Peer-review form

STUDIA REGIONALIA
Editor in Chief
JOURNAL
JOURNAL OF
OF THE
THE POLISH
POLISH ACADEMY
ACADEMY OF
OF SCIENCES,
SCIENCES,
COMMITTEE
COMMITTEE FOR
FOR SPATIAL
SPATIAL ECONOMY
ECONOMY AND
AND REGIONAL
REGIONAL PLANNING
PLANNING
&
& EUROPEAN
EUROPEAN REGIONAL
REGIONAL SCIENCE
SCIENCE ASSOCIATION
ASSOCIATION (ERSA)
(ERSA) POLISH
POLISH SECTION
SECTION
SCIENTIFIC JOURNAL PAPER PEER-REVIEW FORM
Title: [filled in by the editorial office]
The manuscript (Please, underline your judgement):
- should be considered for publication
- should be considered for publication, however it needs clarifications/amendments
- may be considered for possible re-submission in case it is significantly altered
- should not be considered for publication
General comments:
This is a cross-cutting commentary to the paper that should particularly focus on identifying the
possible add value of the article to regional science. Ideally, it should refer the paper to international
state-of-the art. The general comments are mainly for the editors of the journal and should allow the
maintenance of highest scientific professional standards of the journal. Recommended length – 100
words.
Specific comments to the author(s):
This is a commentary addressing the main advantages and disadvantages of the provided paper with
regards to theoretical framework, methods and investigation results. These are the obligatory fields of
revision, however it should have a disciplinary and enhancing function, especially for improvements of
the research in regional science. Recommended length – at least 150 words.
Editor-in-chief: Tadeusz Markowski
Co-editors: Paulina Legutko-Kobus (KPZK PAN), Artur Ochojski (ERSA)
KOM ITET PRZESTRZENNEGO
ZAGOSPODAROWANIA KRAJU
PAN
COMMITTEE FOR SPATIAL ECONOMY
AND REGIONAL PLANNING
POLISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
Pałac Kultury i Nauki, p. 2308, 00-901 Warszawa, pl. Defilad 1
website: kpzk.pan.pl | e-mail: [email protected]
EUROPEAN REGIONAL SCIENCE ASSOCIATION
- SEKCJA POLSKA
POLISH SECTION OF ERSA / RSAI
ul. Długa 44/50, 00-241 Warszawa
website: ersa.org.pl | e-mail: [email protected]