docSUPPLY CHAIN STRATEGIES IN EMERGING MARKETS: AN INDIAN PERSPECTIVE
download 
Reklamacja Transkrypt
SUPPLY CHAIN STRATEGIES IN EMERGING MARKETS: AN INDIAN PERSPECTIVE
SUPPLY CHAIN STRATEGIES
IN EMERGING MARKETS:
AN INDIAN PERSPECTIVE
Balwinder Singh
!"#$%&'()*+,-!$"./01234356%$7'(8$9:;51!$<=(;54!>!89?!%;5@%&$!
Abstract
2-'(,$%,5-!(A'9850BB'(5?=,'5,(0#9?50<<0(9=%$9$'859?!95/!%%095!BB0(&5905 '5
-$88'&50=95 :5/0(<0(!9'5#0("&5.@%&$!5?!85!5?=,'5<09'%9$!"5#?$/?5$85:'95905
'5'C<"0$9'&.5D?'5"0,$89$/8E8=<<":5/?!$%5'C<'(985?!7'5%095 ''%5! "'5905-''95
9?'5('F=$('-'%950B5'7'%5=( !%5<0<="!9$0%58=//'88B="":5805B!(.55D?$85<!<'(5
B0/=8'850%5$,%$9$%,59?'5-$%&50B5/0(<0(!9'5 $,#$,85#$9?5!5!$-5905!&&('8859?'5
$88='850B58=<<":5/?!$%589(!9',$'85?0"$89$/!"":.5D?'5($,?95!<<(0!/?59058=<<":5
/?!$%5 &'7'"0<-'%95 $85 B=%&!-'%9!"5 905 8=//'88B="5 'C<"0$9!9$0%5 0B5 9?'8'5 0<<0(9=%$9$'8.5
Key words: 8=<<":5/?!$%589(!9',$'8;5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'98
Introduction
@%&$!5$85!5&'7'"0<$%,5/0=%9(:5#?'('58?$B9$%,5<0"$9$/8;5=%89! "'5'/0%0-$/8;5"!/A50B5 !8$/5$%B(!89(=/9=(';5!%&5"$-$9'&5!<<"$/!9$0%50B5'%9'(<($8'5-!%!,'-'%959'/?%0"0,$'85!('59?'5%0(-8.5@%58<$9'50B59?'8'5/?!""'%,'85!%&5<$9B!""8;5
$95 ?!85 !5 ?=,'5 <09'%9$!"5 905 !&&('885 9?'5 '-'(,$%,5 %''&85 0B5 9?'5 <'0<"'5 !%&5
8=<<":5/?!$%5<"!:85!%5$-<0(9!%95(0"'.
G%'5-0('5$88='5#?$/?5-'($985&$8/=88$0%5$859?!959?'5@%&$!%5-!(A'95$85905 '5
/0%8$&'('&5!85!58= H/0%9$%'%9I58'(7$%,5@%&$!5$858$-$"!(59058'(7$%,5!5#$&'":5
&$7'(8'5-!(A'95#?'('5"!%,=!,'8;5/="9=('8;5?! $985!%&5/0%8=-'(5<('B'('%/'85!('5&$BB'('%95$%5'7'(:58$%,"'5@%&$!%589!9'.52!/?589!9'59?'('B0('5('F=$('85
!5/=890-$J'&5!<<(0!/?.
@%&$!%5<0<="!9$0%5/!%5 '5&$7$&'&5$%9057!($0=858',-'%98I5="9(!H($/?;5($/?;5
=<<'(5-$&&"'5/"!88;5-$&&"'5/"!88;5"0#'(5-$&&"'5/"!88;5<00(50%59?'5 0(&'(5"$%'5
K!8<$($%,5905/0-'5905-$&&"'5/"!88L5!%&5<00(5<0<="!9$0%.527'(:5/!9',0(:5?!85
&$BB'('%95('F=$('-'%985!%&5$%9'""$,'%95-!(A'95-=895/!9'(59?'5('F=$('-'%985
Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4
!//0(&$%,":5;#?$/?5('F=$('85!59?0(0=,?5=%&'(89!%&$%,50B59?'5"0/!"5/0%8=-<9$0%5<!99'(%8.5@%5!&&$9$0%;5<($/'85!%&5<(0&=/985%''&5905 '59!$"0('&59059?'59!89'5
!%&5#!""'9850B5'!/?5/!9',0(:50(5,(0=<50B5/!9',0($'850B59?'5/0%8=-'(8.
1.Challenges for India
1.
1.Poor infrastructure
D?'5 $,,'895/?!""'%,'5B0(5@%&$!5$85!5<00(5$%B(!89(=/9=('.5@%B(!89(=/9=('5
&'7'"0<-'%95$859?'5,('!9'895/?!""'%,'5B!/$%,5@%&$!;5$B5$95$859058=89!$%5?$,?5
"'7'"850B5'/0%0-$/5,(0#9?.5@%&$!N
85<08$9$0%50%59?'5#0("&59(!&'5-!<5?!85 ''%5
,(0#$%,589'!&$":507'(59?'5<!895:'!(8.5O0#'7'(;59?'5<?:8$/!"5$%B(!89(=/9=('5
?!85%095 ''%5! "'5905A''<5=<5#$9?59?'5/0=%9(:N
85'/0%0-$/5'C<!%8$0%.5D(!%8<0(9'&570"=-'85!('5/"$- $%,5(!<$&":;5&'-!%&5B0(5'%'(,:5?!85$%/('!8'&5!%&5
9?'5/0--=%$/!9$0%5%'9#0(A5$85('!/?$%,5$985-!C$-=-5/!<!/$9:.5P'$%,5?0-'5
90507'(5QB9:5%!9$0%!"5?$,?#!:8;59?'58!&589!9'50B5!BB!$(85$859?!95-0895%!9$0%!"5
?$,?#!:85!('5>=8959#05"!%'850(5'7'%5"'88'(.5D?'5&'8$,%50B59?'5?$,?#!:85$85
!5 -!99'(5 0B5 ,('!95 $-<0(9!%/'5 8$%/'5 0%":5 <(0<'(":5 &'8$,%'&5 ?$,?#!:85 /!%5
#$9?89!%&59?'5<('88=('5/('!9'&5 :5?'!7:57'?$/"'8.5R<!(95B(0-5 '$%,5%!((0#5
9?':5!('5!"805?$,?":5/0%,'89'&58$%/'5F=$9'5!5"!(,'5<!(950B5@%&$!N
85B('$,?95$85
/!(($'&50%59?'8'5?$,?#!:8.5
S 0('5/!%5 '5!//0-<"$8?'&5$B59?'('N
85 '99'(5$%B(!89(=/9=('5!%&59?'5! $"$9:5
9058/!"'5=<5905,'95<(0&=/9859059?'57$""!,'8.5T0(5'C!-<"';59?'5T00&5U'/=($9:5
P$""5 9?!95 ?!85 ''%5 <!88'&5 %''&85 905 '5 $-<"'-'%9'&.5 O0#5 905 ,'95 ($/'5 !%&5
B00&5,(!$%859059?'57$""!,'85('-!$%85!%5U3S 5/?!""'%,'.5D?'('N
85,0$%,5905 '5
!5?=,'50<<0(9=%$9:50%/'5$%B(!89(=/9=('5 099"'%'/A85!('5('-07'&.5@%&$!5?!85
9?'5<09'%9$!"5905/0-'5=<5!85!58=<<":5/?!$%5/'%9('50B5'C/'""'%/'5B0(59?'5#0("&.5
D?'5A':5$%B(!89(=/9=(!"5/?!""'%,'855$%70"7'59?'5!/9$7'5(0"'50B5(0!&85!%&59?'5
@%&$!%5(0!&5B('$,?95$%&=89(:;5(!$"#!:8;5<0(985!%&58?$<<$%,;5!$(<0(985!%&59?'5
@%&$!%5 !$(5 B('$,?95 $%&=89(:.5 D?'8';5 $%5 9=(%;5 !('5 8=<<0(9'&5 :5 <0#'(;5 '%'(,:5 !%&5 9?'5 @3DH$%B(!89(=/9=('.5 R"9?0=,?5 9?'5 @%&$!%5 ,07'(%-'%95 ?!85 ''%5
9!A$%,589'<85905$-<(07'559?'5/0=%9(:N
85<?:8$/!"5$%B(!89(=/9=('V59?'('5$8589$""5
-=/?5,(0=%&5"'B95905/07'(.5S !%:5:'!(850B5=%&'(5$%7'89-'%95!('5%0#59!A$%,5
9?'$(590""50%59?'5/0=%9(:N
85/0-<'9$9$7'%'885!85@%&$!589$""5/0-<!('85=%B!70(!":5 905 09?'(5 '-'(,$%,5 '/0%0-$'8.5 @%5 !&&$9$0%;5 89(=/9=(!"5 $%'BQ/$'%/$'85 $%5
9?'5 Q%!%/$!"5 8:89'-;5 /0=<"'&5 #$9?5 9?'5 ,"0 !"5 /('&$95 /(=%/?;5 ?!7'5 "'B95 9?'5
/0=%9(:5#$9?5!58?0(9B!""50B56UW5X.Y5 $""$0%5$%5Q%!%/$%,5A':5$%B(!89(=/9=('5
<(0>'/9;5!85!5('/'%9589=&:5 :5S /Z$%8':5('7'!"8.
40!&85 !('5 9?'5 "$B'"$%'5 0B5 !%5 '/0%0-:.5 @%5 @%&$!;5 (0!&5 9(!%8<0(9!9$0%5 !//0=%985B0(5[)5\50B5B('$,?959(!BQ/5!%&5])5\50B5<!88'%,'(59(!BQ/.5@%&$!5?!85
9?'58'/0%&5"!(,'895(0!&5%'9#0(A50B59?'5#0("&I5$95$85%'!(":59#$/'5!85"0%,5!85
3?$%!N
85!%&5$95(!%A858'/0%&50%":5%'C959059?'56UR5KT$,.XHML.5O0#'7'(;50=950B5
)M
Supply chain strategies in emerging markets: an Indian perspective
@%&$!N
85^.^5-$""$0%5A-;50%":5M5\5!('5'C<('885?$,?#!:85!%&5"'8859?!%5?!"B59?'5
(0!&85!('5<!7'&.5GBB59?'5?$,?#!:8;59(!%8<0(9!9$0%5"$%A85 '/0-'57'(:58/!(/'5
905%0%H'C$89'%9.5T$(-85/!%50%":5=8'59(=/A859?!95!('58-!""'(59?!%5[5-'9'(85
KMH!C"'5($,$&59(=/A85!%&58-!""'(L.
T$,=('5X.5U9!9=850B5@%&$!%5(0!&8
U0=(/'I5_OR@;5M`X)
T$,=('5M.5a(0,('8850B5@%&$!%5(0!&8
U0=(/'I5P!8$/5(0!&589!9$89$/850B5@%&$!;5M`XM555
R//'8859059?'5$%9'($0(50B59?'5-!$%"!%&5$85"$-$9'&;5bM\50B59?'5@%&$!%5<0<="!9$0%5 "$7'85 $%5 7$""!,'85 !%&5 -0('5 9?!%5 M)\5 !('5 :'95 905 '5 /0%%'/9'&5 #$9?5
(0!&8.5 4'!/?$%,5 /0%8=-'(5 $%5 (=(!"5 @%&$!5 9?'%5 '/0-'85 !5 /?!""'%,';5 '8<'/$!"":5,$7'%59?!959?$85$85#?'('59?'5%'C95-!(A'95<09'%9$!"5$85'C<'/95905/0-'5
B(0-.5U05?0#5&0'85!5Q(-5,'95$985<(0&=/959059?'5('-09'5@%&$!%57$""!,'8c
)^
Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4
D?'5@%&$!%5(0!&5%'9#0(A5$85%0950%":5$%57'(:5<00(58?!<'V5$95?!85!"805('!/?'&5
$985&'8$,%!9'&5/!<!/$9:.5D?$85="9$-!9'":5('8="985$%57'(:5B('F='%95/0%,'89$0%8.5
D?'5!7'(!,'58<''&50%5@%&$!%5?$,?#!:85$85^`5A-5<'(5?0=(;5#?$/?5$859?(''5
9$-'85 "0#'(5 9?!%5 9?'5 !7'(!,'5 8<''&5 0%5 ?$,?#!:85 $%5 &'7'"0<'&5 /0=%9($'8.5
D?'5?$,?5!7'(!,'5&!$":59(!BQ/570"=-'85$%&$/!9'59?'5=(,'%95%''&5B0(5$-<(07'-'%950B59?'5(0!&5$%B(!89(=/9=('.
U0-'5@%&$!%5U9!9'85?!7'59($'&5905-!%!,'5(0!&5/0%,'89$0%85 :5$%9(0&=/$%,5d9(=/A5/=(B'#8N
;5#?$/?5!('58<'/$Q/5?0=(85&=($%,5#?$/?59(=/A85!('5%095
!""0#'&5905'%9'(59?'5/$9:5"$-$98.5G%/'5!57'?$/"'5-$88'859?'5/=(B'#8;5$95$85?'"&5
!"0%,8$&'59?'5(0!&85=%9$"59?'5%'C95&!:5#?'%5$95#$""5,'959?'5/?!%/'5905'%9'(59?'5
/$9:5"$-$98.5U=/?5<0"$/$'850%":5"'!&5905-0('5&'"!:8.5D05-''959?'5$%B(!89(=/9=(!"5 %''&;5 9?'5 _!9$0%!"5 O$,?#!:85 R=9?0($9:5 0B5 @%&$!5 K_OR@L5 "!=%/?'&5
9?'5_!9$0%!"5O$,?#!:85e'7'"0<-'%95a(0>'/9.5D?$85<(0>'/95?!859?(''5<?!8'8;5
#?$/?5!('5-'!%95905=<,(!&'5!%&5#$&'%59?'5/0=%9(:N
85?$,?#!:5%'9#0(A.5D?'5
Q(895<?!8'5$%/0(<0(!9'859?'5&'7'"0<-'%950B59?'5f0"&'%5g=!&($"!9'(!"5/0%%'/9$%,5e'"?$;5S =- !$;53?'%%!$5!%&5Z0"A!9!.5D?'58'/0%&5<?!8'5$%70"7'85
9?'5&'7'"0<-'%950B59?'5_0(9?HU0=9?5!%&52!89Hh '895"$%A8;5#?$/?5(=%85B(0-5
U($%!,!(5905Z!%:!A=-!($5!%&5B(0-5a0( =%&'(5905U$"/?!(.5D?'59?$(&5<?!8'5
/0%8$89850B59?'5=<,(!&'50B5'C$89$%,5%!9$0%!"5?$,?#!:8.
1.
2.Highly fragmented supplier base
4'!/?$%,5 -!885 -!(A'985 'BB'/9$7'":5 #$""5 ('F=$('5 9?'5 &'7'"0<-'%95 !%&5
0<9$-$J!9$0%50B5&:%!-$/5/?!%%'"85'8<'/$!"":5$%59?'5/="9=(!"5&$7'(8$Q/!9$0%5
"$A'5@%&$!.5@%5-!%:5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'98;50=9"'95<'%'9(!9$0%5$85/?!""'%,$%,5905
!/?$'7'5 '/!=8'50B5B(!,-'%9!9$0%.5@%&$!5B0(5'C!-<"'5?!8580-'9?$%,5$%59?'5
0(&'(50B5-0('59?!%5X^5-$""$0%50=9"'985K9?'56U5 :5/0-<!($80%5?!85B'#'(59?!%5
Y)`;```L.5R859?':5 =$"&5!58=<<":5/?!$%59059!A'59?'$(5 (!%&85!%&5<(0&=/985$%905
9?'5-!$%89('!-50B5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'98;5!""5<"!:'(85-=895A''<59?$85$%5-$%&.
1.3.Complexsystem oftaxes and government regulations
@%&$!%59!C'85!%&5&=9$'85!('5A%0#%5905 '5!5"! :($%9?;5 =959?':5!('5'88'%9$!"5 <!(!-'9'(85 $%5 9?'5 0<9$-$J!9$0%5 0B5 8=<<":5 /?!$%8.5 30(<0(!9'5 9!C5 9('!9-'%95$%5@%&$!57!($'858$,%$Q/!%9":5B(0-5U9!9'5905U9!9';5!85!""5"'7'"850B5,07'(%-'%95?!7'59?'5!=9?0($9:5905"'7:59!C'850%5,00&85!%&58'(7$/'8.5D?'5T'&'(!"5
,07'(%-'%95"'7$'859!C'850%5$%/0-';5$-<0(985KCustom dutiesL;59?'5('%&'($%,5
0B58'(7$/'85(Service Tax) !%&5,00&85-!%=B!/9=('&5$%5@%&$!5(Central Value
Added Tax or cenVAT).5D?'5U9!9'5f07'(%-'%985-!:5/?!(,'59!C'850%5<(0B'88$0%8;50%5<(0<'(9:59(!%8!/9$0%85(Stamp Duty);59?'5iRD50%5$%9(!H89!9'58!"'85
0B5,00&8;59?'53'%9(!"5U!"'85D!C5K3UDL50%5$%9'(H89!9'58!"'850B5,00&85!%&59?'5
State Excise.5j0/!"5 0&$'859!C5<(0<'(9$'8;5Octroi #?'%5,00&85'%9'(59?'5/$9:5
)*
Supply chain strategies in emerging markets: an Indian perspective
"$-$98;5!%&59?'58=<<":5!%&5=8'50B5=9$"$9$'8.5@95$85<('8'%9'&5$%5T$,.^5
T$,=('5^.5U/0<'50B59!C'85$%5@%&$!
U0=(/'I5@%&$!%5D!C5G7'(7$'#;5M`XXI5X`
1.
4.Ineffective usage ofinformation technologies and
communication
a($0(5905XY]`859?'5$%B0(-!9$0%5k0#5 '9#''%5B=%/9$0%!"5!('!85#$9?$%5!%5
0(,!%$J!9$0%5!%&5 '9#''%58=<<":5/?!$%5-'- '(850(,!%$J!9$0%85#'('5d<!<'(N5
!8'&.5 D?'5 d<!<'(N5 !8'&5 9(!%8!/9$0%5 !%&5 /0--=%$/!9$0%5 $85 8"0#.5 e=($%,5
9?$85<'($0&;5$%B0(-!9$0%5#!850B9'%507'(5"00A'&5!85!5/($9$/!"5/0-<'9$9$7'5('80=(/'5 '/!=8'5 $985 7!"='5 905 8=<<":5 /?!$%5 -'- '(85 #!85 %095 /"'!(":5 =%&'(8900&.5 @D5 $%B(!89(=/9=('5 /!<! $"$9$'85 <(07$&'5 !5 /0-<'9$9$7'5 <08$9$0%$%,5 0B5
=8$%'885 $%$9$!9$7'85 "$A'5 /:/"'5 9$-'5 ('&=/9$0%;5 $-<"'-'%9!9$0%;5 $-<"'-'%9$%,5('&'8$,%'&5/(088HB=%/9$0%!"5<(0/'88'8.5D?(''5B!/90(85?!7'589(0%,":5$-<!/9'&59?$85/?!%,'5$%59?'5$-<0(9!%/'50B5$%B0(-!9$0%.5T$(89;58!9$8B:$%,5$%5B!/95
<"'!8$%,5/=890-'(5?!85 '/0-'580-'9?$%,50B5!5/0(<0(!9'50 8'88$0%.5U'(7$%,5
9?'5/=890-'(5$%59?'5 '89;5-0895'BQ/$'%95!%&5'BB'/9$7'5-!%%'(5?!85 '/0-'5
/($9$/!".5U'/0%&5$%B0(-!9$0%5$85!5/(=/$!"5B!/90(5$%59?'5-!%!,'(8N5! $"$9$'85905
('&=/'5 $%7'%90(:5 !%&5 ?=-!%5 ('80=(/'5 ('F=$('-'%95 905 !5 /0-<'9$9$7'5 "'7'".5
D?$(&;5$%B0(-!9$0%5k0#85<"!:85!5/(=/$!"5(0"'5$%589(!9',$/5<"!%%$%,.
2.A concept ofsupply chain management
D?'58=<<":5/?!$%5/0%/'<95$8589$""5%!8/'%95$%5@%&$!.5O0#'7'(;59?'5%''&5B0(5
9?'58!-';5!959?$8589!,';5$85-0('59?!%5'7'(5 'B0('5 '/!=8'50B59?'5/?!""'%,'85
=%"'!8?'&5 0%5 9?'5 /0-<'9$9$7'%'885 0B5 9?'5 @%&$!%5 $%&=89(:5 :5 &'(',="!9$0%5
!%&5,"0 !"$J!9$0%.5R%5'88'%9$!"5Q(89589'<5$%59?'5<(0/'885$85905!88'8859?'5/=(('%958=<<":5/?!$%5/!<! $"$9:5!%&55905,!=,'59?'5/=(('%9589!9'50B58=<<":5/?!$%5
-!%!,'-'%95 $%5 9?'5 @%&$!%5 $%&=89(:.5 @95 $85 9(='5 9?!95 5 !5 ',$%%$%,5 ?!85 ''%5
))
Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4
-!&'5!%&5"!(,'5%=- '(50B5@%&$!%50(,!%$J!9$0%8590&!:5!('5('!"$J$%,59?'5$-<0(9!%/'5 0B5 &'7'"0<$%,5 !%&5 $-<"'-'%9$%,5 !5 /0-<('?'%8$7'5 8=<<":5 /?!$%5
89(!9',:5l5!%&59?'%5"$%A$%,59?!9589(!9',:5905&'"$7'(5 0990-5"$%'5('8="98.
2.
1.Major challenge to adapt existing strategies to the
peculiarities ofthe Indian landscape or design new strategies
from scratch,that are entirely adapted to the local conditions
@%&$!5?!85!59('-'%&0=85-!(A'95<09'%9$!".5@95!"8050BB'(85('-!(A! "'580=(/$%,5 0<<0(9=%$9$'8;5 89(0%,5 "0,$89$/85 !%&5 8=<<":5 /?!$%5 <(0/'88'85 !('5 %'/'88!(:5$%50(&'(59058=<<0(950 >'/9$7'8.5_''&5905/0<'5#$9?5!""59?'5/?!""'%,'850B5
-!%!,$%,5'BB'/9$7'58=<<":5/?!$%8.52-'(,$%,5-!(A'985!('5?09;590&!:5-0('5
9?!%5'7'(.5h ?$"'59?'8'5"0#'(H/0895/0=%9($'85#'('5<'(/'$7'&5 :5-="9$%!9$0%!"5Q(-85!85!%50<<0(9=%$9:5905 '%'Q95B(0-5"! 0=(5/0895!( $9(!,'5$%59?'5<!89;5
9?'59('%&5?!85/?!%,'&.5_'C95905(!&$/!"5/0895('&=/9$0%8;509?'(5A':5B0(/'85!('5
!"805&($7$%,5-="9$%!9$0%!"5/0(<0(!9$0%8590#!(&85,"0 !"$J!9$0%5!%&5'-'(,$%,5
-!(A'98.5D?'8'5!('I5%'#5-!(A'985!%&5,(0#9?50<<0(9=%$9$'8;59'/?%0"0,$/!"5
/!<! $"$9$'8;5!%&5<0"$9$/!"5!%&5-!/(0'/0%0-$/5$%/'%9$7'8.5D?=8;5:'89'(&!:N
85
"0#H/0895/0=%9($'85!('5%0#5 '/0-$%,590-0((0#N
85%'#5-!(A'985!%&589(!9',$/5
"0/!9$0%85 905 9!<5 $%905 "0/!"5 9'/?%0"0,$'85 !%&5 A%0#H?0#.5 O0#'7'(;5 '-'(,$%,5 -!(A'985 ?!7'5 9?'$(5 0#%5 /?!""'%,'8;5 (!%,$%,5 B(0-5 <00(5 <?:8$/!"5 $%B(!89(=/9=(';5$%'C$89'%95&$89($ =9$0%5/?!%%'"85!%&5!5B(!,-'%9'&58=<<"$'(5 !8'5905
!5"!/A50B59(!%8<!('%95(',="!9$0%8.5D?$85/!%5/!=8'5'BB'/9$7'59$-'H9'89'&58=<<":5 /?!$%5 -!%!,'-'%95 <(!/9$/'85 9?!95 #0(A5 $%5 &'7'"0<'&5 /0=%9($'8;5 905 B!$"5
9'(($ ":5#?'%5!<<"$'&5$%5'-'(,$%,5'/0%0-$'8.5
T$,=('5*.5Z':5$-<'(!9$7'8
)[
Supply chain strategies in emerging markets: an Indian perspective
Triple A-rated
@95$85$-<'(!9$7'5905!/?$'7'5!5d9($<"'5RH(!9'&N58=<<":5%'9#0(A5H&'"$7'($%,5
<(0&=/985 9?!95 !('5 !BB0(&! "';5 !7!$"! "';5 !<<'!"$%,.5 D?'8'5 !('5 -0('5 <(0-$%'%9":57$8$ "'5$%59?'5'/0%0-$'85"$A'5@%&$!.5
Skilled labour
D?'5!7!$"! $"$9:50B5F=!"$9:58A$""'&5"! 0=(;5#?'9?'(5$%59?'5/$9$'850(5(=(!"5
!('!8;5$850B9'%5$%58?0(958=<<":.530-<!%$'85-=895/="9$7!9'5!%&5<(0,('88$7'":5
9(!$%59058=//''&5$%5('9!$%$%,5!%&5,(0#$%,5<00"850B58A$""'&5('80=(/'858=<<"'-'%9'&;5#?'('5!<<(0<($!9';5 :58<'/$!"$895'C9'(%!"5'C<'(9$8'5!%&5$%<=9.5@%&$!5
%''&5905/('!9'5!5#'""59(!$%'&5B="":58A$""'&5-!%<0#'(5<00".5a('8'%9":;59?'('5$85
?=,'5&'Q/$'%/:5$%59(!$%$%,5$%89$9=9'85'8<'/$!"":559059(!$%58A$""'&5-!%<0#'(.
Supplyeverybody& everywhere
D?'5(!<$&5=( !%$J!9$0%50B5'-'(,$%,5'/0%0-$'85/('!9'85d$%89!%9N5-!(A'985
9?!95!('5,'0,(!<?$/!"":5/0%/'%9(!9'&.5P=95%'#":5-$&&"'5/"!885/$9:5&#'""'(85
!('57'(:5B!(5B(0-5('<('8'%9$%,59?'5909!"50<<0(9=%$9:.54'!/?$%,59?'589$""5$--'%8'5(=(!"5<0<="!9$0%5$85/($9$/!"5905,(0#9?5!%&5'/0%0-:.
E-Commerce
G%"$%'5$%B0(-!9$0%58?!($%,5$%/('!8'859(!%8<!('%/:;57$8$ $"$9:;58<''&5!%&5
!//=(!/:5$%5-!9'($!"5-07'-'%95!/(08859?'58=<<":5/?!$%.5D?'('5$85!%5=(,'%95
%''&5 0B5 2H30--'(/'5 "0,$89$/85 B0(5 9?'5 '%9'(<($8'5 905 ($%,5 'BQ/$'%/:5 !%&5
'BB'/9$7'%'885$%5-!9'($!"5&'"$7'(:59059?'5/=890-'(.
Fragmentation
@%&$!%5-!(A'95?!85!5B(!,-'%9'&5 !8'5#?'('$%59?'('5!('5"09850B58-!""5905
-$&58$J'5/0-<!%$'85!%&5#?'('5'7'%59?'5 $,5<"!:'(85?!7'589$BB5/0-<'9$9$0%.5
@95$85 '/!=8'50B5&$7'(8$Q/!9$0%5$%5/="9=(';5?! $98;59!89'85'9/.5@95$%&$/!9'859?!95
9?'('5!('5/=890-'(85B0(59?$85&$BB'('%959:<'50B5<(0&=/9.54'!/?$%,5-!885-!(A'985'BB'/9$7'":5#$""5('F=$('59?'5&'7'"0<-'%95!%&50<9$-$J!9$0%50B5&:%!-$/5
/?!%%'"8.5
@%&$!5 $85 /?!(!/9'($J'&5 :5 !5 B(!,-'%9'&5 8=<<"$'(5 !8';5 #$9?5 !5 "095 0B5 $%9'(-'&$!($'85!%&5?=,'5/!<! $"$9$'85&$BB'('%/'85 '9#''%58=<<"$'(8.5D?'5Q(895
90<59$'(58=<<"$'(85!('580<?$89$/!9'&5!%&59?':5/!%5'!8$":5/0-<'9'5#$9?59?'$(5
<''(85 $%5 &'7'"0<'&5 -!(A'98.5 D?':5 B0""0#5 #0("&H/"!885 <(!/9$/'8;5 <088'885
"'!&$%,H'&,'5 9'/?%0"0,$'85 !%&5 !('5 =<H90H&!9'5 #$9?5 9?'5 "!9'895 -!%!,'-'%95
9'/?%$F='8.5 @%&$!5 ?!8;5 $%5 B!/9;5 9?'5 -0895 Q(-85 /0%B'(('&5 #$9?5 9?'5 e'-$%,5
R#!(&50=98$&'51!<!%5!%&5-08950B59?'8'5?!7'5 ''%5!#!(&'&590590<59$'(58=<<"$'(8.5D$'(5M5!%&59$'(5^58=<<"$'(85!('50B9'%5(=(!"5!%&5"!,5B!(50%59?'590<59$'(.5
)b
Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4
!"#$%&"#'($#)!"#
U=//'885&'-!%&85!#!('%'8859?!95!5d0%'58$J'5Q985!""N5!<<(0!/?5$85=%"$A'":5
905#0(A5!%&55!959?'58!-'59$-';5/"08'5!"$,%-'%95#$9?59?'5%''&850B5$%&$7$&=!"5
-!(A'985-=895 '5 !8'&50%58=89!$%! "'5/08959058'(7'.
Grow your own talent
D?'('5$85!5%''&5905"'7'(!,'5!%&5-!9=('5-!%!,'-'%95'C<'($'%/'59?(0=,?5
d0%59?'5,(0=%&N5$%70"7'-'%9.5S !%!,'(859?'-8'"7'85#$""5 '%'Q95B(0-5<'(80%!"5&'7'"0<-'%95!%&5'C<'($'%/'5,!$%'&5!959?'5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'9858?!(<5'%&5
#0(A$%,5/"08'":5#$9?;5!%&5&'7'"0<$%,59?'$(5"0/!"5!%&5(',$0%!"59!"'%9.
Sourcing
U0=(/$%,5 $85 &'Q%'&5 !85 9?'5 '%9$('5 8'95 0B5 =8$%'885 <(0/'88'85 ('F=$('&5 905
<=(/?!8'5,00&85!%&58'(7$/'8.5@%5&0$%,580;5/0-<!%$'85!/F=$('5(!#5-!9'($!"8;5
/0-<0%'%98;5 8'(7$/'8;5 0(5 09?'(5 ('80=(/'85 B(0-5 8=<<"$'(85 905 'C'/=9'5 9?'$(5
0<'(!9$0%8.5 R%5 0(,!%$J!9$0%5 9:<$/!"":5 &'/$&'85 905 80=(/'5 B(0-5 !%5 $%9'(%!9$0%!"5"0/!9$0%5#?'%5$95!&&857!"='5905$985!/9$7$9$'85$%59'(-850B5/089;5F=!"$9:;5
!%&5 9$-'5 0(5 /!<! $"$9:.5 f00&5 80=(/$%,5 &'/$8$0%85 /!%5 "'!&5 905 !5 8$,%$Q/!%95
/0-<'9$9$7'5!&7!%9!,'.5T$(89;5!85Q(-85?!7'5('&=/'&57'(9$/!"5$%9',(!9$0%5!%&5
!859?':5!('5$%/('!8$%,":50=980=(/$%,59?'5-!%=B!/9=($%,50B5/0-<0%'%98;590&!:N
858?!('50B5<=(/?!8'&5<!(985#$9?$%59?'5/08950B5,00&8580"&55$85?$,?'(59?!%5
8'7'(!"5&'/!&'85!,05K3?0<(!;5S '$%&";5M``]I5*XYL.5f00&580=(/$%,5&'/$8$0%85
/!%5 9?'('B0('5 ('8="95 $%5 "0#'(5 /08985 0B5 ,00&85 K0(5 8'(7$/'8L5 80"&.5 U'/0%&":;5
,$7'%59?'5/=(('%95Q%!%/$!"5/($8$8;5!/?$'7$%,5!5"0#5/089589(=/9=('5?!85 '/0-'5
/(=/$!"59059?'58=(7$7!"50B5%=-'(0=85Q(-8.5D0&!:;5-!%:5-="9$%!9$0%!"5-!%=B!/9=($%,5Q(-85!('5"00A$%,5!95@%&$!5!85!5?$,?H<09'%9$!"580=(/$%,50<<0(9=%$9:.5
@95?!85!57'(:5"!(,'5%=- '(50B57'(:5/0-<'9'%9;52%,"$8?H8<'!A$%,5'%,$%''(85
,(!&=!9$%,5'!/?5:'!(V5#$9?5"! 0(5/089859?!95!('50B9'%5>=895!5QB9?50B5#?!959?'$(5
<''(85-!:5/0895$%5&'7'"0<'&5'/0%0-$'8.5
27'%59?'5-0895'C<'($'%/'&580=(/$%,5<(0B'88$0%!"85#$""5 '507'(#?'"-'&5
:59?'58$J';59?'5/0-<"'C$9:5!%&59?'5&$7'(8$9:50B5@%&$!.5m@%59'(-850B5"!#8;59!C!9$0%;5"!%,=!,'8;5/="9=('85!%&509?'(5'"'-'%98;59?'('5'C$8958$,%$Q/!%95&$BB'('%/'85!-0%,59?'57!($0=8589!9'85$%5@%&$!.5D?'('5!"805!('5&$BB'('%/'85!-0%,5
9?'57!($0=85 =8$%'8858'/90(8.5U0580=(/$%,5B(0-5@%&$!5!/9=!"":5%''&85905 '5
9(!%8"!9'&5$%90580=(/$%,5B(0-5!5<!(9$/="!(5<!(950B59?'5/0=%9(:.5U0=(/$%,5B(0-5
@%&$!5 $-<"$'85 /?!%,'85 $%5 9?'5 'C$89$%,5 8=<<":5 /?!$%5 %'9#0(AI5 %'#5 ('"!9$0%8?$<85!('5 =$"95!%&5"$%A'&59059?'5'C$89$%,5%'9#0(A;5#?$"'50 80"'9'5('"!9$0%8?$<85-=895 '5! !%&0%'&.5R%!":J$%,5!580=(/$%,50<<0(9=%$9:5-'('":5B(0-5
!589(!9',$/5<0$%950B57$'#5$85 0=%&5905"'!&5905=%'C<'/9'&50=9/0-'8;58=/?5!85
9?'5?$&&'%5/089850B5-!9/?$%,5!%&5/00(&$%!9$%,5<(0/'88'8;5!%&59?'5('80=(/'85
%''&'&5905"'7'(!,'5:0=(5Q(-N
85/0-<'9'%/'85$%50(&'(5905 ($%,5:0=(5@%&$!%5
8=<<"$'(85 =<5 905 :0=5 'C<'/9!9$0%8.5 5 @%5 90&!:N
85 '/0%0-:;5 <(07$&$%,5 !5 ,00&5
)]
Supply chain strategies in emerging markets: an Indian perspective
<(0&=/95#$9?59?'5($,?95B'!9=('85$85%05"0%,'(58=BQ/$'%9.5P(!%&5$-!,'5!%&59?'5
#!:5 9?'5 <(0&=/95 $85 <'(/'$7'&5 :5 9?'5 '%&H=8'(85 !('5 $%/('!8$%,":5 $%k='%/$%,5/0%8=-'(8N5 '?!7$0(.5_$A'5"'!(%'&59?$85"'880%59?'5?!(&5#!:.5D?'5_$A'5
8#008?5?!850B9'%5B!/'&5/($9$/$8-5B0(5=8'50B5/?$"&5"! 0(;5&='5905<(0&=/9$0%5
/0%9(!/9859?!95#'('5,$7'%5905/0-<!%$'859?!950<'(!9'5$%5!('!85#?'('5$%!&'F=!9'5(',="!9$0%85!%&5-0%$90($%,5-!A'85$95?!(&5905!8/'(9!$%59?!95/?$"&5"! 0(5
$85%095=8'&.5h ?'%580=(/$%,5B(0-5@%&$!;5$95$859?'('B0('5/(=/$!"5905A%0#5:0=(5
8=<<"$'(859?(0=,?5!%&59?(0=,?;5!%&5905-!A'58=('59?!959?':5/0-<":5#$9?5!""5
89!%&!(&85!%&5(',="!9$0%8.5
j00A$%,5B0(58=<<"$'(857$!5#' H8'!(/?;5'H-!$"85!%&5<?0%'5/!""85/!%5?!(-5
:0=(5 =8$%'88;58$-<":5 '/!=8'5/0-<!%$'859?!95!('5F=!"$Q'&5-!:5%095('8<0%&V
5
9?':5 !('5 0B9'%5 9005 =8:5 /?!8$%,5 #?!95 9?':5 /0%8$&'(5 905 '5 ('!"5 <(08<'/98.5
D?'('B0(';5/?!%/'85!('59?!959?'5('8<0%8'5:0=5-!:5,'9;5/0-'85B(0-5!5/0-<!%:59?!95$85<00(":5(=%5905,'95 =8$%'8850%59?'$(50#%.5G(5$95-!:5/0-'5B(0-5
80-'5$%9'(-'&$!(:5#?05&0'85%0950#%5!%:5B!/$"$9$'850B5$9850#%;5$%5#?$/?5/!8'5
:0=5#0="&5 '5?!7$%,5%05!//'8859059?'5!/9=!"580=(/'8.5
30%/"=8$7'":;580=(/$%,5B(0-5@%&$!50BB'(85-!%:50<<0(9=%$9$'8.5O0#'7'(;5
9?'5/?!""'%,'85!('5!"8059?'('.5D?':5/!%5 '5 09?5'C9'(%!"5K"0,$89$/85/?!""'%,'8;5"!/A50B5F=!"$9:5!%&59(!%8<!('%/:5!959?'58=<<"$'(N
85'%&;L5!%&5$%9'(%!"5905
9?'5Q(-5K"!/A50B5A%0#"'&,'5! 0=95@%&$!5!959?'5/0(<0(!9'5"'7'";58?0(9!,'50B5
"0/!"580=(/$%,.5O0#'7'(;59?'8'50 89!/"'85/!%5 '507'(/0-';59?0=,?5$950B9'%5
('F=$('85/('!9$7'59?$%A$%,5!%&5"0/!"5$%%07!9$0%8.5
T$,=('5).5e'8$(! "'5B0/=8
U0=(/'I5G#%589=&:
a('8'%9":;59?'5$%&=89(:5!%&58=<<":5/?!$%5-!%!,'-'%95$85B0/=8'&50%5/$9$'85
!%&58!9'""$9'8589!9$0%85!%&59?':5!('5:'95905'C<"0('59?'5?=,'5-!(A'95!#!$9$%,5
$%5 9?'5 (=(!"5 !('!85 0B5 @%&$!.5 R 0=95 bM.M\5 0B5 9?'5 <0<="!9$0%5 "$7'85 $%5 80-'5
[^];```57$""!,'85!%&59?'5('895Mb.]\5$%5! 0=95);*]`590#%85!%&5=( !%5!,,"0-'(!9$0%8.5@95-'!%859?!95!<<(0C.5XM\50B5#0("&5<0<="!9$0%5$85"$7$%,5$%5(=(!"5
!('!50B5@%&$!5!%&59?$85$85:'95905 '59!<<'&5 :5'BB'/9$7'5!%&589!9'5$B5!(958=<<":5
/?!$%5-!%!,'-'%9E'C<'(98.5
)Y
Forum Scientiae Oeconomia Volume 2 (2014) No. 4
3.An approach: effective supply chain
@95$85$-<'(!9$7'59?!95@%&$!5%''&5905&'7'"0<59?'5($,?958=<<":5/?!$%5B0(58=//'885$%5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'9850B59?'5B=9=('.5D?'('5!('59?(''5A':5!('!85#?$/?5!('5
('F=$('&5905 '5!&&('88'&.
Developinga triple A-rated supplychain
D?'5 $,,'895 /?!""'%,'5 B0(5 8=<<":5 /?!$%5 '-'(,$%,5 -!(A'985 $85 905 '%8=('5
9?!959?'$(5<(0&=/95$85!//'<9! "'59059?'5/0%8=-'(85!%&5!959?'58!-'59$-'5$95$85
!//'<9! "'5!%&5!7!$"! "'5.5@%57$'#50B5?=,'5B(!,-'%9!9$0%55%!9=('50B58=<<":5
!8'5!%&5! $"$9:5905<=(/?!8'5<(0&=/950B50#%5/?0$/';5/"$'%9855?!7'5=%"$-$9'&5
/?0$/'5B(0-5/?'!<5905/089":5<(0&=/98.5O0#'7'(;5="9$-!9'":5#?!95#$""5-!99'(5
9?'5!<<'!";5!BB0(&! $"$9:5!%&5!7!$"! $"$9: Kf'"&!(&;5M`XXL.5
How should an effectivelyre-engineered channel perform?
D05!/?$'7'58=//'88;59?'5!<<(0!/?5905<(0&=/95<0(9B0"$05#$""5-$,(!9';5B(0-5
d "!%A'9N5905 <('/$8$0%;5 9?(0=,?5 B0/=85 <(0&=/985 !%&5 d-=895 890/AN5$9'-85 8=<<0(9'&5 :5#'""5'C'/=9'&5<(0-09$0%8.5D?'('5$85%058/0<'50B5/0-<"!/'%/:5$B5
8=<('-!/:5$85905 '5!/?$'7'&5$%59?'5-!(A'9.5
D05!/?$'7'59?'5-!9=('5-!(A'95"'7'"850B58=<<":5/?!$%57$8$ $"$9:5('F=$('85
(!&$/!"5('!<<(!$8!"50B5/=(('%958:89'-5!%&5!<<(0!/?'8.5Z%0#"'&,'59!"'%95$%5
9?'58:89'-5-=895 '5/!<9=('&;5$%9'(<('9'&5!%&5"'7'(!,'&5!85<'(59?'5"0/!"5/0%&$9$0%85!%&59!(,'95-!(A'9.
D05 '5'BB'/9$7';59'/?%0"0,:5 !8'&50%5B!895!%&59(!%8<!('%95/0--=%$/!9$0%5
8?0="&5 '5&'7'"0<'&5B0(5!%!":8$%,59?'58!"'85!/9$7$9$'85!%&5&!9!5B0(5/"'!(5=%&'(89!%&$%,50B5-!(A'95!8<'/98.
[`
Supply chain strategies in emerging markets: an Indian perspective
*+(+,"#-#.,))'!/#0%$(,%1+(%)!#2)0"3
D?$85 ',$%85#$9?58'"'/9$%,59?'5/?!%%'"50<9$0%85#$8'":;5$%50(&'(5905-$%$-$J'5/089H90H8'(7'5!%&5<(09'/95-!(,$%8 @95$85$-<'(!9$7'59?!958=<<":5/?!$%5
$%59?'5'-'(,$%,5-!(A'958?0="&5?!7'5"!895-$"'57$8$ $"$9:.530%8=-'(85$%59?'5
<('8'%958/'%!($05!('5$%5%05-00&5905?!7'5=%/'(9!$%9:5$%5&'"$7'(:5
Conclusions
@%&$!5?!85!5?=,'5,(0#9?50<<0(9=%$9$'85 =95!959?'58!-'59$-'5$95?!85$9850#%5
/?!""'%,'8.56%"$A'5$%59?'5&'7'"0<'&5'/0%0-$'8;5<"=,5!%&5<"!:58=<<":5/?!$%55
$85=%"$A'":5905 '58=//'88B="5$%5@%&$!.5a"!%%'(85%''&5905=%&'(89!%&59?'5"0/!"5
$-<'(!9$7'85!%&5"'7'(!,'59?'-59059?'$(5!&7!%9!,'8.5D?':5!"805%''&5905?!7'5
89(!9',:5 905 !"!%/'5 9?'5 'C9'%95 0B5 "0/!"$8!9$0%5 $%5 0(&'(5 905 8=//''&5 $%5 9?'8'5
=%<('&$/9! "'5!%&5$%&$7$&=!"5=%$F='5-!(A'98.5
T0(59?'5<=(<08'50B52S 24f@_f5S R4Z2D589(!9',:5$%5@%&$!;5#'5%''&5
905/0%8$&'(5$95 '$%,55!5?'9'(0,'%'0=85%!9$0%.52!/?589!9'5?!85$9850#%5/="9=(';5
(="'85!%&5(',="!9$0%8;5"!%,=!,'85!%&5<('B'('%/'85B0(5<(0&=/985!%&58'(7$/'8.5
D?'('5 $85 !5 %'/'88$9:5 905 $%9',(!9'5 9?'5 ,"0 !"5 0<'(!9$0%85 #$9?5 "0/!"5 8=<<":5
/?!$%5 ('"!9$0%8?$<5 !%&5 9?'(' :5 '89! "$8?5 !5 /0- $%'&5 -0&'5 0B5 8=89!$%! "'5
[X
