WP5_ National case study Poland (Polish version)

WP5_ National case study Poland (Polish version)

With the support of the Lifelong Learning Programme of the European Union
„Identifying Barriers in Promoting the European Standards and Guidelines
for Quality Assurance at Institutional Level“
IBAR
Agreement number – 2010 – 4663/001 - 001
WP5
Internal Quality Assurance Systems
National study –Polish version
2011
This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This publication
reflects the views only of the author, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any
use which may be made of the information contained therein.
! !"#$%&'!"#!'! (
! !")'!"#'! ("(# %*+'(! !"
# $%&'( !
)*
+, -.!
*!
/0
)
• $ ( 12 0 3
$4 2* 6
+ 0*+ 7 60( 8
9
• :
; ! 0 3
3 < 0
1 $6<01(! = 1 0
3
!
!
1 *+ >>? >
>?> >
>
>* A> 6+ <
6*+ $C
/ D
* C/D( 7 > >+ >*
EA>
>F
!C>+>G>
+
>>
>>?+H>I>
J>+*H!
+*
*+>?
!!
+*J
+*'K4&*+!C*+*L
II?)
• *+I>
>+*H+
• H**+
J>>
J6<6
• + M 7 *> H > A >GA M
?*>?
• >
>I
$ (>
E>*>
+?>+&1N!
,
'$ # -"#. -!/! 1*"2+$ 4!.5( .1!6( ! 1.6!( #71#(
> ** J G *J
G + $O 1E > P , ! ++ *
*>(>?)
• *
• >>?> =C1>E >!
H*>G
• *J!
C>+OQ1E>F
>
J
H*>G >I+? >
J
**+
>*
>
GH
F>>*>G$>>
*
> HG>> G> > >
>>*!1>*A>+>*+>
>>?>4 >*+ I A I? + >+L A &1N A
+>!
6A > >?> + $<>>?> = C* 1>*EA>>P$">!O-RS#!!(J
*>G(>+I>
>+*H!
9
:%! +! "( T > >GA
+* 'K0< J > ? +
*>
> +*! EJ L * * *>G>JA>>G+?>JA*>HJ+?
AL > +*H > > >
&1N! T > +* G * * >* +* *HL $>( *>+I
$(>
+*****+>>*
$
(GH$(!
TA>*?>I$*!RF(>>*G?JAHL>>JG
*J >?G I *A * >* +*) > G ?U > +
>+ >G>>?>>
>*+9* >>*
*7
>9>JA>I
$(*>G>>!
I *A L > >JA+ * +H > >*$>(> *GJ$>
* *( *A >> J J + +$ (!
'
>*
*+G>>G>>
>+*H*JGA>>4&1N
I?>>*>G4>!
=+?>*>>IJI+?>)
• 1>*GNGJ%E>$E1&
(V1N%2E1&W
•
•
•
O 0
=*> > $0
=*> O(
VO0=20=OW
*XJ>*$OM>(VX2OMW
K*EA>1>*G
!8!>*>K* KG+$!!(VKE12YYW
' +*J>? I > A> ! 1?>
A J > >
? +?+
>
>?*+*H
*>>>*+*>+>&1N!
:
;+(- ' !"-"< ("'+ *=!("( !(>
!1!'(1" 1
1>*GNGJ%
E>2E1
&
O ! 0
=*> 2 0
=*>O
* XJ>* 2
OM>
K*EA>1>*G
!8!
>*>
H
.!"1!(
4!
1
*+
"
#-
1 >
A
1
>
A
1
M*
7
>
G
: 1.6!?6@ !%! +"!!1!A!!("( $(
1N%>)
• H)!*!2>GPFF>*>GGPJ>
#-*J
• >*>E>$*+( *!R
!
>*4JI?+
>?A+**
*!-%&'!
• +>7>GJ*
>
$>>?>(
• >G+?*GI>>
Z;
>G
>
*
• >+
)*++,!
• >GA+ *> >++) + >? >>G? *J+
>GHL* >+>>>,*J
• >? ' ** '' ** ** $>IHL J +I>*
(!
• *** >**
*>>?>
• + + > U? >? J +
$-PJ?>IP(
• +?*I>?GJ>!>
$PPR>
PFF>(
• *
*
) > * > **J
>>
!
:, #$+!$!B(.(1!A+!$B(.(1 #B
O0=>)
• A)!*!2>G#->*>GGRFFPJ
• >*> +H >4 $ E**( ,,P#,
>*4J $, + ( + + > +I*> H*J
>
• +> > , **J +>+ > ***
• > 7 >G > P , ! 7 >*A>
• >+
)>GA*
• >+*>>++)R>GJ+
+?I+?
>>*)
>G>HG>>>?>>>*?!
• >?>*>
J)''''''
*>G
MMM
• >? + + $# F J +
F,P#+
J
(
• J>>
• +?*I*J+>+I*>HO0=+
+
• >G*&O0&O3&C!
• >
:9 "( .!C@+1.!A( (!" #+1
X>)
• A)!*!2>GRR>*>GGFPJ>
,*J
• >*> X> $ ( *! ! >*4J *>
G
• +>7>GJ>
• >G+?*
?>P,* GI>>
Z*;
• >H
A
)*++R,!
• >GA+*>>++)>GJ!
• >' #,***>?' +I>**
P**> +I>**
+
**9'' #,***>?''
+I>* *
, ** > ** !
• + + > U? >? J +
$RF,J?>IFP(
• 4**R4
*
• *I > GJ >! >
$R-F > RR
>(
•
*
*
) > * +
+ JGI >
>
G
>
!
:: ;".!#71!1.6!$D#1.(1!<;>
KE1>)
• G)!*!2>GR->*>GGF-J
• >*>
+HK* KG$*>&
K*( *! P ! >*4J * >
G+ >+
>>
• +> >,>JA
**J$>>?>
* * *+> * I> *
( F
+>+*J>
G
>**+
• 7>GA>>D+I!>>D+IK*3N*
<*+!6I>*>7I>>
• G) >G >> > >> = &*+
C+C"C1 # R,2R,2->-
• +*>>++)>G
• >?G?>' >
*>G
MMM
• >? + + > U? >? J
+$-#J?>IF-(
• +?*I>?GJ>!
$#R>R-
>(
• >
) > 4 * > **J
>>
!
,
E
E
ED
DA
F
G
, 1.6!?6@ !%! +"!!1!A!!("( $(
1>*G NGJ % *I +*H! T GJ ++ >GH
*++>+)
( ? +* +A>+ +*H *>G + 4
> > > >*
J +
J
( ? *+ > > > *J *>G >>*
>JJ
#( ? +* +A>+ >+ **++ > > >I +*HL
*>G*
+*
**+
R( ?G*+*H*>G!
1+GJ>*+*H*>G1>*GNGJ%?>
>*
>I*)
• *
>
>
*
*
+
*>
*>*
*
•
•
•
•
•
*
*
*>G *+?
> HG ?>4
>>>>>*
*>>H?
>GH*++
>A+A>*>>>?>>
+*H? *>G > >
* I>
>>?>+*H?*>G
+>+*>****>G
> >*
4 J +
J
>AJ>>?>+*H?*>G>>JH
>>?>+*H?
J>+IL*>
>A * J >I> > +*H) +
+
>? H*+ *
+ *++ >*JG
*
>$D06&(*JG!
1+ GJ +*H *>G 1>*G ? JA > A
>
? * I> > +*H
*>G**
)
• +*H
J*>
*>G
• +*H
J
• *
+>*
*
• *+J>*+J!
I> > +*H 1N% >>I G [[ *! Q > J >+? +*HL
*>G*+*)
• >>
>*>?
J*>G
• J
• >+*H**>+
• >>J*>H*JJ
• +!
C
>+*H*>G*G+?II+?)
• *
*>G
• >+*H*>+
• ** *>+
• *>+IL*>
• > >GH *>+ * >+ >++
*J
• J!
E,!I>
>>?>+*H?*>G*J
>I >+ *+ > +*H! 1
>>?> +*H?
*>G>*
*+*)
*+*H*>G
+>+>*+>*>
J >+ *>G! EI> >>?> +*H?
*>G>G+H
!1
+
+*>G$
+I(!
">+? <* 1N% >G G TJG ! T>?> 8*H?
6>G! 8> >>
*I> >>?>+*H?*>G!
,, #$+!$!B(.(1!A+!$B(.(1 #
O0=*I>+*H*J+>IH?J+>
!>*>G
>+*H+*A
>G I> > +*H $ >*G G) *
+?>+I**J(!Q
J*>G
? > *>G $ ( > ? > *J +? >L J >J! ?
>+*H?**+*!>?*I>+*H>
>G&1N>>I*>
>>>*+
*
!T>*
*+*H+?I>J
+*>$(+*
++I>*
*
>IH+I>**
!T?>!O0=*
*>IH*+*>GHL>>
>+*H!
OG? 1 > , > ! > O> 1
T>?>
8*H?6>G*J
+)
! 1
?G * +*H *>G O ! 0
=*>>9
>*>+>>*
*9
#! >>
*>GJO
!0
=*>
>9
R! 1>*
+*H*>GO
!0
=*>
>!
O1T86 O0= > >G >+ >>J
>GJ*!1
L*
+H**>!Z*
+*H;*J?*G+?I>J**>+*
*>>?>!
Q> > >+I J O1T86 + < ! 8*H 6>G $<86(
*G+?I>6
+!T8*H6>G$6T86(6
+!Q
8*H6>G$6Q86(!C>JO1T86+*!*>G*J>
>I><86!>*A
>>GG>G*
+!
+*H *>G *J >?) >JG ! > +*H *>G >JG !
+*H*>G!QGI
+?<!8*H6>G>
K<!8*H6>G!
E >* R > O0= $K0"0C'0 C0O6QE& H
>
C+A> +*HL 61T0X3&C'0 O QE0<\ >
O> + T0<T]"T0C0( A >UL ?> >*
J
&1N!E>>JH
>*&1N+
7 C+A> +*HL 61T0X3&C'0 *J JA F J
+)
! E>I>
>+*H*>G!
! O>?*>>+
>>
J!
#! >*
+*>>*
**J!
R! TJA>>I*>JJ!
,! 6>G*!
-! E
>HJ'''!
P! '+>+*>G!
F! <>>+**>G!
O0=+>A*
J>I>>+*H)+
+
> +J >? H*+ *
+ *++ J$O60(*JGF!
,9 "( .!C@+1.!A( (!" #+1
*XJ>**I+*H!TG+IOC#21
*XJ>*+>!#
I>
>
+*H*>GXJ>*+!
+*?
!!)
• **>GXJ>*+
• +*A
>I>>GA
• >*
+A
HA**>G
• >+ * >* ** > >
J
>*
*JA+?I>***
• *>G +*HH*>
>
*+*H*>G
• JGI > >I
> +
*>G>>G>*
• >>>GH*>+*XJ>*+
?**>G
• > >?>4 >+? >JA? >
? ?
HLJ
• > *+H **+H *>+ *
XJ>*+**++
I>+!
>>
>+*+*H+I>
>+*H*>G!E
>?I+?
>)
• A*?G*+*H*>GX>
*>>+>>?I)
J J J > >
J**>G6+<
6*+
>**
>> >* * J
*>G
*J *>G ? >> J > *>+?>*++X
?G
>***>+
> > >? >GH *>+ ++
*J
>>H*
+*>A+*
>GH*>+>
>GH*>+
+>G4>
>+?*+*H*>G
A >
J >>?> >
*EI>1
T8*H6>G!
EI>
>+*H*>GXJ>*++
+)
• >>I>?>GH*>+
)
>*4*>J
*++ > J >* * *+
>
+*
>>>*A>
+ >
> *J > +
J
?I*J*>GJ>J*>+?>
*++X
>J>J>*++X*J
>*J>*>
> *
* *J + **
>HJ>*>
>J
>J
>J**>*H*>
• >?> > J >> > + *H H +*H *U*J +>?>GH*>+++*J
• > +* >+ > +*
I>>G >>G *+ G+ >>J > >GH *>+ > >?>
+? J >+? *> + >>J
>>GH *>+ >*>G
*A+>**
• >+I>G4*+?>>*
+*H*>G!
•
•
•
">+*8*H<*GG<**?6
+I!8*H6>G
*J>>*!6>G!C>>J>G>>G
G >G *
+ ! +*H *>G > > A
4*+*H!
M +>A * J >I>> +*H) +
+
> +J H*+ *
+ *++ >
>$60O(*J>G!
,: ;".!#71!1.6!$D#1.(1!
O>
*>G>>+*H!*I+*HL>+>
+A+> >* + > **++ ! E F >*G>H*JO&+*++*>?>>?+*HJ?*I
*!,
>G>>*IJ?
# >
A>!
O> >*I +*H?>! T>? G++*>G G
>?>*
I>!O>>?*>G
J>
*+? > *4* >H * > >* G >*>+ **O10!Q -*>*+G>
>?>>>
+*H!6*
G >*+
O 1 E G > I +* > +*H * *> I J > *
>
+
> >
>I>
!
E>G?1T>?>
<**F>G
>+*H+
+?>*>*>G>>>
+?
*J>G>>JGO1>#
*!1
>I>&1NL>H!<>+
+&1N>*+?>G>!Q+*I
J>M
G+
+6<6
I>4!E
*
>
>*A>6+<
6*+O>>!
>GGG
**!A6<6&31>>GG
>G*
+!J*>*J>
+
JJ>>J**6<6>
J*!
O>>+>+>I>
J>+*H)-*
*>>1&=ZD
; >+*++*++
>GA+>>>*G>!
9
FB?%)<?%%)
>
! ' !"&'!"#!'! (-"(# -"!(H I#H"
Y'/0Y E$
(Y'
&1NYY'
+&O!
1N% 2 O>
*I+*H*>G!E+*H>++?IU
E1&
J&1N!*+*H>
+?>I++
*+I>>+!
O0= 2 O> *I +*H *>G G 1 > , > ! >
0=O
O>1
T>?>8*H?6>G$O1T86(!8*HL*>G+A+
>
GJ J O0= 7 $ > ! C+A> +*HL
*>G(!
M 2 O> *I > +*H! * +*H X L >J + OM
> > G A G I> >+*H*>G!"*
I
+GA
GI>
>+*H*>G!E+*H>++?I
U J &1N! * +*H + > I! "I
++*+I>>+!
K1E
O> *I >> +*H > +*H 7 > *
>G >! C* * > 7
*
+ A> * > * >
**!
"*
?I+>$**(!1?>>&1NL
*>H4*!
,%+-"(# "*! 1! &'!"#!'! (#$H'!
EY
1N% 2 NGJ*+*H*>G1N%?I>
A>
E1&
?*I>
>>?>+*H?*>G**
*+ *J ! T A >
* * > TJG ! T>?> 8*H? 6>G
*>>G
**1N%!+*H*>G!
O0= 2 <!8*H6>G$<86(*G+?I>6
+!T8*H6>G 0=O
$6T86(6
+!Q8*H6>G$6Q86(+>>>+IJ
O1T86!C>JO1T86+*!*>G*J>>I><86!
M 2 1 X +?G GI A G I> >
OM
+*H*>G!1
+A!TA>
*
*>I*
+!1?G*
+>G>
>*+
J>>J+**>!
K1E
E > G? 1 T>?>
<* * F >G > +*H +
+? >* > *>G! K>H
>HL6>KE1!
9%+-"(# "- ="+-!$ I!('"! + *! 1! !" ' H
1N% 2 E>* +* > ? >?> >> >G >> +*H
E1&
*>G>+*>>TJG!T>?>8*H?6>G>>
>> * >! E >>JH >G >? > GJ
J >>?> +*H? *>G) *>G J *>G
>+*+>*+*J*>G!
O0= 2 >*A
>>GG>G*
+!+*H*>G*J>?)
0=O
>JG ! > +*H *>G >JG ! +*H *>G! QGI
+?<!8*H6>G>K<!8*H6>G
M 2 E>* +*>?>?>
>+*H+
OM
! * X ! *>G >>G >* > *
*
>+?J**J!E>
**>*
G7
JU+>>+*H
7>>*>>J!
>
>*4 G JA > G *J *>G >?>* >
>
**+!
K1E
KE1 + > G? >? + *> $ >G( >>?>!
Q>HL*>G
*J+*H!!
:%+-"(#!++ "$ '+ H I#H '
Y'$
Y('
* YEY
1N% 2 1*?>G*
I+?G>+>)>GJ
E1&
*
+ > > *J *
+ G >> >! 1 ?
>A >
J **J +?
*+ *+ >> 4? 6
+I 0*+? > H* +
*+! EG>+> *I+?>G*>
G ? > J > > > G
>
9 I+? *! E >+ G
>+>*+
>?J!
O0= 2 1 > G?> J>G +*H I> 0=O
>+*H!>J>?*G>G>
>+*H>
G!1?>>
>?*
>>*?U>*J!**+J+*+>GJ
J!
M 2 1*?>G*
I+?G>+>)>GJ
OM
*
+ > > *J *
+ G >> >! 1 ?
>A >
J **J +?
*+ *+ >> 4? 6
+I 0*+? > H* +
*+!EG>+>*I+?>G*>
G ? 7 *! E
>+G>+>*+
>?J!
K1E
1?>G*
1 <E>G*
+
> G
G9
G?>>
>?*!Q*H1O>!
%+-"(# "-((! "! -= !( *! +!(H
2
2Y 0$!!(
2 Y
1N% 2 ">GHL * > > *
* 1N% + U ?> > E1&
? *>?! E> > *
*> +? *
++ > *J+ +A+>
*
? ?I * * + >+IL
*> > >> >>J ! Q *> >
*
*1N%?*>$*(>**H+>?IL
*!">GHL* >+?*>+*4+*
>+>!8*>+>>AH**4
?JA
!
O0= 2 O0=+
>?
*>+?>>
!
0=O
1 J ** ? G?> * V#R- JW!
E*G>?*J
+?*>+!
M 2 ">GHL* >>*
*X+U?>>?
OM
*>?!E>>*
*>+?*
++>
*J+ +A+>
*
? ?I *! ">GHL * > +
?*>*++*>+>!8*
>+ > *J ?IG * >+ H *+ ? *
!
K1E
K1E+>?*>G??>??4!A?**>+*)+>
*
$
?>+?(!
J!!!#-"(#$-"$ ! I$ *! + H '
Y'
$!!(Y
1N% 2 *+*H*>G+A
*!=A*
E1&
+*H *>G 7 ! 6>? >HL > A *+*G
**!+*H*>G!<>+*
+*H *>G + ! 6>
>+
>+*+*H*>G1N%+*+
+*H
*>G*>J> > >
A
>
J>*J>!
O0= 2 '
+>>IGI>G4*>J
)>><*
0=O
G1*GI>G
>+I
G>H>>?++??
>
!'+>>?IA?>
?>>>G4G*+?A
A>
*>>
L*!Q
*
A
H>L>>J*J*>>?+*H
>>><I2K3">GT8*H!=+
7 > * ? >> G+? > >>
> +*H * >GJ! '
> +
>IJ!
M 2 * +*H + A * >* OM
+* >+ >! = A * 7 ! 6>?
>HL>A
**+*H*!
*>G!<>+*+*H+
!1>A
>J+ I> > +*H *>+ * !
*>G>*
+>>*+
*>!
K1E
EA Z ; > > I*>
>A * J!=>
>!
K%+-"(# "!$ *!+ *(""!=! ( +!#+'(! (H
1N% 2 1N%
>I**>>*
H>>!E*>+A?*HL
E1&
>*+>JJ>*JGH*J>!
" >*JG H ? I+? *H 1N%) > J*>G? F E> >GA >> 1N% D+I + 0*+
6*J &*
> >G+? 1N% 0*
=G &*
*>>>>1N%!
O0= 2 O0=>*?*IJG>>*G
H
!E
+*O0=
0=O
M OM
K1E
:
JG+ >R>*G
H
*+I* *> C>*
6
8I>*JQ>++**
*>*
*7CAG>
*RJ!
2 X >***>>*
H>>!EJG+>
>*G
>*+*H*>G
+J>*JGH
*J>!">*JGH?
!!I+?>G)
• ZT *? > ; > H*J O& * R >*JG
H
• *G > >J >*JG H > *J
>
JG+>>+*H*>G
• >> Z > >>; + J
>*JGH9
7>
>
*>*
• HA* *+ J >*JG H *J >G J
*+O&
• *>*>*
>*JGH
J*JHA*
*+J>*JG>>GJ
O&
• >
J*>G?!
1>*G > JGI >
>+?? >
>?>*J > +*H
*+>*GH!T?
JG>>!Z
*G;
>
!
F
F ? L ;GB
F?
;BBDBMNDE
O<?>
P?%Q
• 6++)
*>
>!
K* >>
+ >>?> +*H? *>G
HJ>*
*!
OA
>>?> +*H? *>G > + >
?
>+?!
Q>
>GH>*
*!
K**>+A>G>1N%>*
+
>+*H
• M+ 7 * > +*H I> +
>
PBQ
• 6++)
6>
>?*>
J>*
+*H
O>/0>*?*+I
• C*
$*J*>(7**>J
>?/0
• 1>+/0
• K**GJ2*
++>G*J>G
*
+!+*H*>GV06W
• 3>I>
<T8*H>>I*+HL*+!
PQ
• 6++)
>
IL>
*>
>+*H
• C+H>*
*A>I>+*H
• QJ > > *
* + *
>>*J
>
P;Q
• 6++)
*>
>
* *+ >IH * > >? $HL( *
>>+
>
• =HLJ)>>*>+?
+?>+*H!
• * + > G >+? > > >>
*+
>?+*H
NE NDDR BBD BM N
DE
O<?>
P?%Q
• > > +H >>?>+*H?>+!
• "*K4*7+I>GL+?
>+*H!
• 0*+>*>
*>>+
• TA1
>?1J>G>?>>>>?>
+*H?
*>G!
PBQ
• 0*+ 60 +* >* >*J >>J
>GJG>G*
+!+*H*>G
• &1N7+I>GL+?
>+*H
• 0*+>*>
*>>+
PCQ
• ^
HL>A*>
• 0*+>*>
?Z**?;
• 1*>+
>+*H
• 6+HIK4*
>X
P;Q
• D>+7>GI>L*+*H+
• "*K4*7+I>GL+?
>+*H
• 0*+>*>
*>>+
•
B
BBD QM'\6' ' 1\1&=O
T0&EC'0C'0806Q^3'7KO"QE\6OMO<\806Q^3')
P?%Q
• EA>+Z ;!
D*++? *>G J J +*H
>+IL*>*J*>G!
• 6*>>I>
>+*HA+I
J**>?>4
>
+*H!
• = *> * G 7 > *>
!
• > ? *> J > +*H
*>G1N%!
• 8*HL*>G+>>
H
!
PBQ)
• EAZ ;
• 1>* *J O0= >* > +*H >? >+I +Z
;
• >?* J * I+ 7 * I > *+ >*J *+I>K<86
• E> >A J > * G >> J
>?+*HO0=>I*>GI*!
• E * +*H+ ? > >G +? >*H*J+>
O1T86!
PCQ
• EAZ ;
• >?*J*I+
• 1
>+*H>?*+>A
• =
*G!
P;Q
• EAZ ;
• >?*J*I+>A!I
J
>>>6<6!
• >H*KE1>H>KE1
>>
• =
*G!
•
NEC
;%EE
P?%Q
• >
*+?
>+IL>AH+*H!
• *>
+*H>+IL*>
• J > >
A
+*H
*>G
PBQ
• 1>* + O1T86 ?I >I* >>?> > > > > G
*
<*!8*H6>G
PCQ
• **>*4*J>O1T86
P;Q
• * *> I J >
*
>
+
>>
>I>
!
•
*HL>**>H*J++*H