)<";>2(9"#"#;&2(&')*"*0="1#26=)*"/#$'93)*"-8#=#'#?3("1/#75);>2"("(34"
3#/&-"7&/+-()*";05%(+6$3615('&/')*"'&%0/-)@"]5#7&5'6",/6-6$"\'&'$#26<"-&.&+'()'()"
#3()15)'(&",5(;&%0"("/)2#503*(")')/.)%63-')*"%#"'&*7&/+-()*"-'&')"1/-6,8&+6"26-2&B"
;(:+-6'&/#+#2634<",%>/634"'()"$1#$>7"7&+&F"#./&'(3-&*93"$(:"%65,#"+#";)%#+#5#.(("
-"-&,/)$0"'&0,("#"$%#$0',&34";(:+-6'&/#+#2634@"M)+'&,"%&,=)"/-0%"#,&"'&";'()*"$,#;­
15(,#2&')" &$1),%6" 7)-1()3-)B$%2&" 1&B$%2<" *&," 1/#5(O)/&3*&" '0,5)&/'&" 3-6" %)//#/6-;"
1#,&-0*)<"=)"+5&"-/#-0;()'(&"%)*"1/#75);&%6,("'()-7:+'&"*)$%"2()+-&"-"+-()+-('"'(),()+6"
7&/+-#"#+5).8634"#+"%/&+636*'()"1#*;#2&'634"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634@"j#7/6;"
1/-6,8&+);"?/)+'(#%)/;('#2)*"1/#.'#-6";(:+-6'&/#+#2)*<"26,#/-6$%0*93)*"2()+-:"
),$1)/%>2"-"/>='634"+-()+-('"*)$%"/&1#/%"N1-@)1+>$"/3&+JKJM*+B+>$)/&D-$9"3+7-$13LT. [#"+/0.()<"2$1>81/&3&"2"-+62)/$6\,#2&'634"./01&34"1#;&.&"$-67,#"+-()5(F"$(:"
2()+-9"1#-&"./&'(3&;("1#$-3-).>5'634"#/.&'(-&3*("("70+#2&F"-&0O&'()";(:+-6"),$­
1)/%&;("/)1/)-)'%0*936;("/>=')"('$%6%03*)@"n&,&"2$1>81/&3&"3-:$%#"#,&-0*)"$(:"%/0+­
'()*$-&"'(=";#=)"$(:"%#"26+&2&F"1#$%/#'');0"#7$)/2&%#/#2("D"#/.&'(-&3*)"#"-75(=#­
'634" ,#;1)%)'3*&34" (" -&+&'(&34" ;&*9" 7#2();" 3-:$%#" %)'+)'3*:" +#" /62&5(-#2&'(&"
;(:+-6" $#79" (" '()34:%'()" +-()59" $(:" 2()+-9<" -28&$-3-&" *)?5(" ;#=)" #'&" +)36+#2&F"
#"1#5(%63-'634"21862&34"+&')*"('$%6%03*(@"
[#"%/-)3()<"2()+-&"("+#?2(&+3-)'()"$%&*9"$(:"3#/&-"7&/+-()*"/#-1/#$-#')"("1/#3)$"
&'&5(-6" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634" 1#2('()'" 02-.5:+'(&F" '()" %65,#" $%&'#2($,#"
),$1)/%>2" (" &'&5(%6,>2<" ,%>/-6" -&2#+#2#" -&*;0*9" $(:" 7&+&'();" +&').#" 1/#75);0<"
&5)"%&,=)"#$>7"#"(''6;"+#?2(&+3-)'(0"-&2#+#26;<"+)36+)'%>2"1#5(%63-'634<"+615#­
;&%>2" (" 0/-:+'(,>2<" +-()''(,&/-6<" 1/-)+$%&2(3()5(" #/.&'(-&3*(" 1#-&/-9+#2634"
("2$-6$%,(34"(''634"('%)/)$&/(0$-6<",%>/-6";#.9"1#$(&+&F"#/6.('&5'6"2.59+"2"&'&5(­
-#2&')"-&.&+'()'()@"
[#" 3-2&/%)" 2/)$-3()<" ;)%#+6" 1/&36" ./01#2)*" 2" ;#=5(2()" />='#/#+'6;" ?/#+#­
2($,0" ),$1)/%>2" 1#-2&5&*9" 2)/6\,#2&F" %-2@" ;#+)5" ;)'%&5'6<" 3-65(" 01/#$-3-#'6"
$-,()5)%" 1/#75);0<" 70+#2&'6" 2" 0;6?5)" 3-8#2(),&<" &" #7)*;0*936" *).#" /#-0;()'()" (",#'3)1%0&5(-&3*:<"3-:?3("$,8&+#2)"("-&.&+'()'(&"1#2(9-&')"#/&-"/)5&3*)";(:+-6"'(;(@"
n80;@"E&.+&5)'&"o/&23-6,kf&+2&'
f@M@"e)0)/"M/@<"f@e@"[4)/$#'<"#1@"3(%@<"$@"Y@
LT"
N1-@)1+ >$"/3&+ JKJM*+B+ >$)/&D-$9"3+ 7-$13H+ !&$4('.%#'" j@A@b" R&%(#'&5" H'%)55(.)'3)" A#0'3(5p" ^I"
]#g)/';)'%"[/('%('."CO\3)<"NQQW<"/&1#/%"+#$%:1'6"'&"4%%1bcc222@+'(@.#gc'(3cRHAhNQNTh1/#*)3%@4%;5
LY"
LV"
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
221
! N#!<,'OM%P)!K%,.%K.QL
E#+)5";)'%&5'6"*)$%".8:7#,#"-&,#/-)'(#'6;"2"0;6$8&34"&'&5(%6,>2"1/-),#'&'();"
'&" %);&%" ;)34&'(-;0" O0',3*#'#2&'(&" *&,().#?" )5);)'%0" =63(&" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2).#"
("*)$%"#'"-&/&-);"7&/+-#"%/0+'6"+#"-;(&'6@"M)+'&,<"*&,"1#,&-0*9"7&+&'(&<"$%)/)#%61"
%)'"$%&'#2("'&*3-:$%$-9"1/-63-6':"78:+>2"2"&'&5(-()"("2"1/#.'#-#2&'(0"$%#$0',>2"
;(:+-6'&/#+#2634LP@"q0+-()<".+6"-&7()/&*9"$(:"+#"7&+&'(&"*&,().#?"1/#75);0<"'(.+6"
'()"/#7(9"%).#"-""J3-6$%6;"0;6$8);r<"-&2$-)";&*9"*0="1)2')""J1/-)+k$9+6r"'&"+&'6"
%);&%<"+6$1#'0*9"*&,(;?"+#?2(&+3-)'();"("2()+-9"("'&"'(34"70+0*9"$2#*9"1)/$1),%62:"
507"10',%"2(+-)'(&<",%>/)"'&-62&;6";#+)5);";)'%&5'6;@"E#+)5"%)'"3-:$%#"1#+?2(&­
+#;()" 1#+1#2(&+&" &'&5(%6,#;<" 3-).#" 1#$-0,(2&F<" *&,()" 16%&'(&" -&+&2&F<" 3#" *)$%"
($%#%')"#/&-"*&,"('%)/1/)%#2&F"%#<"3#"$(:"2(+-(@"n)'";#+)5<"261/&3#2&'6"2"%#,0")+0­
,&3*("#/&-"1/&,%6,("-&2#+#2)*"1)8'("7&/+-#"($%#%')"O0',3*)<"0;#=5(2(&"7#2();"$&;#"
O0',3*#'#2&'()" &1&/&%0" 1#-'&23-).#" 3-8#2(),&" #/&-" 1#-2&5&" 1/-)1/#2&+-&F" ,&=­
+).#" +'(&" +-()$(9%,(" %/&O'634" /#-0;#2&B@" _&2#+-(" #'" *)+'&," 3-:$%#" 2" 1/-61&+,0"
-8#=#'634<"2()5#&$1),%#2634"-&.&+'()B<"2",%>/634"+#+&%,#2#"-'&3-'6"*)$%"1#-(#;"
'()1)2'#?3("("'();&89"/#5:"#+./62&*9"-+&/-)'(&"#"34&/&,%)/-)"5#$#26;@"
f#7)/%"M)/g($"2"-'&,#;(%)*"1/&36"6"$0"2'4-/+)/3+<4&2"$0"2'4-/+4/+C/'"$/)'4-/)1+
Politics $-3-).>8#2#"#;&2(&<"*&,"+-(&8&"#1($62&'6";#+)5";)'%&5'6"("+#7/-)"1#,&-0*)"
1/>."-&2#+'#?3("&5.#/6%;(3-').#";6?5)'(&<"'&2)%"2"$6%0&3*(<".+6"&'&5(-6"+#,#'0*)"
'&*-'&,#;(%$-6"),$1)/%k$#5($%&LU@"[/&3&"M)/g($&"'&"5(3-'634"1/-6,8&+&34"+#2#+-(<"*&,"
%/0+'#" *)$%" 1#+2&=&F" -&8#=)'(&" /#-0;#2&B<" ,%>/6;(" $(:" #1)/0*)" #/&-" +#,#'62&F"
,#/),%"2"1)/3)13*(@"X'&5(%636"("+)36+)'3("1#5(%63-'(";&*9"$,8#''#?F"+#"'()+#$%/-).&­
'(&"507"1#;'()*$-&'(&"-'&3-)'(&"%634"O&,%>2<",%>/)"'()"1&$0*9"+#";#+)50";)'%&5').#<"
2"/&;&34",%>/).#"#1)/0*9@"!6,&-0*9"'&%#;(&$%"%)'+)'3*:"+#"263426%62&'(&"1/-)+)"
2$-6$%,(;"%634"('O#/;&3*(<",%>/)"1&$0*9"+#"%).#<"3#"*0="2()+-9"#"+&'6;"1/#75);()@"
n&"$8&7#?F",#.'(%62'&"*)$%"'&*3-:$%$-6;"1#2#+);"78:+'634"&'&5(-"$%#$0',>2";(:­
+-6'&/#+#2634"2"1/-)8#;#2634"+5&"?2(&%&";#;)'%&34@"E)%#+6"&'&5(%63-')"1/#1#­
'#2&')"1/-)-"e)0/&"("[4)/$#'&";&*9"'&"3)50"08&%2()'()"26$%&2()'(&"'&"1/>7:"+#;(­
'0*93634"-&8#=)B<"1#-2&5&*9"'&",&=+6;")%&1()"1/#3)$0"&'&5(%63-').#"2/>3(F"+#"O0'­
+&;)'%&5').#"1#-(#;0"1/-)$8&'),"("-&+&F"16%&'()"#"(34"$80$-'#?F@"
^$%/0,%0/6-#2&')"%)34'(,("&'&5(%63-')"08&%2(&*9"-"*)+')*"$%/#'6"$1#%,&'()"50+-("
#"#+;()''634"+#?2(&+3-)'(&34<"1#;&.&*9"(;"2"$2#7#+')*"26;(&'()";6?5(<"&"%&,=)"
70+0*9"&%;#$O)/:"%2>/3-).#<"'()$,/:1#2&').#";6?5)'(&"#"-&.&+'()'(&34";(:+-6'&­
/#+#2634@" _" +/0.()*" *)+'&," $%/#'6" -&1)2'(&*9" +#$%&%)3-'()" $(5'6" O0'+&;)'%" 2$1>8­
1/&36<" +-(:,(" ,%>/);0" 26%/93)'()" -" 1#-'&23-).#" status quo<" ,%>/)" *)$%" '()-7:+'6;"
)5);)'%);" ,/)&%62').#" ;6?5)'(&<" '()" #$(9.&" '&+;()/').#" 1#-(#;0@" _76%" +0=&" LP"
[#/@"M@"j&g($<"7!%+Q)3+>!4/8&+W)22"/+'-+N--3+B/)1%&'&<"2b"f@_@"])#/.)<"M@s@"s/03)l/)+@m<"Analy­
54/8+C/'"1148"/0"*+X$484/&H+X@&')01"&H+)/3+C//-F)'4-/&<"!&$4('.%#'"j@A@"NQQW@
LU"
[#/@"f@"M)/g($<"6"$0"2'4-/+)/3+<4&2"$0"2'4-/+4/+C/'"$/)'4-/)1+6-14'40&<"[/('3)%#'<"LSUP<"$@"LLUD"NQN@
222
Anna Wojciuk
'()/>2'#2&.&"1#-'&23-&"+#1/#2&+-(F";#=)"7#2();"+#"/#-1&+0"3&8).#"1/#3)$0"./0­
1#2).#@"J[/-)1($r"1#$%:1#2&'(&"2"1/&36"./01#2)*"*)$%"7&/+-#"($%#%'6"("1/)36-6*'6<"
%&,"76"-&1)2'(F"$%&7(5'#?F"(")O),%62'#?F"2$1>81/&36@"H'$%/0,3*)"1#$%:1#2&'(&"2"1/&36"
./01#2)*" 762&*9" '&2)%" 1#/>2'62&')" +#" $%&'+&/+#2634" 1/#3)+0/" #1)/&36*'634"
2"2#*$,0"l&'.@b"IC["D"&')/3)$3+-2"$)'4/8+2$-0"3#$"m@"o$(9=,&"e)0)/&"("[4)/$#'&"03-6"
1#'&+"$-)?F+-()$(:3(0"$-3-).>8#2634"%)34'(,"&'&5(%63-'634"+5&"2$-6$%,(34"O&-"7&+&2­
3-634<"1#3-92$-6"#+"O#/;08#2&'(&"$&;).#"1/#75);0<"&"$,#B3-62$-6"'&"(;15);)'­
%&3*("(")2&50&3*(")O),%>2"1/#3)$0"&'&5(%63-').#"-"1)/$1),%626"3-&$0@"!"%6;";()*$30"
34#+-("*)+'&,"'()"%655)"#"1/-)+$%&2()'()"1#$-3-).>5'634"'&/-:+-(<"(5)"#"-&1/)-)'%#2&­
'()"#.>5'634"-&$&+"7&+&'(&"1/#75);&%6,(";(:+-6'&/#+#2)*";)%#+9"1/&36"-)$1#8#2)*@
`(5#-#\&"0$%/0,%0/6-#2&'634"%)34'(,"&'&5(%63-'634";>2(<"=)"'&2)%"*)?5("*&,()?"
'&/-:+-()";#=)"-#$%&F"-&$%#$#2&')"1/-)-"('+62(+0&5').#"7&+&3-&<",&=+6")%&1"1/&36"
'&+"+&'6;"-&.&+'()'();"1#2('()'"76F"2"$6$%);&%63-'6"("%/&'$1&/)'%'6"$1#$>7"0-)­
2':%/-'(&'6"2"O#/;()<"+-(:,(",%>/)*"./01&";#=)"8&%2#"26;()'(&F"$(:"$1#$%/-)=)'(&;(<"
70+#2&F" '&" 0$%&5)'(&34" (''634" 3-8#',>2" #/&-" 2" '()$,/:1#2&'6" $1#$>7" 1#++&2&F"
,/6%63)"1#$-3-).>5')"O/&.;)'%6"&'&5(-6LW@"j-(:,("%&,()*";)%#+-()"1/&36"&'&5(%6,"'()­
0$%&''()",#'O/#'%0*)"$(:"-"#+;()''6;("1)/$1),%62&;("(",#',0/)'36*'6;("('%)/1/)%&­
3*&;(<"1#5);(,&"*)$%"3-6;?"('$%6%03*#'&5'()"270+#2&'6;"2"1/#3)$<"#++-()5&*93"*0="
-&"1#;#39"$&;)*";)%#+#5#.((",/6%6,:"-&1/#1#'#2&')*"&'&5(-6"#+",/6%6,("#$#76"),$­
1)/%&@"R&/-:+-(&"$%/0,%0/6-0*9"-&%);"-&/>2'#"('+62(+0&5')";6?5)'()<"*&,"("('%)/&,3*)"
;(:+-6"&'&5(%6,&;("2"-)$1#5)"507"2"2(:,$-)*"./01()@"[/#3)$"+#34#+-)'(&"+#"1#$-3-)­
.>5'634",#',50-*("3-9$%,#2634"*)$%"1/-)*/-6$%6<"&",&=+6",#5)*'6",/#,";#=)"$%&F"$(:"
1/-)+;(#%);"+6$,0$*("2"./01()@"R#2)"('O#/;&3*)"("1#;6$86"1#*&2(&*93)"$(:"2"%/&,3()"
7&+&'(&";#.9"$2#7#+'()"('$1(/#2&F"(''634"03-)$%'(,>2<"&",#5)*')"(+))";&*9"$-&'$:"
$%&F"$(:";'#='(,();"1#;6$8#2#?3("3&8)*"./016@"M)$%"%#<"-+&'();"&0%#/>2<"#1%6;&5'&"
#/.&'(-&3*&"1/&36<"*)?5("343)"$(:"$%6;05#2&F"%2>/3-)<"(''#2&36*')";6?5)'()@"!$1>5')"
/#-2(9-62&'()"1/#75);0"*)$%"1#+)*?3();"-&$&+'(3-#"#+;()''6;"'(="#1($&'&"26=)*"
%/&+636*'&"1/&3&"2"./01()<"2"/&;&34",%>/)*",&=+6"+#$%&*)"O/&.;)'%"2(:,$-).#"-&+&'(&"
(" $&;#+-()5'()" 1/&30*)" '&+" '(;<" 2" ;('(;&5'6;" -&,/)$()" ,#'$05%0*93" $(:" 2" %/&,3()"
-" (''6;(" 3-8#',&;(" -)$1#80@" !" $6%0&3*(<" .+6" 50+-()" 7&+&*9" -8#=#')" -&.&+'()'()<"
$6')/.(&"2()50"0;6$8>2"+&*)"+0=#"5)1$-)")O),%6"'(="'&;6$8"$&;#%').#"&'&5(%6,&LS@
R&/-:+-(&" 1/&36" ./01#2)*" 2" &'&5(-()" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634" ;&*9" %)="
$2#*)"$8&7#?3(@"A-8#',#2()"-)$1#80";#.9"21&?F"2"108&1,(";6?5)'(&"./01#2).#"507"
1#++&F" $(:" 21862#2(" +#;('0*93634" 2" +&')*" -7(#/#2#?3(" *)+'#$%),@" ^$%/0,%0/6-#­
2&')"%)34'(,("&'&5(%63-')"-&2()/&*9"2()5)"J2)'%65("7)-1()3-)B$%2&r<";&*93634"#34/#­
'(F" ./01:" 1/-)+" +#;('&3*9" '&*$(5'()*$-634" *)*" 03-)$%'(,>2" (" 26+#76F" 1)/$1),%626"
/)1/)-)'%#2&')" 1/-)-" 3-8#',>2" #" ;'()*$-)*" $(5)" 1/-)7(3(&<" ,%>/-6" ;#.9" 2'()?F" +#"
+6$,0$*("#+;()'')<"($%#%')"10',%6"2(+-)'(&<"#"(5)"-&1)2'("$(:"(;";#=5(2#?F"("7)-1()­
LW"
LS"
f@M@"e)0)/"M/@<"f@e@"[4)/$#'<"#1@3(%@<"$@"V@
H7(+);<"$@"PDU@
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
223
3-)B$%2#" 261#2()+-(@" E)%#+6" %)" -&1)2'(&*9" %)=" )O),%62'9" ,#;0'(,&3*:" 2" ./01()"
#$>7" 1#$80.0*93634" $(:" '(),()+6" #+;()''6;(" *:-6,&;(" 1/#O)$*#'&5'6;(" #/&-" 03-9"
%/&O')*" +),#;1#-63*(" 1/#75);0" '&" 3-:?3(" $,8&+#2)@" [#+1#2(&+&*9<" *&," /&+-(F" $#7()"
2"+0=6;("(5#?3(&;("+&'634<"76"'()"$%/&3(F"-"#3-0"%).#<"3#"*)$%"-&$&+'(3-6;"1/#75)­
;);"+#"/#-2(9-&'(&@"R()7&.&%)5')"-'&3-)'()"+5&"%2>/3-)*"1/&36"2"./01()";&"%&,=)"
/#-2>*"%)34'#5#.((",#;0'(,&36*'634"("('O#/;&%63-'634"#/&-"'()2()5,(",#$-%"(34"-&$%#­
$#2&'(&@"s)-1/)3)+)'$#26;"08&%2()'();"*)$%"'&"1/-6,8&+";#=5(2#?F"2$1>5')*")+6­
3*(" +#,0;)'%>2" -&" 1#?/)+'(3%2);" H'%)/')%0<" 21/#2&+-&'(&" '&" 7()=93#" 1#1/&2),<"
&"%&,=)"+-()5)'(&"$(:",#;)'%&/-&;("-"-&34#2&'();"#/6.('&5').#"%),$%0@"A#/&-"1#10­
5&/'()*$-)"$9"%&,=)"'&/-:+-(&"+#"2(-0&5(-&3*("1/#75);0<"08&%2(&*93)"1/)-)'%&3*:"2"O#/­
;()" ./&\3-')*" -8#=#').#" -&.&+'()'(&" 1#" *).#" +),#;1#-63*(" '&" 3-6''(,(" 1()/2$-)@"
R&/-:+-(&"%#"#3-62(?3()"'()"2$-6$%,#<"'&2)%"'&*5)1$-)"'()"1#;#.9<"*)?5("&'&5(%6,#;"
7/&,#2&F"7:+-()"2()+-6<"+#?2(&+3-)'(&"507"26#7/&i'(NQ@
[#+$%&2#26;" -&/-0%);" 2#7)3" %)34'(," 1/&36" ./01#2)*" 2" &'&5(-()" $%#$0',>2"
;(:+-6'&/#+#2634"*)$%"3-&$#348#''#?F"1/#3)$0@"_+&'();")'%0-*&$%>2"*)+'&,<"*)$%"%#"
.8>2'()" 1/#75);" 28&?3(2)*" #/.&'(-&3*(" 1/&36" (" 26/#7()'(&" 0" 3-8#',>2" ./016" #1%6­
;&5')*"/>2'#2&.(";(:+-6"%2>/3-9"$2#7#+9"261#2(&+&'(&"$2#(34";6?5("#/&-"$&;#­
+6$3615('9"("?2(&+#;#?3(9"%).#<"3#"*)$%"1/-)+;(#%);"("3)5);"1/#3)$0"&'&5(%63-').#@"
!"1/&,%63)"2()5)"-"%)34'(,"'()"'&5)=6"+#"3-&$#348#''634<"&".+6"3-8#',#2()"./016"
#1&'0*9"-&$&+6"1/&36<"1/#3)+0/6"%)"1#-2&5&*9"2/:3-"'&"-'&3-939"#$-3-:+'#?F"3-&$0@"
j-()5)'()" $(:" '&2-&*);" 2()+-9" (" +#?2(&+3-)'(&;(" #/&-" 03-)'()" $(:" 50+-(" #+" $()7()"
1#-2&5&" ('+62(+0&5');0" &'&5(%6,#2(" -&#$-3-:+-(F" 2()5)" .#+-('<" ,%>/)" 2" %/&+636*­
'6;" ;#+)50" 1/&36" ;0$(" #'" 1#?2(:3(F" '&" -.8:7()'()" />='634" 29%,>2" -&.&+'()'(&<"
,%>/)" #$%&%)3-'()" ;&*9" ;&/.('&5')" -'&3-)'()" +5&" 26,#'62&').#" -&+&'(&@" [#-&" %6;"
+-()5)'()"$(:"2()+-9"'&",&=+6;")%&1()"#./&'(3-&"/6-6,#"1/-)#3-)'(&"*&,(34?"($%#%'634"
3-6''(,>2"1/-)-"3-:?F"./016@"
! R#!<,H.H!I!J,+KL%!H!S,%H&)I0%!,'/ILT/)IH0L%!K,'OM%PUI
s6F";#=)"*)+'&,"%)34'(,("%)"$9"+#"%).#"$%#1'(&"26$1)3*&5(-#2&')"("26;&.&*93)<"=)"
#"(5)"-&3(),&2(F";#.9"&'&5(%6,>2"1/&30*93634"+5&"('$%6%03*("262(&+#23-634<"#"%65)"
'()"#,&=9"$(:"1/-6+&%')"2"1/&36"7&+&3-&"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634<"'()"2$1#;(­
'&*93"*0="#"+6+&,%63)@"M&,"+#2#+-("1/-6,8&+"1#+/:3-'(,&"e)0)/&"("[4)/$#'&<"#1($6­
2&')"%0"'&/-:+-(&"3()$-9"$(:"+0=6;"-&('%)/)$#2&'();"2"&+;('($%/&3*("1075(3-')*<"'&"
0'(2)/$6%)%&34<" 2" #?/#+,&34" &'&5(%63-'634<" 7(-')$()<" \'&'$&34" (" ;)+636'()NL@" R()"
%65,#"-/)$-%9"2"+-()+-('()"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634"$%#$0*)"$(:"%2>/3-)";)%#+6"
1/&36" 2" ./01()" +#" /#-2(9-62&'(&" -8#=#'634" 1/#75);>2@" _'&3-)'()" 2$1>81/&36"
NQ"
NL"
H7(+);<"$@"P@
H7(+);<"$@"U@
224
Anna Wojciuk
2" '#2#3-)$'6;" 7(-')$()" -#$%&8#" 1/-),#'0*93#" 1#,&-&')" 2" 7)$%$)55)/-)" -" NQQP" /@"
74(4/-940&=+ W-.+ <)&&+ E-11)@-$)'4-/+ E!)/8"&+ OF"$%'!4/8NN@" !" $2#*)*" '&*'#2$-)*"
,$(9=3)"<)0$-.4(4/-940&*+Y"@--'4/8+Q#&4/"&&+)/3+'!"+7-$13<"j#'"n&1$3#%%"("X'%4#'6"
!(55(&;$" 1/-),#'0*9<" =)" 1#26=$-6" ;#+)5" 2" -&2/#%'6;" %);1()" 01#2$-)34'(8" $(:"
2"3(9.0",(5,0"#$%&%'(34"5&%"("(''#2&36*'#?F"./016"50+-("-'&*+0*)"5(3-')"("2&=')"-&$%#­
$#2&'(&" *0=" '()" %65,#" 2" 7(-')$()<" &5)" 2" '&03)<" &+;('($%/&3*(" (" )+0,&3*(NY@" _+&'();"
&0%#/>2<"2"GGH"2@"'&*5)1()*"1#/&+-9"$#7()"%)"#/.&'(-&3*)"("./016"50+-(<",%>/)"3)34#­
2&F"7:+-()"1(:F"O0'+&;)'%&5'634"-&$&+b"2$1>81/&3&<"#%2&/%#?F<",05%0/&"+-()5)'(&"$(:"
2()+-9<";#/&5')"/).086"./6"#/&-"2$1>8-&5)='#?3(@"j#"1#+#7'634"2'(#$,>2"+#34#+-9"
7&+&3-)" &'&5(-0*936" i/>+8&" $0,3)$0" '&*5)1$-634" \/;" +#/&+3-634" -&*;0*93634" $(:"
-&/>2'#"-5)3)'(&;("-"$),%#/&"1/62&%').#<"*&,"("1075(3-').#NV@"[&05"`/(.&"1/-)+$%&2(&"
;)%#+6"-)$1#8#2).#"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);>2"$%#$#2&')"2"2(#+93634"\/;&34",#'­
$05%('.#2634@" _&02&=&" #'<" =)" 2$-6$%,()" $%/&%).(3-')" +)36-*)" $9" %&;" 1#+)*;#2&')"
2"26'(,0"1/&36"./016"#$>7<"'(.+6"-&?"('+62(+0&5'()NT@"_7()='#?F"1#;6$8>2"*)$%"'()k
_7()='#?F"1#;6$8>2"*)$%"'()­
1/-61&+,#2&<"-&/>2'#"'&/-:+-(&"&'&5(-6"+&'634"262(&+#23-634"2"$%#$0',&34";(:k
(&+#23-634"2"$%#$0',&34";(:­
+-6'&/#+#2634<" 1/)-)'%#2&')" 1/-)-" e)0/&" (" [4)/$#'&<" *&," (" '#2#3-)$')" %)34'(,("
$%#$#2&')" 2" &+;('($%/&3*(<" ,#'$05%('.0" (" 7(-')$()" 262#+-9" $(:" -" ;)%#+#5#.((" %-2@"
1/#3)$0",/)&%62').#"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);>2NP<"#1/&3#2&')*"2"5&%&34"TQ@"GG"2@"
1/-)-"X5)Z&"C$7#/'&"("I(+')6&"[&/')$&@"
f#'&5+"e)(O)%-"'&-62&"2()5#&$1),%#2)<"$,#;15(,#2&')"-&.&+'()'(&<"26;&.&­
*93)" ,/)&%62'634" /#-2(9-&B" 26-2&'(&;(" &+&1%&36*'6;(<" 2" 1/-)3(2()B$%2()" +#"
26-2&B" %)34'(3-'634<" .+-()" &5.#/6%;(3-')" ;)%#+6" 1/&36" 1/-6'#$-9" -&+#2&5&*93)"
/#-2(9-&'(&NU@" e)(O)%-" %#" *)+)'" -" '&*5)1()*" #3)'(&'634" 1/-)-" $%0+)'%>2" 1/#O)$#/>2"
e&/g&/+"o)'')+6"I34##5"#O"]#g)/';)'%<"&"-&/&-);"&0%#/"-'&')*",$(9=,("R")3"$&!42+
Without Easy Answers, ,%>/&"2"3(9.0"'();&5"+20+-()$%0"5&%"+#3-),&8&"$(:",(5,0'&$%0"
26+&B"2"I%&'&34"_*)+'#3-#'634"("%80;&3-)B"'&"1#'&+"+2&+-()?3(&"*:-6,>2@"[/&3&"
%&"1/-),#'0*)<"=)"26-2&'(&"&+&1%&36*')"26;&.&*93)",/)&%62').#";6?5)'(&"2"./01()"
#$>7" +#%63-9" 2" -&$&+-()" 2$-6$%,(34" +-()+-('" =63(&" 50+-,().#<" 2"%6;" 1#+&*)" 5(3-')"
1/-6,8&+6"-"+-()+-('6"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634NW@"
j@" n&1$3#%%<" X@" !(55(&;$<" 74(4/-940&=+ W-.+ <)&&+ E-11)@-$)'4-/+ E!)/8"&+ OF"$%'!4/8<" [)'.0('"
s##,$<"q#'+#'"NQQP@
NY"
j@"n&1$3#%%<"X@"!(55(&;$<+<)0$-.4(4/-940&*+Y"@--'4/8+Q#&4/"&&+)/3+'!"+7-$13<"R)2"a#/,"NQLQ@
NV"
[#/@"[@"`/(.&<">!"+<0Z4/&"%+O/8)8"9"/'*+B+6-."$D#1+>--1(4'+[-$+<-$"+OD\04"/'+)/3+ODD"0'4F"+>")9+
6$-@1"9+ G-1F4/8<" NQQWp" d@" f&$()5<" >!"+ <0Z4/&"%+ <4/3*+ ]/3"$&')/34/8+ )/3+ C921"9"/'4/8+ '!"+ 6$-@1"9­
^G-1F4/8+>--1&+)/3+<)/)8"9"/'+>"0!/4P#"&+-D+'!"+7-$13_&+>-2+G'$)'"840+E-/&#1'4/8+[4$9<"NQQLp"d@"f&$()5<"
The McKinsey Way<"LSSSp"A@"I%)/'<">!"+Q-&'-/+E-/&#1'4/8+N$-#2+-/+G'$)'"8%*+E1)&&40+E-/0"2'&+)/3+,".+
Perspectives<"NQQP@
NT"
[@"`/(.&<"#1@"3(%@
NP"
X'.@"A/)&%(g)"[/#75);"I#5g('."[/#3)$$
NU"
f@"e)(O)%-<"X@"]/&$4#2<"E@"q('$,6<">!"+6$)0'40"+-D+B3)2'4F"+R")3"$&!42H+A&;7/(+.)"E@X@"NQQS<"
$@"LSDNN@
NW"
[#/@"f@"e)(O)%-<"R")3"$&!42+74'!-#'+O)&%+B/&."$&<"A&;7/(+.)"E@X@<"LSST@
NN"
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
225
f#-2(9-62&'()" 1/#75);0" #" 34&/&,%)/-)" &+&1%&36*'6;" ;&" '&*2(:,$-)" $-&'$)"
1#2#+-)'(&"2>23-&$<".+6"-&&'.&=#2&')"-#$%&'9"2"1/#3)$"#$#76"/)1/)-)'%0*93)";#=­
5(2()"$-)/#,()"$1),%/0;"('%)/)$&/(0$-6<"&"2"/&;&34"+&')*"#/.&'(-&3*("D"50+-()"-&*;0­
*936" />=')" 1#-63*)<" 5).(%6;0*936" $(:" #+;()''6;(" +#?2(&+3-)'(&;(" #/&-" $%&%0$);"
2"/&;&34"('$%6%03*(@"M&,"1($-)"e)O)%-<"'&*7&/+-()*"#2#3'&"*)$%"2$1>81/&3&"2"./01()<"
,%>/&" 893-6" 50+-(" 1/-)8&;0*93" O#/;&5')" (" '()O#/;&5')" 7&/()/6<" -+#5'#?3(9" %2#/-)'(&"
%&,(34"./01"34&/&,%)/6-0*9"'&*7&/+-()*"%2>/3-)<"(''#2&36*')"("+6'&;(3-')"#/.&'(-&­
cjeNS@"!&=')"*)$%"%&,=)"0%/-6;62&'()"'&1(:3(&"1#;(:+-6"/>='6;(<"&3-",#;15);)'%&/­
'6;("0;()*:%'#?3(&;("("10',%&;("2(+-)'(&@"R&1(:3()"%#"1#2(''#"76F"*)+'&,",#'%/#­
5#2&')" %&,<" &76" '()" 1/-),/#3-68#" ./&'(36<" 1#-&" ,%>/9" ,#'t(,%" 1/-)$%&*)" 76F" -+/#26"
(" 1/#+0,%62'6<" &" -&3-6'&" 1/-6%8&3-&F" (" #7)-28&+'(&F" 03-)$%'(,>2" ./01630@" C$#76"
03-)$%'(3-93)" 2" 1/#3)$()" /#-2(9-62&'(&" 1/#75);0" 1#2(''6" 76F" '()0$%&''()" '&$%&­
2(#')"'&"03-)'()"$(:"#+"$()7()"'&2-&*);<"&"2&/0',("(34"2$1>81/&36"1#-2&5&F"1#2(''6"
'&"),$1)/6;)'%6<"&"'&2)%"+#10$-3-&F"78:+6YL@"e)(O)%-"1/-),#'0*)<"=)"2"%&,()*"&%;#$­
O)/-)"50+-()"$%&*9"$(:"7&/+-()*"1#;6$8#2("("%2>/3-6YN@"[#+#7'()"*&,"e)0)/"("[4)/$#'<"
%&,=)"e)(O)%-"2()5)"1($-)"#",#'()3-'#?3("#34/#'6"("-&1)2'()'(&"1#3-03(&"7)-1()3-)B­
$%2&"%6;"3-8#',#;"./016<",%>/-6";&*9"#+;()'')"-+&'()"'(="2(:,$-#?F<"34/#'(F"'&5)=6"
%)=" '()$O#/'634" 03-)$%'(,>2<" %-2=+ '$-#@1"9)("$&@" M)+'#$%,(" #" %&,(;" 1/#\50" ;&*9"
7#2();" -+#5'#?F" $%&2(&'(&" %/0+'634" 16%&B<" ,2)$%(#'#2&'(&" 1/-)$8&')," (" /-03&'(&"
'()-&5)='634"$9+>2<"-;0$-&*93"./01:"+#"1/-);6?5)'(&"-&23-&$0"'&*$8&7$-634"10',­
%>2"/#-0;#2&'(&33@"
[#+#7')"2'(#$,("'&$02&*9"$(:"1#+3-&$"5),%0/6"1/&3"[)%)/&"I)'.)<"1/#O)$#/&"EHn<"
,%>/6"*)$%"$1)3*&5($%9"-"-&,/)$0";6?5)'(&"$6$%);#2).#"#/&-"&0%#/);"1/-)8#;#2)*"%)#­
/(("J#/.&'(-&3*("03-93)*"$(:r@"I)'.)"1#+,/)?5&<"=)"./01&"03-6"$(:"+-(:,("*)+'#$%,#;<"
,%>/)" $(:" 03-9@" H" #" (5)" %#<" =)" *)+'#$%,(" $(:" 03-9" '()" .2&/&'%0*)" *)$-3-)<" =)" 03-6F" $(:"
7:+-()" 3&8&" ./01&<" #" %65)" 03-)'()" $(:" 3-8#',>2" ./016" *)$%" '()-7:+'6;" 2&/0',();"
%2>/3-).#"1/#3)$0"2"/&;&34"-7(#/#2#?3(YV@"j#$,#'&5)'()"$(:"*)+'#$%),"+)\'(0*)"$(:"
%0"*&,#"'()0$%&''9"3(),&2#?F"?2(&%&"#/&-".#%#2#?F"-+#762&'(&"'#2)*"2()+-6"("0;()­
*:%'#?3(<" &" '&2)%" -'&3-').#<" $%#1'(#2).#" 1/-)2&/%#?3(#262&'(&" $2#(34" 1#.59+>2@"
!6F2(3-)'()" '&26,0" ,/)&%62').#<" &" '()" /)&,%62').#" +-(&8&'(&" #/&-" .#%#2#?F" '&"
,#'O/#'%&3*:"26#7/&=)B"#"/-)3-62($%#?3("-"/-)3-62($%#?3(9"%&,9<"*&,&"#'&"/-)3-62(­
?3()"*)$%<"2&/0',0*)"1#;6$8#2#?F"#/&-"'()$34);&%63-')";6?5)'()@"^3-)'()"$(:"./016"
f@"e)(O)%-<"X@"]/&$4#2<"E@"q('$,6<""#1@3(%@<"$@"LQY@
q@"e(/$44#/'<"n@"](5;#/)<">!"+,".+Q-#/3)$4"&+-D+'!"+_Q-#/3)$%1"&&`+E-92)/%<"Ke&/g&/+"s0$(')$$"
f)g()2r";&*D3-)/2()3"LSSN"/@<"$@"T@
YL"
!(:3)*" '&" %);&%" 1/#3)$0" 03-)'(&" $(:" 1#/@" A4@"X/.6/($<" j@X@" I34#'"X@<" X$8)/45)'4-/)1+ R")$/4/8*+
A Theory of Action Perspective< f)&+('.<"E&$$@"LSUW"#/&-"('')"1/&3)"A4/($&"X/.6/($&@
YN"
f@"e)(O)%-<"X@"]/&$4#2<"E@"q('$,6<"#1@3(%@<"$@"LQY@
33 H7(+);<"$@"LPSDLUT@"
YV"
[@"I)'.)<">!"+[4D'!+V4&04214/"*+>!"+)$'+)/3+2$)0'40"+-D+'!"+1")$/4/8+-$8)/45)'4-/<"R)2"a#/,"LSSQ<"
$@"LYS@
NS"
30 226
Anna Wojciuk
%#"1/#3)$"70+#2&'(&"2$1>5')*"2(-*("%).#<"3#"343)"$(:"#$(9.'9F<"$%#1'(#2).#"-75(=&'(&"
$(:" +#" $()7()" />='#/#+'634" 1/-),#'&B" 3#" +#" 3)50" 1/&36<" *&,()" -26,5)" 1#*&2(&*9" $(:"
2" -7(#/#2#?3(@" !" +#7/-)" +-(&8&*93)*" ./01()" 50+-()" $9" '()" %65,#" 0%&5)'%#2&'(" #/&-"
1#$(&+&*9" 2$1>5'9" 2(-*:" 3)50<" &5)" %&,=)" 0;()*9" 2$1>81/&3#2&F" D" #$(9.&*9" $6')/.(:"
1#/>2'62&5'9"+#"34>/0@"
[/&3&" 2" ./01()" ;&" -+&'();" [)%)/&" I)'.)" +2&" ,/6%63-')" 26;(&/6@" [#" 1()/2­
$-)<" ,#'()3-')" *)$%" -6$,&'()" 2.59+0" 2" ,#;15),$#2)" -&.&+'()'()<" ,%>/)" *)$%" 1/-)+­
;(#%);"-&('%)/)$#2&'(&"./016<"'&763()"0;()*:%'#?3("26,#/-6$%&'(&"1#%)'3*&80"2()50"
0;6$8>2" (" (34" 1/-)2&.(" '&+" *)+'6;" %65,#" /#-0;);@" [#" +/0.()<" %/-)7&" /#-2(*&F"
(''#2&36*')<" $,##/+6'#2&')" +-(&8&'(&@" !" $1/&2'()" O0',3*#'0*93)*" ./01()" %&,<" *&,"
2"+#7/)*"+/0=6'()"$1#/%#2)*<",&=+6"3-8#'),"-)$1#80";&"?2(&+#;#?F"(''634"-&2#+­
'(,>2"("+-(&8&"%&,<"=)"(''(";#.9"1#5).&F"'&"'(;<"&"+-(&8&'(&"1#$-3-).>5'634"#$>7"$9" ,#;15);)'%&/')35@"
R&0,&"2"./01()"26;&.&"#1&'#2&'(&"$-%0,("+(&5#.0"("+6$,0$*(@"j(&5#."1#5).&"'&"
2#5'6;" (" %2>/3-6;" #+,/62&'(0" -8#=#'634" 1/#75);>2<" 1&%/-)'(0" '&" '()" -" />='634"
$%/#'<"'&"J.8:7#,(;r"$8034&'(0"$(:"'&2-&*);"("1#2$%/-6;62&'(0"#+",&%).#/63-'634"
$9+>2@" A)5);" +(&5#.0" *)$%" 26*?3()" 1#'&+" ('+62(+0&5'6" 1#-(#;" /#-0;()'(&" +&').#"
-&.&+'()'(&"("2"7)-1()3-'634"2&/0',&34"0*&2'()'()"'()$1>*'#?3("("$8&7#?3("1/-),#­
'&B@"X76" +(&5#." 768" ;#=5(26<" -+&'();" I)'.)<" ;0$-9" 76F" $1)8'(#')" %/-6" 2&/0',(<"
03-)$%'(36";0$-9"0;()F"J-&2()$(Fr"$2#*)"-&8#=)'(&<";0$-9";()F"1/-),#'&'()<"=)"($%­
'()*)";(:+-6"'(;(",#5)=)B$,&"18&$-3-6-'&"+(&5#.0"#/&-";0$("76F"2"./01()"#$#7&"+7&­
*93&"#"-&34#2&'()"#+1#2()+'().#",#'%),$%0"+(&5#.0@"j6$,0$*&"'&%#;(&$%"*)$%"7&/+-()*"
+6'&;(3-'&<"1/-61#;('&"./:"2"1('.k1#'.&<"1#-2&5&"1/)-)'%#2&F"/>='#/#+')"1#.59+6<"
,#'O/#'%#2&F" *)" (" 7/#'(F@" !" +6$,0$*(" 34#+-(" /&3-)*" #" 1/-),#'62&'()" (''634" '(="
#"2$1>5')"-.8:7(&'()"1/#75);0YP@"j(&5#."("+6$,0$*&"$9"1#%)'3*&5'()",#;15);)'%&/')<"
*)+'&," '&5)=6" /#-/>='(&F" ;(:+-6" '(;(" (" +7&F" #" 28&?3(29" />2'#2&.:@" j(&5#." ;&"
7#2();"%)'+)'3*:"+#"1/-),$-%&83&'(&"$(:"'()1#$%/-)=)'()"2"+6$,0$*:@"
^;()*:%'#?F" 1/&36" 2" .01()" %#" %&,=)" -+#5'#?F" /&+-)'(&" $#7()" -" ;)34&'(-;&;("
#7/#''6;(" 3-8#',>2<" ,%>/)" $1/#2&+-&*9" '(),()+6" -7(#/#26" 26$(8)," '&" ;&'#23)"
("3-6'(9"2$1>81/&3:";&8#"1/#+0,%62'9@"E)34&'(-;6"#7/#'')"34/#'(9"-26,5)"3-8#'­
,>2" ./016" 1/-)+" ,8#1#%5(26;(<" '()26.#+'6;(" $6%0&3*&;(@" M&," +#2#+-(" 2" $2#(34"
7&+&'(&34" A4/($"X/.6/($<" 1/#O)$$#/" e&/g&/+" s0$(')$$" I34##5<" -'&'6" -" -&$%#$#2&'(&"
2()+-6"'&0,#2)*"+#"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/&,%63-'634"1/#75);>2"2"#/.&'(-&3*&34<"50+-()"
1/-)+)"2$-6$%,(;"#7&2(&*9"$(:"26$%&2()'(&"'&",/6%6,:"("0*&2'()'(&"$8&7#?3("/#-0;#­
2&'(&<",%>/)"$%#("-&"(34"1#.59+&;(<"&";'()*"34#+-("(;"#"$&;#"#3&5)'()"1#.59+>2<"3-6"
#"1#-63*:"2"./01()YU@"!",#'%),?3()",#'t(,%0";&"'(),()+6";()*$3)"$-%03-')"-&3()/&'()"
/>='(3"507"-&$%#$#2&'()"-&$&+6<"=)"J-263(:-3&"7()/-)"2$-6$%,#r@"]/01()"%/0+'#"*)$%"
H7(+);<"$@"NYP@"
H7(+);<"$@"NVLDNVY@
YU"
A4@"X/.6/($<"G'$)'"8%H+E!)/8"+)/3+V"D"/&4F"+Y-#'4/"&<"s#$%#'"LSWT@
35 YP"
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
227
03-6F" $(:<" .+6" '&" 50,:" 1#-'&23-9" #+1#2(&+&" $(:" /)+0,#2&'();" 1#3-03(&" 1#%/-)76"
03-)'(&"$(:"-&;(&$%"1#$-0,(2&'(&"'#2634"/#-2(9-&B@"
[/#+0,%62')" 1#+)*?3()" +#" 1/#75);0" -&,8&+&" 1&%/-)'()" '&" -&.&+'()'()" -" 2()50"
/>='634" 1)/$1),%62" (" 1#$-0,(2&'()" 5(3-'634<" &5%)/'&%62'634" /#-2(9-&B@" !" %&,()*"
&%;#$O)/-)" ;#='&" 26;()'(F" $(:" 2()5#;&" (+)&;(" (" +#*?F" +#" '(),#'2)'3*#'&5'634<"
'()7&'&5'634"2&/(&'%>2@"A)5);"1/#+0,%62').#";6?5)'(&"*)$%"26.)')/#2&'()"+0=)*"
5(3-76"&5%)/'&%62'634"/#-2(9-&B<"$1#?/>+",%>/634"'&*;'()*"#3-62($%6;"1#?2(:3&"$(:"
%65)"$&;#"02&.(<"3#"'&*7&/+-()*"1/&2+#1#+#7'6;@"o/)&%62')";6?5)'()"1/#2&+-("+#"
#+,/63(&"1)/$1),%62<",%>/634"'(,%"23-)?'()*"'()"#1($&8@"[()/2$-6;",/#,();"*)$%"1/-)­
O#/;08#2&'()"1/#75);0"'&"2()5)"#+;()''634"$1#$#7>2<"%&,"&76"26*?F"1#-&"$34);&­
%63-'9<"%61#29"*).#"1)/3)13*:@"_+#5'#?F"#+'&*+62&'(&"1#893-)B"("-2(9-,>2";(:+-6"
1#-#/'()"#+5).86;("#+"$()7()"-&.&+'()'(&;("1#-2&5&"-&02&=6F"-&.&+'()'(&<",%>/634"
(''("7&+&3-)"'()"+#$%/-).5(@"n2>/3-)";6?5)'()"26;&.&"/>2'()="-+#5'#?3("3()/15(2).#"
-'#$-)'(&"&;7(2&5)'3*(";(:+-6",#',0/)'36*'6;("('%)/1/)%&3*&;("/-)3-62($%#?3("#/&-"
0%/-6;62&'(&" -&('%)/)$#2&'(&" ,(5,#;&<" 1#-#/'()" '(),#;1&%67(5'6;(" +-()+-('&;("
2()+-6@"A)346<",%>/)"2&/%#"F2(3-6F"("2$1()/&F"%#"-+#5'#?F"/-03&'(&"26-2&'(&"status quo, 0;()*:%'#?F",2)$%(#'#2&'(&"1/-)$8&'),<"3(),&2#?F<"-&;(8#2&'()"+#"1#$-0,(2&­
'(&"&5%)/'&%62'634"1#;6$8>2<"34:F"1#+)*;#2&'(&"('(3*&%626<"26#7/&i'(&"("'&,()/#­
2&'()"'&"1/-6$-8#?F<"&+&1%&36*'#?F"+#"/>='634"#,#5(3-'#?3("("-&+&B"-&2#+#2634YW@"""
H''9"-&$&+9"0$%/0,%0/6-#2&'634"%)34'(,"*)$%"1#2/&3&'()"+#"23-)?'()*$-634")%&­
1>2"1/#3)$0"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);0"("0;#=5(2()'()"03-)$%'(,#;"-&,2)$%(#'#2&'(&"
1/-)$8&')," #/&-" 2$-6$%,(34" O&-" /#-0;#2&'(&@" [#+#7'()" #" &'&5(-&34" 1#5(%63-'634"
(" 1/#3)$()" 15&'#2&'(&" 1#5(%6," 1075(3-'634" 1($-)" ;@('@" d0.)')" s&/+&34@" _2/&3&" #'"
02&.:<"=)"1/#3)$"/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);>2"#1&/%6"*)$%"'&"1/>7&34"("78:+&34<"+5&%).#"
-26,5)"%/-)7&"1#2%&/-&F"1#$-3-).>5')",/#,("("2/&3&F"+#"23-)?'()*$-634")%&1>2"1/&36"
-)"?2(&+#;#?3(9"+&5$-634"2'(#$,>2<"+#",%>/634"-&8#=)'(&"("/#-0;#2&'(&"1/#2&+-9YS@"
f#-2(9-62&'()" 1/#75);0" 3-:$%#" 26;&.&" /)+)\'(3*(" 3&8).#" -&.&+'()'(&" 2" %/&,3()"
1/&36<"/)2(-*("$1),%/0;";#=5(2634"2&/(&'%>2"#/&-",/6%)/(>2"#3)'6")O),%>2@"[/#3)$"
%)'" 762&" O/0$%/0*936<" *)+'&,<" .+6" 28&?3(2()" 1#1/#2&+-#'6<" +&*)" +0=9" $&%6$O&,3*:"
1#-'&23-9@
^3-)'()"$(:"#+"(''634"50+-("("1/&3&"2"./01()";&*9"$-3-).>5')"-'&3-)'()"2"'&03)@"
!)/')/" e)($)'7)/.<" -'&'6" \-6," (" %2>/3&" 1/&2&" '()#-'&3-#'#?3(" 1($&8<" =)" J'&0,&"
*)$%" -&,#/-)'(#'&" 2" /#-;#2()@"!$1>81/&3&" />='634" 50+-(" ;#=)" -&#2#3#2&F" )O),­
%&;(" #" '&*2(:,$-6;" -'&3-)'(0KVQ@" !" 1#+#7'6;" ?2()%5)" d0.)')" s&/+&34" 1/-)+$%&­
2(&"1/#3)$"&'&5(-"("1/#*),%#2&'(&"1#5(%6,"1075(3-'634<"2"%6;"1#5(%6,("-&./&'(3-')*<"
*)?5(" ;&" #'" #2#3#2&F" /#-2(9-62&'();" 1/#75);>2<" &" '()" 2'(#$,&;(" #" 34&/&,%)/-)" YW"
[#/@"n@"[/#3%#/<"E$")'4F"+6$-@1"9+G-1F4/8+D-$+<)/)8"$&*+V"F"1-24/8+&(411&+D-$+3"04&4-/+9)(4/8+)/3+
innovation<"NQLQ@
YS"
[#/@"d@"s&/+&34<"B+6$)0'40)1+N#43"+D-$+6-140%+B/)1%&4&*+>!"+O48!'D-13+6)'!+'-+<-$"+ODD"0'4F"+6$-­
@1"9+G-1F4/8<"NQQW@
VQ"
!@"e)($)'7)/.<"6!%&40&+)/3+Q"%-/3*+O/0-#/'"$&+)/3+E-/F"$&)'4-/&<"LSUL@
228
Anna Wojciuk
&5.#/6%;(3-'6;VL@"s&+&*93"+#/#7),"(''634"+6$3615('"2"+-()+-('()"%2>/3-).#";6?5)­
'(&"("/#-2(9-62&'(&"1/#75);>2<";#='&"$1#+-()2&F"$(:<"=)"0$%/0,%0/6-#2&')";)%#+6"
&'&5(%63-')" -&1/)-)'%#2&')" 1/-)-" e)0)/&" (" [4)/$#'&" '()" $9" 1#;6$8);" 3&8,#2(3()"
&0%#/$,(;@"I%&'#2(9"#')"0+&'9"&+&1%&3*:",/)&%62'634";)%#+"2$1>81/&36"$%#$#2&'634"
2"'&0,&34"?3($8634"("7(-')$()"+#"1#%/-)7"7&+&B"'&+"$%#$0',&;(";(:+-6'&/#+#26;(@"
[/&3)"1#?2(:3#')"%2>/3-);0";6?5)'(0"0,&-62&86"$(:"*0="2"5&%&34"VQ@"GG"2@<"*)+­
'&,"1/&2+-(2&";#+&"'&"%).#"%610"5(%)/&%0/:"1#*&2(8&"$(:"1>8"2(),0"1>i'()*@"R&*2(:3)*"
#1075(,#2&'#"#3-62(?3()"2"#7$-&/-)"7(-')$0<"+0=6"/#-.8#$"-6$,&8&";@('@",$(9=,&"n#'6­
).#"[/#3%#/&<"E$")'4F"+6$-@1"9+G-1F4/8+D-$+<)/)8"$&*+V"F"1-24/8+G(411&+D-$+V"04&4-/+
<)(4/8+)/3+C//-F)'4-/ VN@"A#"3(),&2)<"-&1/)-)'%#2&')"2"'()*"'&/-:+-(&"1/&36"%2>/­
3-)*"7&/+-#"1/-61#;('&*9"1/#1#-63*)"e)0)/&"("[4)/$#'&@"C76+2&"1#+)*?3(&"0-'&*9<"=)"
,/)&%62'#?F"'()"*)$%"%6;"$&;6;<"3#"('%)5(.)'3*&@"M)+'#$%,&";#=)"76F"-'&3-'()"('%)5(­
.)'%'()*$-&"'(="*)$%",/)&%62'&"("-'&3-'()"7&/+-()*",/)&%62'&"'(="('%)5(.)'%'&@"q0+-()"
-26,5)";6?59"2"$1#$>7"/)1/#+0,%62'6"("&5.#/6%;(3-'6<"#1()/&*9"$(:"'&"+#?2(&+3-)­
'(0<",%>/)"'&765(";()/-93"$(:"-"1#+#7'6;("-&.&+'()'(&;("2"1/-)$-8#?3(@"n&,&"?3()=,&"
;#=)"1/#2&+-(F"+#"0%/2&5&'(&";#+)5(";)'%&5'634"#/&-"+#"'&+;()/')*"1)2'#?3("3#"+#"
%/&O'#?3("$2#(34"$9+>2@"M)+'&,<"*&,"1/-),#'0*)"n(;"e0/$#'<",/)&%62'#?3("("%2>/3-).#"
;6?5)'(&";#='&"$(:"'&03-6F<"'()"*)$%"%#"-+#5'#?F"-".>/6"+&'&"507"'()"+&'&"*)+'#$%3)VY@
! V#!2%.*0LSL!+-&,+S&+,)/'IH0%Q!O+,/)!PU/JUI
[/&3&"2"./01()"'&+"-&.&+'()'();"-"#7$-&/0"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634"1#2(''&<"
-+&'();"e)0)/&"("[4)/$#'&<"-&3-6'&F"$(:"#+"-70+#2&'(&"%&,$#'#;(("1/#75);0"#/&-"
*).#"+),#;1#-63*(<"&"-&%);"0$%&5)'(&"$%/0,%0/6"-&.&+'()'(&<")5);)'%>2"$,8&+#2634<"
-&$%&'#2()'(&"$(:<"'&"*&,()",503-#2)"16%&'(&"'&5)=6"#+1#2()+-()F@"!"O&-()"%)*";#='&"
%)="1#$%&2(F"16%&'()<"3-6"2"#.>5)"$&;"1/#75);"*)$%"+#7/-)"$O#/;08#2&'6<"3-:$%#"1()/­
2#%'&" ,#'3)1%0&5(-&3*&" *)$%" -76%" 29$,&" 507" -76%" $-)/#,&<" '(),()+6" '()" +#$%/-).&"
*&,(34?"O0'+&;)'%&5'634",2)$%((@"[#'()2&="0;6$8"50+-,("$8&7#"/&+-("$#7()"-"-&1&;(:­
%62&'();" (" #1)/&3*#'&5(-&3*9" +0=)*" (5#?3(" +&'634<" 1#" 0$%&5)'(0" $%/0,%0/6" 1/#75);0<"
2&/%#" 1/-)+$%&2(F" *9" 2" O#/;()" ./&\3-')*<" -&-'&3-&*93" #+1#2()+'(#" '1@" $%/-&8,&;("
02&/0',#2&'(&<",#/)5&3*)")%3@"
A4#F"2$-6$%,()")%&16"&'&5(-6"#1()/&*9"$(:"'&"%)34'(3)"70/-6";>-.>2<"2"$-3-)­
.>5'#?3(" O&-&" +/0.&" D" 3-65(" .)')/#2&'()" 1#;6$8>2" 26;&.&" '&2)%" ,(5,0,/#%').#"
1/-)1/#2&+-)'(&" 0$%/0,%0/6-#2&').#" @$)4/&'-$94/8=+ A-&$" %)'" $80=6" $2#7#+');0"
/-03&'(0" (+)(<" $,#*&/-)B<" $-3-).>5'()" 3)'')" $9" %)" 893-93)" -'&')" +#%6343-&$" (+))"
2"'#26"$1#$>7@"s0/-&";>-.>2"'()"#+'#$("$(:"+#"./016"-'&*#;634"$()+-93634"/&-);" d@"s&/+&34<"#1@"3(%@<"NQQW@
n@"[/#3%#/<"#1@"3(%@<"NQLQ@
VY"
n@"e0/$#'<">!4/(+Q"''"$*+B/+C//-F)'-$_&+N#43"+'-+6$-3#0'4F"+>!4/(4/8<"NQQU@
VL"
VN"
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
229
("/#-;&2(&*93634"#"1/#75);()@"s0/-&";>-.>2"%#"1/#3)$"./01#26<"/-9+-936"$(:"?3(­
$86;(" -&$&+&;(" (" 1/#3)+0/&;(<" -&1)2'(&*936;(" ;&,$6;&5'9" 1/#+0,%62'#?F@" [#"
1()/2$-)<"-&1/&$-&*93"03-)$%'(,>2"./016"'&5)=6"-"261/-)+-)'();"1/)36-6*'()"#,/)­
?5(F"3)5"("%);&%"1/&36"#/&-"1#1/#$(F"(34"#"1/-6.#%#2&'()"$(:"+#"$1#%,&'(&@"[#"+/0.()<"
'#2)"1#;6$86"$9"-&2$-)";(5)"2(+-(&')"("'&"%6;")%&1()"'()"'&5)=6"(34",/6%6,#2&F<"
'&2)%" *)?5(" 26+&*9" $(:" 7&/+-#" +-(2')" 507" '(),#'2)'3*#'&5')<" 50+-()" ;0$-9" -26,5)"
26.8#$(F",(5,&"$8&7$-634",#'3)13*(<"76"21&?F"'&"'&1/&2+:"%2>/3-9"(+):@"[#"%/-)3()<"
'&5)=6"-&1)2'(F<"=)"#+762&"$(:"%65,#"*)+'&"/#-;#2&"'&"$&5("("=)",&=+6";&"$-&'$:"$(:"
261#2()+-()F@"[#"3-2&/%)<"'&"70/-:";>-.>2"1#2(''#"$(:"1/-)-'&3-6F"+#$%&%)3-'()"
+0=#"3-&$0"%&,<"&76"3-8#',#2()"./016";()5("$-&'$:"2)*?F"2",/)&%62'9"O&-:"1/&36@"[#"
1(9%)<"&76"0'(,'9F"/6-6,&";6?5)'(&"./01#2).#<"2&/%#"2893-6F"2"1/#3)$",#.#?"$1#-&"
?/#+#2($,&<"+6$1#'0*93).#"#+;()''6;"+#?2(&+3-)'();<",%#"-&1)2')"'()"7:+-()"$(:"
-.&+-&8"-"2(:,$-#?3(9@"[#"$->$%)<"/#-2>*"70/-6";>-.>2"+#7/-)"*)$%"?5)+-(F<"'&*5)1()*"
2"$1#$>7"2(+#3-'6"+5&"03-)$%'(,>2<"'&"1/-6,8&+"/6$0*93";&1:"1#;6$8>2"'&"%&75(36@"
R&",#'()3"'&5)=6"1#+$0;#2&F"1/&3:"("1#1/#$(F"03-)$%'(,>2<"&76"'()-&5)='()"#+"$()­
7()"-&1($&5("'&",&/%,&34",(5,&"'&*2&='()*$-634"1#;6$8>2<",%>/)"1#*&2(86"$(:"2"%/&,3()"
$1#%,&'(&@"R&$%:1'()"'&5)=6"2'(#$,("%)"-./#;&+-(F"("1#+-()5(F"$(:"'(;("-"03-)$%'(,&;("
70/-6";>-.>2<"&"*)?5("%#";#=5(2)"%&,=)"#$#7&;("$1#-&"%).#"./#'&@"!"./01()"1#2(''&"
76F"#$#7&"3-02&*93&"'&+"1/-)$%/-).&'();"/).08"("2"/&-()"1#%/-)76"0;()*93&"26*&?'(F"
*)" 03-)$%'(,#;@" R&*7&/+-()*" 1/#+0,%62')" 70/-)" ;>-.>2" #+762&*9" $(:" 2" ./01&34"
5(3-93634";(:+-6"3-%)/6"&"+2&'&?3()"#$>7VV@
I-3-).>5')"-&$&+6"'&5)=6"-&$%#$#2&F"2>23-&$<".+6"$%&%0$"#$>7"7(#/93634"0+-(&8"
2"1/#3)$()"*)$%"%&,"/>='6<"(="($%'()*)"#7&2&<"=)"'(),%>/-6"'()"7:+9"2"$%&'()"$2#7#+'()"
261#2()+-()F"$2#*).#"-+&'(&"507"%)=<"=)"1#++&+-9"$(:"$0.)$%(("+#;('0*93634"2"./0­
1()" *)+'#$%),@" [#+#7')" ?/#+,(" 7)-1()3-)B$%2&" 2&/%#" $%#$#2&F" %&,=)" 2>23-&$<" .+6"
$&;"%);&%"*)$%"7&/+-#",#'%/#2)/$6*'6@"!"%&,(34"$6%0&3*&34"-&5)3&"$(:"21/#2&+-)'()"
%-2@"(;()'')*"%)34'(,("./01#2)*@"[#+#7'()"*&,"2",5&$63-')*"70/-6";>-.>2<"%&,=)"%0%&*"
26$%:10*)"#$#7&"3-02&*93&"'&+"1/#3)$);@"R&"2$%:1()"-&+&*)"#'&"03-)$%'(,#;"#%2&/%)"
16%&'(&<"2"/#+-&*0"JM&,()"3-6''(,("2186'9"'&@@@uK<"JM&,";#=);6"$%2()/+-(F<"=)@@@uK<"
JA#"1#2(''#c'()"1#2(''#"-'&5)iF"$(:"2"%6;"1/#*),3()"7&+&23-6;@@@uK"(%+@"R&$%:1'()"
3-8#',#2()"-)$1#80"+#$%&*9"3-&$"'&"-&$%&'#2()'()"("#+1#2(&+&*9"'&"16%&'(&"'&",&/%­
,&34<" ,&=+6" #$#7'#@" H+))" $9" '&$%:1'()" #+3-6%62&')" 1/-)-" 1/#2&+-93).#" $1#%,&'()"
("-&1($62&')"'&"%&75(36@"j6$,0$*&"'()"'&$%:10*)"+#1>%6<"+#1>,("2$-6$%,()"1#;6$86"'()"
-#$%&'9"#+3-6%&')<"&"(34"-'&3-)'()"26*&?'(#')@"!"'&$%:1')*"O&-()"-)7/&'("+6$,0%0*9"
#"1#;6$8&34"2",#5)*'#?3(<";#='&"*)"893-6F<"&5)"'()";#='&"-;()'(F"=&+').#"1#;6$80<"
#"(5)"'()"-.#+-("$(:"'&"%#"*).#"&0%#/@"!67>/"'&*($%#%'()*$-634"1#;6$8>2"'()"*)$%"-26­
,5)",#'()3-'6<"*)?5("*)+'&,"%&,"$(:"-+&/-6<"-26,5)"+#,#'0*)"$(:".#"2"%&*'6;".8#$#2&­
'(0<"'1@"267()/&*93"3-%)/6"'&*5)1$-)"1#;6$86"("1/-6-'&*93"(;"10',%6<"'1@"#+"V"+#"LVT@"
VV"
VT"
f@M@"e)0)/"M/@<"f@e@"[4)/$#'<"#1@"3(%@<"$@"SY@
H7(+);<"$@"LQQ@
230
Anna Wojciuk
!"%/&,3()"70/-6";>-.>2"1#$-0,0*)"$(:"-26,5)"5($%6"-&8#=)B<"-;()''634<"$(8"+)36­
+0*93634"#"/#-2#*0"$6%0&3*(<"4(1#%)-<",503-#2634"./&3-6"("('%)/)$&/(0$-6<"$3)'&/(0$-6<"
(+)'%6\,0*)" $(:" ($%'()*93)" +&')" 507" i/>+8&" ('O#/;&3*(<" 1#%)'3*&5')" /#-2(9-&'(&" 1/#­
75);0"(";#=5(2)")O),%6VP@"H$%'()*9"$-3-).>8#2)"1/#3)+0/6"+5&"70+#2&'(&"$3)'&/(0$-6<"
#,/)?5&'(&" +5&" '(34" 2$,&i'(,>2" #/&-" -&$&+" ;#'(%#/#2&'(&" %634=)@" H$%#%'9" 3-:?3(9"
1/&36"%2>/3-)*"*)$%".)')/#2&'()"4(1#%)-<"&"'&$%:1'()"1#+)*;#2&'()"1/>7"(34"O&5$6\­
,&3*(@"A#"('%)/)$0*93)<"e)0)/"("[4)/$#'"1/-),#'0*9<"=)"'&*7&/+-()*"5(3-6F"$(:"%/-)7&"'()"
-"%6;("4(1#%)-&;(<"'&"/-)3-",%>/634"1/-);&2(&"'&*2(:,$-&"(5#?F"+&'634<"&5)"-"%6;(<"
1/-)3(2",%>/6;"?2(&+3-6"'&*;'()*$-&"(5#?F"+#2#+>2VU@"_&&2&'$#2&'6")5);)'%"7&+&­
'(&"+#%63-6"1#$-0,(2&'(&",#/)5&3*(";(:+-6"-;()''6;(<"&"'&$%:1'()"1/-63-6'"("$,0%­
,>2@" M&," 2" ,&=+)*" +-()+-('()" '&0,(<" %&,=)" 2" $%#$0',&34" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634" $(5')"
;)%#+#5#.(3-'()"+#2()+-)'()"-2(9-,>2"1/-63-6'#2#k$,0%,#2634"*)$%"7&/+-#"%/0+­
'6;"-&+&'();@"!&/%#"1#'#2'()"1#+,/)?5(F<"=)",#5)*')")%&16"1/#3)$0"7&+&23-).#"'()"
$9"+#;,'(:%)"("'&",&=+6;")%&1()";#='&"2/>3(F"+#"23-)?'()*$-634"O&-@"A#"3(),&2)<"
3-:$%#"'&"+&5$-634")%&1&34"-&&2&'$#2&'(&"$,8&'(&"$(:"./01:"+#"1#2/#%0"'&"1#-(#;"
$&;)*"+)\'(3*("1/#75);0"507"-&8#=)B<"#"1#'#2')"(34"-(+)'%6\,#2&'()<"&"%&,=)"2$,&­
-&'()")2)'%0&5'634"$8&7634"10',%>2@"!$-6$%,()")%&16"1/&3"/-9+-9"$(:"-&$&+&;("$2#­
7#+')*" 2$1>81&36" 2" /&;&34" 0$%&5#'634" /).08<" 3-65(" $2#*9" \5#-#\9" 1/-61#;('&*9"
0$%/0,%0/6-#2&'9"70/-:";>-.>2@
! W#!:H-&'-'IH0LH!()(HS&)./0%
]/01#2)" %)34'(,(" &'&5(%63-')" 2" $%#$0',&34" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634" $%&'#2(9" '()" %65,#"
3(),&2)" ('$%/0;)'%&/(0;" +5&" 7&+&3-6<" &5)" %&,=)" 1#%)'3*&5'()" 1/-6+&%')" '&/-:+-()"
+6+&,%63-')@" !()5)" 0;()*:%'#?3(<" ,%>/634" 03-6" 1/&3&" 2" ./01()" -.#+'&" -" -&$&+&;("
70/-6";>-.>2"*)$%"7#2();"-7()='&"-"%-2@",503-#26;(",#;1)%)'3*&;(<",%>/)"0-'&*)"
$(:"-&"'()-7:+')"+5&"$0,3)$0"-&2#+#2).#"2"GGH"2@"H+)&",503-#2634",#;1)%)'3*("
;&"'&"?2()3()"("2"d0/#1()"+80.9"%/&+63*:"l%/-6"\5&/6")+0,&3*("j)5#/$&<"/&1#/%"j)I)A#"
CdAj<" I%/&%).(&" q(-7#B$,&<" &" #7)3'()" Jd0/#1&" NQNQKm@" [0',%);" #+'()$()'(&" +5&"
1&B$%2"3-8#',#2$,(34"^d"l("'()"%65,#m<"$%&8&"$(:"/),#;)'+&3*&"[&/5&;)'%0"d0/#1)*­
$,().#"("f&+6"^'(("d0/#1)*$,()*"-"NQQP"/#,0<",%>/&"-&2()/&"5($%:"("+)\'(3*)"W",#;1)­
%)'3*(" ,503-#2634VW@" I1#?/>+" %634=)" #1($62&')" %)34'(,(" +#$,#'&59" k" 1#" 1()/2$-)" k"
-&&2&'$#2&')" 1#/#-0;()2&'()" $(:" 2" *:-6,0" #*3-6$%6;<" 2" %6;" 2" $-3-).>5'#?3("
03-)$%'(3-)'()" 2" +6$,0$*&34<" $8034&'()<" 261#2(&+&'()" $(:<" 3-6%&'()" (" ,#*&/-)'()"
H7(+);<"$@"WS@
H7(+);<"$@"LVW@
VW"
j#",#;1)%)'3*("%634"-&5(3-&*9"$(:b"lLm"[#/#-0;()2&'()"$(:"2"*:-6,0"#*3-6$%6;<"lNm"[#/#-0;()2&'()"
$(:"2"*:-6,&34"#73634<"lYm"o#;1)%)'3*)";&%);&%63-')"("1#+$%&2#2)",#;1)%)'3*)"'&0,#2#k%)34'(3-')<"
lVm"o#;1)%)'3*)"('O#/;&%63-')<"lTm"^;()*:%'#?F"03-)'(&"$(:<"lPm"o#;1)%)'3*)"$1#8)3-')"("#762&%)5$,()<"
lUm"H'(3*&%62&"("1/-)+$(:7(#/3-#?F<"lWm"v2(&+#;#?F"("),$1/)&$*&",05%0/&5'&@
VP"
VU"
Metody twórczej pracy grupowej w analizie polityki zagranicznej i dydaktyce stosunków międzynarodowych
231
("'O#/;&3*("#/&-"+6$1#-63*:"+#",/6%63-').#"(",#'$%/0,%62').#"+(&5#.0<"&"%&,=)".#%#­
2#?F"+#"26;(&'6";6?5("-"(''6;(@"[#"+/0.()<"26/&7(&*9"-'&*#;#?F"("#763()"-"1#+$%&­
2#29"O#/;9"/#-0;#2&'(&"2"+-(&8&5'#?3("'&0,#2)*<"'()-7:+'9"+#"/#-0;()'(&"2$1>8­
3-)$').#"?2(&%&"("%#2&/-6$-93634";0"1/-),&->2@"[#"%/-)3()<"/#-2(*&*9"-+#5'#?F"03-)­
'(&"$(:<"2"%6;"1#3-03()"-&0O&'(&"+#"28&$'634";#=5(2#?3(<";#%62&3*:"+#"1#.8:7(&'(&"
0;()*:%'#?3(" #/&-" ,#*&/-)'()" -)" $#79" />='634" +-()+-('" 2()+-6@" [#" 3-2&/%)<" 70+0*9"
0;()*:%'#?3("$1#8)3-')<"1#5).&*93)"'&"2$1>81/&36"-"(''6;(<"03-9"-&$&+"1/&36"2"./0­
1()<" /#-2(9-62&'(&" ,#'t(,%>2" (" #$(9.&'(&" ,#'$)'$0$0<" +&*9" /#-0;()'()" 1#%/-)76"
03-)$%'(3-)'(&"2"2(:,$-634"O#/;&34"2$1>81/&36@"[#"1(9%)"2/)$-3()<"2-;&3'(&*9"('(­
3*&%62:"("1/-)+$(:7(#/3-#?F"/#-0;(&')"7&/+-#"$-)/#,#<"*&,#"0;()*:%'#?F"1/-),02&'(&"
1#;6$8>2"2"3-6'6<"%2>/3-).#"1#+)*?3(&"+#"#%&3-&*93)*"/-)3-62($%#?3("#/&-"15&'#2&­
'(&"(",()/#2&'(&"/>=').#",&5(7/0"1/-)+$(:2-(:3(&;(@"
_&34:3&*936;" 3-6''(,();" *)$%" -&1&8" $%0+)'%>2" +#" 7/&'(&" 0+-(&80" 2" %).#" %610"
1/-)+$(:2-(:3(&34@"!"H'$%6%03()"I%#$0',>2"E(:+-6'&/#+#2634"^!"#+"2()50"5&%"$%#­
$0*)" $(:" ;)%#+:" 1/&36" ./01#2)*" 2" '&03-&'(0" 1/-)+;(#%0" J').#3*&3*)" ;(:+-6'&/#­
+#2)K@"A#/#3-')"/)5&3*)"$%0+)'%>2"2$,&-0*9"'&"26$#,9"&1/#7&%:"%).#"/#+-&*0";)%#­
+#5#.(("'&03-&'(&@"!"%6;"$&;6;"H'$%6%03()"-"7&/+-#"+#7/6;("$,0%,&;("03-#'#"%)="
-&"1#;#39"1/&36"-)$1#8#2)*"1/-)+;(#%0"J+)36-*)"1#5(%63-')K@"R&*+#,8&+'()*$-)"+&')"
#+'#$-93)"$(:"*0="1/)36-6*'()"+#"'&03-&'(&"-&"1#;#39"#1($&'634"2"'('()*$-6;"%),­
?3()"./01#2634<"0$%/0,%0/6-#2&'634"%)34'(,"&'&5(%63-'634"-)7/&'#"2"/&;&34"1/-)+­
;(#%0"J1/#.'#-#2&'()"("$6;05&3*)";(:+-6'&/#+#2)K@"s&+&'()"26,#'&'#"'&"1/>7()"
LNN"$%0+)'%>2"H"/#,0"HH"$%#1'(&"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634<"2"%6;"SP"#$>7",$-%&8­
3(8#"$(:"'&"$%0+(&34"+-()''634<"&"NP"'&"2()3-#/#2634@"!$-6$36";()5("-&"$#79"+20­
,/#%')"+#?2(&+3-)'()"%2>/3-)*"1/&36"2"./01()"1/-6"#,&-*("+2>34"-&+&B"26;&.&*9­
3634" /#-2(9-62&'(&" 1/#75);>2<" 2" %6;" *)+').#" 2(:,$-).#" (" *)+').#" +/#7').#@"
C7$)/20*93"1>i'()*$-)"1#$%:16"("7(#/93"1#+"02&.:",#;0'(,&%6"186'93)"#+"$%0+)'%>2<"
;#='&" $1#+-()2&F" $(:<" =)" 2" ,#5)*'634" )%&1&34" 2$1>81/&36" ./016" +#1/&3#2&86"
;)%#+6<"3-)/1(93"2(:,$-9",#/-6?F"("$&%6$O&,3*:"-"+-(&8&'(&@"!"&',()3()")2&50&36*')*"
1#" -&5)+2()" 1>8%#/&" ;()$(93&" ,0/$0" $%0+)'3(" #3)'(&5(" 1/-6+&%'#?F" 1(:3(0" )5);)'%>2"
+6+&,%6,(<"26,#/-6$%62&'634"2"*).#"%/&,3()b"5),%0/<"+6$,0$*("'&"-&*:3(&34<"$%0+(0;"
1/-61&+,0<"1/&36"2"./01()"#/&-"26,8&+#236@"
E(;#",/>%,().#"3-&$0"'&0,("("1#3-9%,#2634"%/0+'#?3(<"&"'&2)%"-&.07()'(&"-2(9­
-&').#"-",#'()3-'#?3(9"2+/#=)'(&"$(:"2"-01)8'()"'#29";)%#+#5#.(:<"1/&3&"2"./01()"
#%/-6;&8&"-&$,&,0*93#"26$#,()"#3)'6@"!"$,&5("LDT"1/&3:"2"./01()"#3)'(#'#"?/)+'(#"
'&"V@N"l1#+#7'()"'&"$%0+(&34"+-()''634"("'&"2()3-#/#2634m<"#,#8#"1#8#26"#$>7"#3)­
'(8#"1/&3:"2"./01()"'&"T@"!"3-:?3("*&,#?3(#2)*"&',()%6"$%0+)'3("2$,&-62&5("'&",#'­
,/)%')"2/&=)'(&"2",#/-6$%&'(&"-"%)*";)%#+6@"!?/>+";&',&;)'%>2"26;()'(&'#".8>2­
'()"1/#75);".&1#2(3-&<"34&#$"#/.&'(-&36*'6"("3-&$#348#''#?F@"I%2()/+-)'()"#"26$%:­
1#2&'(0".&1#2(3->2"+#%63-68#"#,#8#"YQw"&',()%"("2(9-&8#"$(:"-"-&$&+'(3-#"'(=$-9"
#3)'9"3&8)*";)%#+6@"[#*&2(8#"$(:"*)+'&,"-&$,&,0*93#"2()5)"261#2()+-(")'%0-*&$%63-­
'634<"'1@b"J1/&3&"2"./01()"*)$%"7&/+-#")O),%62'&<"26-2&5&"%2>/3-)";6?5)'()"("1#-2&5&"
232
Anna Wojciuk
/#-$%/-6.'9F"1/#75);"2"'#26<"7&/+-#"3(),&26"$1#$>7K<"J762&"%/0+'#<"&5)";#='&"$(:"
#+"(''634"7&/+-#"+0=#"'&03-6F"("1/-)$%&2(F"'()3#"$2#*)";6?5)'()K<"J2$1>8#+1#2()­
+-(&5'#?F"-&"-&+&'()"03-6"+6$3615('6K<"J1#-6%62')"-&$,#3-)'()K<"J$01)/K<"J$1#%,&'(&"
2"./01()"%#"3)'')"+#?2(&+3-)'()<".+6="*)$%);"('+62(+0&5($%9K<"J'(,%"'()"*)$%"-&,/-6­
3-&'6<"+-(&8&;6"+);#,/&%63-'()K<"J2";#*)*"./01()"2$-6$36"1/&30*9"+-()5'()<",&=+6"
2,8&+&"2"$2#*)"-&+&'()";&,$6;&5'9"(5#?F"1/&36K<"J;#=);6"$(:"5)1()*"1#-'&F"("1/-)+­
$%&2(F"2()5)"/#-2(9-&B"*)+').#"1/#75);0K@
* * *
^$%/0,%0/6-#2&')"%)34'(,("&'&5(%63-')"$%#$0',>2";(:+-6'&/#+#2634"$%#$#2&')"
2" %#,0" 1/&36" ./01#2)*" $%&'#2(F" ;#.9" ('%)/)$0*939" 1/#1#-63*:" +5&" 1/&3#2'(,>2"
#?/#+,>2" &'&5(%63-'634" #/&-" 1/-)+$%&2(3()5(" &+;('($%/&3*(" 1075(3-')*" 3#/&-" 3-:?3()*"
-;0$-#'634"/)&.#2&F"'&"-8#=#')"1/#75);6"("#O)/#2&F"%2>/3-)"/#-2(9-&'(&@"_&3()­
,&2(F" ;#.9" #')" 7&+&3-6" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634<" ,%>/634" 3#+-()''6;"
+#?2(&+3-)'();"*)$%"1/&3&"'&+"-&.&+'()'(&;("26;&.&*936;("2()+-6"-"2()50"+6$36­
15('"'&0,#2634@"I%#$0',(";(:+-6'&/#+#2)"&./).0*9"7#2();"2()+-:"-"-&,/)$0"$&;)*"
'&0,(" #" $%#$0',&34" ;(:+-6'&/#+#2634<" &5)" />2'()=" 1#5(%#5#.((<" ),#'#;((<" 1/&2&<"
$#3*#5#.((<"+);#./&\(<"4($%#/((<"+);#./&\(<",05%0/#-'&2$%2&<"/)5(.(#-'&2$%2&<"&"'()­
,()+6"%&,=)"'&0,"?3($8634@"j5&%).#"+-()+-('&"-&('%)/)$#2&'&"("('$1(/#2&'&"28&?3(2()"
2$-6$%,(;(" &$1),%&;(" =63(&" 50+-,().#<" ;&" $-&'$:" $-3-).>5'()" %2>/3-#" #+,/62&F"
1#./&'(3-&" '&0,<" '&" ,%>/634" +-(&8&@" [/-6+&%'634" +#" %).#" '&/-:+-(" +#$%&/3-&F" ;#.9"
;(:+-6"(''6;("0$%/0,%0/6-#2&')"%)34'(,("&'&5(%63-')@"C;>2(#')"%0";)%#+6"-&2()­
/&*9"-'&3-'6"1#%)'3*&8"+6+&,%63-'6<"&"+#%6343-&$#2)<"$,/#;')"+#?2(&+3-)'(&"2"(34"
$%#$#2&'(0"-&34:3&*9"+#"+&5$-634"),$1)/6;)'%>2@"s#.&%&<";(:+-6'&/#+#2&"1/&,%6,&"
#$%&%'(34" 5&%" 1#,&-0*)<" =)" 1#26=$-634" ,#'%),$%&34" +#%63-93634" $%#$0',>2" ;(:+-6­
'&/#+#2634"'&/-:+-(&"%)"$1/&2+-(86"$(:"2"2()50",/&*&34"("2"2()50"/-9+#2634"("1#-&­
/-9+#2634"#/.&'(-&3*&34";(:+-6'&/#+#2634@