It appears you don`t have a PDF plugin for this browser. No biggie
Transkrypt
It appears you don`t have a PDF plugin for this browser. No biggie
●●JOURNAL JOURNAL OF OFPUBLIC PUBLIC HEALTH, HEALTH, NURSING NURSING AND ANDMEDICAL MEDICAL RESCUE RESCUE ●●No. No.4/2015 ● ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING AND MEDICAL RESCUE ●4/2015 2/2014(38-43) ● ● 38 Coping with stress by women in early postpartum (Sposoby radzenia sobie ze stresem kobiet we wczesnym połogu) M Makara-Studzińska 1,A,D, K Zwierz 2,F, A Madej 1,B,C, A Wdowiak 2,E Abstract – Introduction. Pregnancy is a special time in the life of every woman. Regardless of whether having children is a dream come true or a surprise, it is considered in the context of stressful situations. The aim of this study is to show the ways of coping with stress during the postpartum period. Moreover, two separate groups of women with no symptoms and symptoms of postpartum depression (PPD) were distinguished. Materials and methods. The study involved 110 women in early postpartum aged 20-41, put into the following age groups: 20-24, 25-29, 30-35 and 36-41. All women agreed to fill out an anonymous questionnaire. The research tool used was the authors’ own questionnaire enriched with the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS). The results were subjected to statistical analysis. Results. When asked about the preferred styles of coping with stress, 44 (40%) of respondents answered that they applied the task-focused style, 43 (39.1%) – the avoidance-focused style, and 23 (20.9%) – the emotion-focused style. By means of the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale, it has been found that 85 (77.3%) of women surveyed show no signs of depression, while in 25 (22.7%) there is a high probability of its occurrence. Conclusions: The most popular method of coping with stress used by women during the postpartum period is conversation with a close person. Women who underwent an unplanned Caesarean section are more likely to develop symptoms of PPD, The use of emotion-focused style increases the risk of PPD. Skalą Depresji Poporodowej (EPDS). Uzyskane wyniki badań poddano analizie statystycznej. Wyniki: Na pytanie odnośnie preferowanych stylów radzenia sobie ze stresem 44 (40%) ankietowanych położnic odpowiedziało, że stosują styl skoncentrowany na zadaniu, 43 (39,1%) wybrało styl skoncentrowany na unikaniu, a 23 (20,9%) styl skoncentrowany na emocjach. Za pomocą Edynburskiej Skali Depresji Poporodowej ustalono, iż 85 (77,3%) położnic nie wykazuje objawów depresji, z kolei u 25 (22,7%) zachodzi duże prawdopodobieństwo jej występowania. Wnioski: Najczęściej stosowany sposób radzenia sobie ze stresem kobiet w okresie połogu to rozmowa z bliską osobą, Kobiety, u których wykonano nieplanowane cesarskie cięcie wykazują większą tendencję występowania objawów PPD, Stosowanie stylu skoncentrowanego na emocjach zwiększa ryzyko pojawienia się PPD. Słowa kluczowe - radzenie sobie ze stresem – połóg – depresja poporodowa. Author Affiliations: 1.Department of Applied Psychology, University of Lublin 2.Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Nursing Obstetrics and Gynecology, Medical University of Lublin Authors’ contributions to the article: Key words - coping with stress – postpartum – postpartum depression. Streszczenie – Wstęp. Ciąża to czas szczególny w życiu każdej kobiety. Niezależnie od tego, czy jest ona spełnieniem marzeń o posiadaniu potomstwa, czy też zaskoczeniem – rozpatrywana jest w kontekście sytuacji stresogennej. Celem niniejszej pracy jest ukazanie sposobów radzenia sobie ze stresem w okresie połogu. Dodatkowo wyodrębniona została grupa kobiet bez objawów i z objawami depresji poporodowej (PPD). Materiał i metody: W badaniu udział wzięło 110 kobiet we wczesnym połogu w wieku 20-41 lat, w grupach 20-24, 25-29, 30-35 i 36-41 lat. Wszystkie badane kobiety wyraziły zgodę na wypełnienie anonimowej ankiety. Narzędzie badawcze stanowił kwestionariusz ankiety własnego autorstwa, wzbogacony Edynburską A. The idea and the planning of the study B. Gathering and listing data C. The data analysis and interpretation D. Writing the article E. Critical review of the article F. Final approval of the article Correspondence to: Agata Madej, Department of Applied Psychology, University of Lublin, W. Chodźki 15 Str.,PL-20-093 Lublin, Poland, e-mail: [email protected] Accepted for publication: October 9, 2015. ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING ANDAND MEDICAL RESCUE ● No.4/2015 ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING MEDICAL RESCUE ● 2/2014 ● ● I. INTRODUCTION he role of a woman as a mother is considered to be natural from the biological point of view. It is a general belief that taking care of a newborn child should be a source of joy and satisfaction [1]. Unfortunately, the reality is in stark contrast to that. Pregnancy is a time of intense effort for a woman’s body, which results from dynamic changes in both hormones and the psyche [2]. Concern with the child’s health appears and relationships with the close ones may become disturbed. Problems may occur in professional life and self-perception. Sadness and depression are also likely [2-5] to emerge. The sense of loneliness, anxiety and the lack of support all result in emotional disorders which may gain intensity in the postpartum period, even leading to postpartum depression [6-10]. Data provided in literature on the subject proves that the perinatal period is a time of increased risk of developing anxiety or depressive disorders which may have an adverse effect on pregnancy, labour, and postpartum [11]. Childbirth has an enormous impact on a woman’s body and mind. Contemporary mothers evince a lower resistance to stress and the effects of emotional problems than women in previous generations. A genetic predisposition to such problems is presumed to exist for pregnant women whose first-degree relatives experienced postpartum disorders. They include: the postpartum blues (25-83%), postpartum depression (1020%), and psychosis (0.1-0.2%) [12-17]. Postpartum is the period of 6-8 weeks following delivery during which the anatomical, morphologigal, and functional changes related to pregnancy and childbirth retreat and the woman’s body returns to its non-pregnant state. It begins in the period of delivering a complete placenta and it is characterised by the highest-ever risk of developing mental disorders in the woman’s lifetime [6, 12, 18]. This is due to the fact that postpartum mothers are less resistant to stressful stimuli and more prone to emotional pain [13]. Stress is an indispensable element of every person’s life. Researchers believe that people should attempt to control stress and find ways to cope with it [19]. Such methods alleviate stress and reduce its negative effects. Expecting a child is interpreted as a difficult situation, especially if it is the first child, when the parents are minors or elderly, when pregnancy was unplanned or it occurred before marriage, when the mother is physically/mentally disabled or when complications appear in pregnancy and hospitalisation is necessary. Two types of stress may be distinguished in the perinatal period: T 39 acute – triggered by a sudden and important change, i.e. childbirth or the baby’s/mother’ illness, Chronic – caused by the everyday routine, i.e. a lonely mother’ care of a child, financial problems [20]. For the majority of women, childbirth and the new role in life – that of a mother – constitutes a stressful factor and leads to a considerable emotional burden. Usually, their well-being depends on their mental state and relationships with close ones in the perinatal period. Mothers who are flexible, open to changes, with a good self-esteem, who plan and reach their goals, communicate effectively with the environment and have the ability to ask for help, cope better with the difficulties of motherhood. An additional burden for young mothers may be the financial situation. In some sources, also the external resources related to religiousness, cultural heritage, and national tradition are mentioned [13, 20]. The starting point for the discussion on the topic mentioned in the title is the typology by Endler and Parker, who proposed three styles of coping with stressful situations: the task-focused style – the subject takes action to solve a problem by means of cognitive processing or by attempting to change the situation, the emotion-focused style – it pertains to people tending to focus on their own emotions such as anger, tension, guilt, which leads to wishful thinking and fantasising in difficult situations, the avoidance-focused style – it takes two forms: engaging in displacement activities and seeking social contact [21-24]. II. MATERIALS AND METHODS The study involved 110 women in early postpartum aged 20-41 hospitalised from April to June 2014 at the Obstetrics and Perinatology Clinic of the Autonomous Public Hospital no. 4 in Lublin. All the women surveyed had been informed about the purpose and rules of the study and subsequently asked to fill out a questionnaire. Participation was voluntary and anonymous. The diagnostic survey method was used. The research tool was the authors’ own questionnaire enriched with the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS). The authors’ own questionnaire included demographic questions related to age, civil status, education and place of residence; there were also questions concerning child-bearing, the course of pregnancy, the manner of delivery (natural birth or Caesarean section), problems related to maternity, and the ways of coping with stress triggered by new responsibilities. The EPDS is a screening question- ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING ANDAND MEDICAL RESCUE ● No.4/2015 ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING MEDICAL RESCUE ● 2/2014 ● ● naire composed of 10 simple statements making it possible to test the level of postpartum depression [25]. In the study group, 15 (13.6%) women were aged 20-24, 33 (30%) women were aged 25-29, 39 (35.5%) were 30-35 years of age and 23 (20.9%) were aged 36-41. For 47 (42.7%) patients, pregnancy ended in vaginal birth, and 63 (57.3%) women had a Caesarean section. In terms of civil status, 95 (86.4%) patients were married, 12 (10.9%) were unmarried, and 3 (2.7%) declared being divorced. Elementary education was declared by 1 (0.9%) respondent, vocational education by 5 (4.5%) women, secondary education by 26 (23.6%), and higher education by 78 (70.9%) women. 23 (20.9%) respondents lived in a city of over 100,000 inhabitants, whereas 25 (22.7%) resided in a city of 25,000 to 100,000 inhabitants, 11 (10%) lived in a town of up to 25,000 residents, and 51 (46.4%) women lived in the country. Statistical methods In order to investigate the correlation between the qualitative characteristics, the Chi-Square Independence Test (χ2) was used. The significance level of p<0.05 was adopted to indicate the existence of statistically significant correlations. Statistical analysis was based on IBM SPSS Statistics software (version 21). 40 Most frequently, the respondents selected conversation with a close person as a method of coping with stress – 77 (70%). Sleep is preferred by 47 (42.7%) women, a warm bath by 30 (27.3%), physical activity by 25 (22.7%), and music therapy was selected by 11 (10%) respondents. The remaining methods of coping with stress are massage for 9 (8.2%) of the respondents and herbal infusions for 7 (7.3%). It also results from the authors’ own study that 49 (44.5%) of the recent mothers surveyed considered calm breathing to be an effective method of overcoming stress. The analysis of results using the Chi-Square test evinced a statistically significant correlation between the form of childbirth and the occurrence of postpartum depression. Women who underwent an unplanned Caesarean section (due to risk to the child’s life) have a higher (39.3%) tendency towards postpartum depression symptoms than women who underwent a planned C-section (20%) or gave natural birth (14.9%). The results are presented in table no. 2. Table 2. The risk of postpartum depression depending on the manner of delivery χ2 ESDP p III. RESULTS Lack of postpartum depression symptoms Likelihood of postpartum depression symptoms N 40 7 % 85.1% 14.9% N 28 7 % 80.0% 20.0% N 17 11 % N 60.7% 85 39.3% 25 % 77.3% 22.7% Manner of delivery Table 1 presents the analysis of the style of coping with stressful situations by recent mothers depending on the manner of delivery. From mothers who gave natural birth, 20 (45.5%) are characterised by a task-focused style, while 12 (52.2%) match the emotion-focused style. Both women who gave natural birth and those who underwent a planned Caesarean section used the avoidance-focused style to the same degree (34.9%). No statistically significant correlation has been found between the variables mentioned. Natural birth Planned Caesarean section Unplanned Caesarean section Total 6.162 p= 0.046 Table 1. The styles of coping with stressful situations by postpartum mothers depending on the manner of delivery Manner of delivery Styles of coping with stress Taskfocused style Emotionfocused style Avoidancefocused style Natural birth N % N % N % N Total % 20 45.5 % 12 52.2 % 15 34.9 % 47 42.7 % Planned Caesarean section Unplanned Caesarean section 16 8 36.4% 18.2% 6 5 26.1% 21.7% 13 15 30.2% 34.9% 35 28 31.8% 25.5% χ2 p 4.274 p= 0.370 It has been demonstrated that there are no significant correlations between the number of births given by the respondents and the occurrence of postpartum depression. The percentage distribution of women showing symptoms of postpartum depression is similar in each of the groups studied. Moreover, no correlation has been noted between the women’s age and the frequency of PPD. Taking into account the recent mothers’ civil status, it may be observed that divorcees evince a higher (66.7%) tendency towards postpar- ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING ANDAND MEDICAL RESCUE ● No.4/2015 ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING MEDICAL RESCUE ● 2/2014 ● ● tum depression than married women (22.1%) and unmarried women (16.7%). Table 3 presents an analysis of the correlation between the postpartum mothers’ education and the risk of postpartum depression. PPD symptoms were not observed in women with elementary and vocational education, yet women with secondary and higher education experienced PPD with a similar frequency. in displacement activities, merely 14% show symptoms of PPD. In turn, 20.5% of the respondents use the most desirable style of coping with stress – the task-focused style. Table 4. The influence of the style of coping with stress on the appearance of PPD symptoms Table 3. The influence of education on the risk of PPD symptoms Lack of postpartum depression symptoms Likelihood of postpartum depression symptoms N 35 9 % 79.5% 20.5% N 13 10 % 56.5% 43.5% N 37 6 χ2 p Education N Lack of postpartum depression symptoms Likelihood of postpartum depression symptoms 1 0 Task-focused style Elementary % 100.0% 0.0% N 5 0 χ2 p ESDP Styles of coping with stress ESDP 41 Emotionfocused style 7.654 Vocational % N 100.0% 20 0.0% 6 Secondary % 76.9% 23.1% N 59 19 % 75.6% 24.4% N 85 25 % 77.3% 22.7% p= 0.022 Avoidancefocused style % 86.0% 14.0% N 85 25 % 77.3% 22.7% 1.885 p= 0.597 Higher Total Table 4 presents a statistical analysis of the correlation between the applied style of coping with stress among postpartum mothers and the risk of developing postpartum depression. Postpartum mothers applying the emotionfocused style (43.5%) show a tendency towards depression. Among women who avoid solving the problem by engaging Total When it comes to the correlation between methods of coping with stress and the frequency of PPD symptoms – no significant correlation may be observed between these variables. Postpartum mothers who have chosen massage, aromatherapy and breathing exercises do not show symptoms of postpartum depression. The percentage distribution of women with PPD symptoms in the remaining groups has been presented in table no. 5. ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING ANDAND MEDICAL RESCUE ● No.4/2015 ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING MEDICAL RESCUE ● 2/2014 ● ● IV. DISCUSSION The main problem discussed in the study is the manners of coping with stress among women in early postpartum. The results concerning the preferred styles of coping with stressful situations have been presented. Also, groups of women with and without postpartum depression symptoms have been distinguished. Based on his own research, Czapiński [26] observed that the strategies of coping with stress differentiated the level of mental well-being regardless of the intensity of stress experienced in life. As a result, individuals following an active task-oriented strategy had better well-being rates than individuals who used passive strategies or gave up in the face of difficulty. The results presented in this study as well as those obtained by Podolska et al. [23] have demonstrated that there exists a correlation between the style of coping with stress preferred by women and the occurrence of postpartum depression symptoms. Postpartum mothers who underwent Caeserian sections statistically significantly more often selected the emotion-focused and avoidance-focused styles. Furthermore, no statistically significant differences have been observed between women as far as age and education are concerned. This data overlaps with the results obtained by Gebuza et al. [12] and Kowalska et al. [2]. There are reports in the literature of the subject pointing to the factors preventing the use of constructive methods of coping with stress. This stems from the mother’ sintensified neuroticism correlating with the experience of negative emotions such as anxiety, depression as well as the sense of hopelessness and guilt. The most desirable style would be that focusing on the task [27]. According to the research by Kossakowska-Petrycka et al. [3], stress levels are lower in women with a correct course of pregnancy compared to women in high-risk pregnancy. Research by Bączek et al. [28] points to the prevalence of fatigue (49%) in the group of postpartum mothers studied, which is a natural state following labour. Depression affected 12% of the female respondents and it mainly resulted from the change in lifestyle and the appearance of new responsibilities. 39% of the mothers surveyed enjoyed wellbeing. Many authors point to civil status as a predictor of postpartum depression [24, 26]. Research by Kettunen et al. [29] has shown that the mental state of recent mothers ought to be monitored during 6 weeks after labour. Selfobservation is not sufficiently effective. It is also crucial to inform women about PPD and to discuss the alarming symptoms so that women may recognise them on their own. Therefore, two groups of women aged 18-40 were exam 42 ined: the experimental group comprised 104 mothers with PPD symptoms, whereas the control group comprised 104 women without PPD symptoms. It emerged that 46.2% of mothers showed symptoms of postpartum depression one and a half weeks after childbirth, 74% after fourth weeks, 83.7% after six weeks, and 98.1% after three months. The results of research by Kowalska et al. [2] confirm the thesis that the recent mother’s civil status has an influence on the postpartum stress levels. The best average wellbeing and the lowest average stress levels were experienced by patients in a relationship, and the worst well-being and highest stress levels affected lonely mothers. Guardino et al. [30] have found that women applying the avoidance-focused style are in the group with risk of developing postpartum depression symptoms. From 306 women examined by them, who had given birth to their first child, those who avoided confrontation with difficult situations in the last trimester of pregnancy exposed themselves to the risk of PPD symptoms in the sixth week following labour. V. CONCLUSIONS The diagnosis of styles of coping with stress should take place as early as possible because it allows choosing the best course of action having a positive influence on the emotional state of women in the difficult period of pregnancy and postpartum. Continuous education about the postpartum period is necessary and it provides the woman with useful knowledge and competences relating to her new life situation. It is crucial that pregnant women and mothers in the postpartum period should be offered contact with medical peronnel in the form of individual consultation or lectures organised for larger groups of women interested in the subject. VI. REFERENCES [1] Iracka E, Lewicka M. Występowanie depresji poporodowej wśród położnic. EJMT 2014; 3;4: 60-66. [2] Kowalska J, Olszowa D, Markowska D, Teplik M, Rymaszewska J. Aktywność fizyczna i szkoła rodzenia w czasie ciąży a poziom postrzeganego stresu i objawów depresyjnych u kobiet po porodzie. Psychiatr Pol 2014; 48; 5: 889-900. [3] Kossakowska-Petrycka K, Walęcka-Matyja K. Psychologiczne uwarunkowania wystąpienia depresji poporodowej u kobiet w ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING ANDAND MEDICAL RESCUE ● No.4/2015 ● JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, NURSING MEDICAL RESCUE ● 2/2014 ● ● ciąży o przebiegu prawidłowym i ciąży wysokiego ryzyka. Ginekol Pol 2007;78: 544-548. [4] Sulima M, Lewicka M, Makara–Studzińska M, Wiktor K, Wiktor H. Nasilenie stresu u kobiet ciężarnych z zagrażającym porodem przedwczesnym. JPHNMR 2013; (4):37-42. [5] Iwanowicz-Palus G, Rzońca E, Bień A, Włoszczak-Szubzda A. Self-reported preparation of Polish midwives for independent performance of health education activities. JPHNMR 2014; (2):41-49. [6] Kaźmierczak M, Gierszewska M, Gebuza G, Mieczkowska, Banaszkiewicz M. Analiza wybranych zmiennych determinujących występowanie zaburzeń nastroju po porodzie. MONZ 2014; 20;4: 390-395. [7] Makara-Studzińska M, Podstawka D, Doroszuk B, Niewiadomska I, Kwiatkowska G. Wsparcie emocjonalne w opiniach położnic po cięciu cesarskim. Hyg Pub Health 2013; 48; 3: 346351. [8] Makara-Studzińska M, Wdowiak A, Podstawka D, Stec M. Opieka personelu medycznego oddziałów położniczych nad kobietą i noworodkiem – w ocenie pacjentek. MONZ 2013; 19;3: 288-293. [9] Podolska M, Majewska A. Lęk jako stan i jako cecha w grupie kobiet, u których zakończono ciążę za pomocą cięcia cesarskiego. Klin Perinatol Ginekol 2007; 43; 4: 60-63. [10] Tataj-Puzyna U. Jak położna może wpłynąć na zmniejszenie lęku kobiety przed porodem? Położ Nauk Prakt 2011;2: 58-62. [11] Wiktor H, Lewicka M, Humeniuk E, Gulanowska-Gędek B, Wiktor K, Kanadys K. Ocena poziomu lęku u kobiet w połogu. Roczniki Pomorskiej Akademii Medycznej w Szczecinie 2009; 55;1: 66-69. [12] Gebuza G, Kaźmierczak M, Gierszewska M, Michalska E. Problemy kobiet w połogu i ich przyczyny. Perinatol Neonatol Ginekol 2010; 3;4: 290-295. [13] Makara-Studzińska M, Iwanowicz-Palus G. Psychologia w położnictwie i ginekologii.Warszawa; Wydawnictwo Lekarskie PZWL, 2009. [14] Józefowicz O, Rabe-Jabłońska J. Stres a czynność układu neuroendokrynnego. Psychiatr Psychol Klin 2009; 9;2:116-124. [15] Forman DR, O’Hara MW, Stuart S, Gorman LL, Larsen KE, Coy KC. Effective treatment for postpartum depression is not sufficient to improve the developing mother-child relationship. Dev Psychopat 2007; 19; 2: 585-602. [16] Guszkowska M. Lęk przed porodem i determinujące go czynniki – przegląd literatury. Psychiatr Psychol Klin 2012;5:154161. [17] Hillerer KM, Neumann ID, Slattery DA. From Stress to Postpartum Mood and Anxiety Disorders: How Chronic Peripartum Stress Can Impair Maternal Adaptations. Neuroendocrinology 2011;1-17. [18] Dudenhausen JW. Położnictwo praktyczne i operacje położnicze. Warszawa; Wydawnictwo Lekarskie PZWL, 2010. [19] Cieślik A. Osobowość a sposoby radzenia sobie ze stresem. Stud Med 2014; 30;1: 57-60. [20] Krzyżanowska-Zbucka J. Problemy emocjonalne kobiet w okresie okołoporodowym. Fundacja Rodzić po Ludzku. Warszawa; ACOG Practice Bulletin 2008. [21] Sygit-Kowalkowska E. Radzenie sobie ze stresem jako zachowanie zdrowotne człowieka – perspektywa psychologiczna. Hyg Pub Health 2014; 49; 2: 202-208. [22] Mroczkowska D, Białkowska J. Style radzenia sobie ze stresem jako zmienne determinujące jakość życia młodych dorosłych. MONZ 2014; 20;3: 265-269. 43 [23] Podolska M, Majewska A. Style radzenia sobie w sytuacjach stresowych stosowane przez matki w połogu. Klin Perinatol Ginekol 2007; 43; 4: 64-67. [24] Mariańczyk K, Libera A, Oleszczuk J. Poczucie beznadziejności a style radzenia sobie ze stresem u kobiet po porodzie przedwczesnym. Ginekol Pol 2010; 81: 342-346. [25] Kossakowska K. Edynburska Skala Depresji Poporodowej – właściwości psychometryczne i charakterystyka. Folia Psychol 2013;17: 39-50. [26] Czapiński J, Panek T. Diagnoza Społeczna 2011. Warunki i Jakość Życia Polaków. Warszawa; Contemporary Economics, 2011. [27] Iwanowicz-Palus G, Bień A. Psychoprofilaktyka u kobiet w ciąży. In: Opieka nad kobietą ciężarną. Bień A (red.) Warszawa; Wydawnictwo Lekarskie PZWL 2009: 342-348. [28] Bączek G, Golubińska H, Dmoch-Gajzlerska E. Wybrane problemy okresu połogowego – rola położnej środowiskoworodzinnej. Prz Med Uniw Rzesz Inst Leków 2012;2: 200-212. [29] Kettunen P, Koistinen E, Hintikka J. Is postpartum depression a homogenous disorder: time of onset, severity, symptoms and hopelessness in relation to the course of depression. BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 2014; 14: 402. [30] Guardino CM, Schetter CD. Coping during pregnancy: a system review and recommendations. Health Psychol Rev 2014; 8;1: 70-94.